3 ms·
So far as I can tell from the literature, nobody has licked the user-generated stories thing. (Well, Eve has, in the sense that they basically built a sandbox
by jacques_chester 14y ago
So far as I can tell from the literature, nobody has licked the user-generated stories thing.
(Well, Eve has, in the sense that they basically built a sandbox and charge for time in it.)
There's lots of literature on building plots ahead of time. The only project that's come close to doing anything in JIT plots was Façade, and that still relied on picking plot elements based on an overall dramatic arc in a very limited scenario. It also required enormous manual work to reach a usable state. (Look up the papers though, they're fascinating).
The basic problem is this: in an AOT plot generator, your system controls all the elements. Every character is controllable, every plot twist is controllable and so on.
Add humans and things get wildly out hand, because human players are thoroughly unpredictable.
So either you "railroad" the player, which destroys agency and the suspension of disbelief. Or you produce what is essentially random events, which destroys agency but might preserve the suspension of disbelief. Neither alternative is very satisfying.
What's wanted is a system that reacts to player actions, constantly replanning current events to satisfy a general plot arc.
I looked at doing JIT, automatic, reactive plot generation as an honours project but it's simply too big for a 1-year project.
Basically pen-and-paper RPGs with a smart, inscrutable GM are still going to be the state of the art on this for some time yet.
(Email me if you want the crappy preliminary research I did on this topic)
- elithrar 14y ago> So far as I can tell from the literature, nobody has licked the user-generated stories thing. Cryptic's new "Neverwinter" MMO aims to do this. How effective it will be is another thing entirely.
- jacques_chester 14y agoPretty much everyone aims to do it. The publicity for just about every CRPG ever made, whether single player or MMO, talks about how amazingly immersive and dynamic and reactive it's going to be. So forgive me if I propose to wait and see :D The thing is that you can go a long way with a sufficiently large, dense story graph. That's the direction that single-player CRPGs have moved in. But it's obviously a non-starter for MMOs.