6 ms·
As Families Change, Korea’s Elderly Are Turning to Suicide
- tokenadult 14y agoThis, by the way, is one of the reasons that the aggregate national suicide rate in Korea (and also in Japan) exceeds the aggregate national suicide rate in the United States. The elderly (persons born before the end of the Korean War, and especially before the end of World War II) in those countries kill themselves at a much higher rate than the same birth cohort in the United States. On the other hand, rates of YOUTH suicide in recent decades have been much more comparable among those countries, and once when I checked in the 1990s, looking up World Health Organisation statistics, the youth suicide rate in the United States was actually higher than that in Japan. So some of the international comparisons in suicide rates have to take a careful look at cohort effects (rates specific to a particular era of birth) to better tease out hypotheses for the causes of differing rates of suicide. This is an old issue all over the world, including in east Asia, the issue of children growing up and taking care of themselves and their children rather than their elderly parents. A comment on Hacker News (as I recall) recently mentioned the 1953 Japanese movie Tokyo Story (東京物語), which I began watching on a DVD from the public library last night. Yes, even in 1953 in early postwar Japan, families had to adjust to children not necessarily being by the side of their parents as the parents grew old.
- abrowne 14y agoSeconding Ozu's Tokyo Story. You can watch it for free on Hulu today – I assume only in the US – along with the rest of the Criterion Collection: <http://www.hulu.com/watch/215840> http://www.hulu.com/watch/215840>.
- genwin 14y agoMaybe a few centuries from now our major societies will no longer rely on population growth. The consequences of this unsustainable approach won't be pretty. My kid will be expected to financially support at least two retirees via Social Security contributions and pay back a chunk of those borrowed $trillions.
- kaonashi 14y agoYour kid will have to support retirees through the output of his labor; the labor required to support a person is dropping , and soon it can be completely automated. The financial economy is a heuristic to explain the underlying economic conditions, not vice-versa.
- crusso 14y agoThe problem is that "support a person" is also a moving target that is ever inflating. Additionally, distribution inefficiencies (whether you're inclined to believe the bad actors are big government, corporations, or the "1%") also keep moving that target. Look at it this way. Per-capita GDP has gone up over time yet poverty rates have stayed fairly fixed over the last 40 years. See also processor speed vs desktop snappiness over time for a similar example of where the underlying performance drivers may look great but the end result appears to stay the same.
- dublinben 14y agoPoverty is a percentage, not an absolute measure. It will never be eliminated as long as there is a distribution of income.
- crusso 14y agoIt's not a specific percentage because it does fluctuate (not going to look up what it's based on just now), but effectively it will never be eliminated. This is precisely my point to the original poster who postulated that increases in worker productivity were making it easier to support those not working.
- genwin 14y agoAs labor is automated there will be increasing downward pressure on my kid's wages and job prospects. Harder work will be required to pay the taxes that are increased to make up for the falling wages.
- matterhorn 14y agoCertainly, when individuals vote to turn over personal responsibilities to the the government, things will turn out badly in the end. However, the break down of personal responsibilities within families is not the result of economic success. Has the article's author considered their implied message - that if only Koreans had experienced economic failure, then everybody would just happy as pigs in slop? That's absurd, of course, as their northern neighbors provide the perfect example for the comparison. If there is a breakdown in familial responsibilities, it is not likely to be the result of economic success. Many people around the world work not just in a distant city, but in a distant country in order to send the fruits of higher earnings home to family - so it is not reasonable to assume that moving to a different city somehow forces a person to lose their sense of familial responsibility. If such a breakdown is occurring, the explanation for its cause lies somewhere other than economic success.
- old-gregg 14y ago> turn over personal responsibilities to the the government Sounds like the modern states are doing a much poorer job caring for their members than a prehistoric tribes used to. At least the tribes provided their members with 4 basic benefits like to hunt together (defense), resolve disputes (justice/law), care of elderly (pensions) and wounded (healthcare). It absolutely blows my mind that someone would consider any of the 4 to be "personal responsibility". Frankly, I find it absurd to pay money for a lawyer to win in court. In my mind that's an equivalent of out-spending your opponent on a personal army and just taking what you need by force. Pensions are not personal responsibility. And California state workers are happy to agree with me, that's why they tax pensionless private sector workers to help themselves with a "state pension". And nobody is protesting against this outrageous behavior... Weird. Where are the burning cars and shattered storefronts?
- WalterBright 14y agoPrehistoric societies would send their elderly out into the snow to die once they were no longer productive members of the tribe. Nomadic tribes would simply leave behind the elderly who couldn't keep up any more. It wasn't so much that they were heartless - they simply did not have the resources to do otherwise.
- brenfrow 14y agoHmm... welcome to life as an American.
- wiradikusuma 14y agoreminds me of a TV ad for Chinese New Year from Petronas, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M3NDaZ2p6ug http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M3NDaZ2p6ug (see the poster's comment for English translation).
- wildranter 14y agoPeople are killing themselves because no one cares about them and some while people discuss the economics of that. Is humanity really that fucked up?
- fakeer 14y agoBeen to Korea 4 times. To work(read slave off by choice), while my visa was business. On whichever weekend I was left alone by my firm I spent it in travelling around, trying things out, meeting people and trying to strike a conversation. Elderly people were extremely polite and courteous and extremely reserved too. Maybe because of the huge language barrier(any language other than Korean has very limited reception in Korea) which is IMHO, though very difficult for me, something South Koreans should be proud of - being self sufficient without English(the colonial hangover) which has crept into social DNA everywhere else. Yes, the 'family' seems to be non-existent in Korea now, following the western tracks. This assumption is based upon external observation and talking to my Korean guest-house people, some staff who are from India/Pakistan/Nepal(either Korean citizens now or having lived their long), colleagues(friends let's say) who ever opened up on such matters(usually after a few drinks). I can confirm that after a few drinks every society becomes one and social taboos are duly fd off. Most open were(once they are open) Korean females friends I have known their, whether met in office or outside - they talked very animatedly about their parents and how they don't find time for each other and most likely will never find it. They also are worried whether their own state is going to be worse than this. Here's the last line of the article, "When I see these old people, I see how my own generation will die.". One answer was common. Your parents bring you up till you get your job and are on your feet, after that you are on your own. And they(parents) are on their own too! They usually spend their time in shops alone and sitting alone in those park benches with those stoic faces. A very healthy life style/food makes the matters worse(as in loneliness) as the life expectancy is quite high in SK. Maybe that's a saving grace in India(my country) as families are slowly disappearing here too, and/or turning into dysfunctional arrangements which is not even a distant resemblance of glorious old Indian family. As for social care - politicians are very corrupt and do surpass even US standards. In US at least even heavyweights get long imprisonments. In Korea they get parliamentary pardon. Nobody cares about national elderly population(besides, just paying bills is hardly they want/need). So, while everyone is busy taking share prices higher and higher and building new things, the last generation - which is no longer a workforce - is left behind in the race; mercilessly abandoned.
- Turing_Machine 14y ago"without English(the colonial hangover)" Korea was never colonized by English-speakers, as far as I know. Japanese, yes.
- chadcf 14y agoThis is something I've been thinking about in the good old USA too. Throughout most of history elderly relied on family to take care of them, but modern society often has families spread out over great distances and children not prepared or expecting to have to care for their parents, and with people living longer than ever it becomes much more of a job to care for your parents. Combine that with the fact that pensions are becoming increasingly rare and social security benefits are likely to be cut at some point in the future, and you have the potential for a massive increase in elderly living below the poverty line with no one to care for them. Even if you prepare and save, that's no guarantee as the recent economic troubles demonstrated, with many people nearing retirement seeing massive decreases in their investments. Not to mention, with the skyrocketing costs of college tuition and wages that have not kept up with inflation, adequately saving for retirement has become increasingly difficult as well. I'm not sure what's going to happen but I don't see the future as being that promising as we age and quite frankly, I can see a lot of seniors turning to suicide when whatever meager savings they have run out. I hope I'm wrong, but it looks quite bleak...
- pmorici 14y ago"adequately saving for retirement has become increasingly difficult" Is that true or is it just a shift in culture where people blow all their money on crap they don't need, disposable convenience, and live a more "up-scale" life style instead of saving for retirement? I was reading a few blogs about early retirement the other day such as, http://www.mrmoneymustache.com/2011/04/06/meet-mr-money-mustache/ http://www.mrmoneymustache.com/2011/04/06/meet-mr-money-must... The financial situations vary widely but the common theme is they save a lot more of their income % wise than a typical person. The guy that writes the above blog retired at 30. Those are extreme examples but surely if that is possible then retiring after working until 60+ isn't particularly out of reach.
- svachalek 14y agoSuppose you're going to live until 90. That's 60 years of retirement. Suppose you're given up on the whole materialism treadmill and are willing to live close to the poverty line, say $25000 per year. That still works out to $1.5M. How many people even make $1.5M by the time they're 30, even before taxes? And that's to live more or less in poverty.
- uvdiv 14y agoThis is a severe abuse of statistics. They are succeeding at alarming rates; the suicides among people 65 or older ballooned to 4,378 in 2010, from 1,161 in 2000. The are absolute counts, not rates. The male 65+ population went up 70% in the same period, and the 75+ subgroup doubled [1]. This explains away much of the increase (c.f. generic statistics in [2]). And at the same time: The number of suicides among other adults and teenagers also surged... (no numbers) Is it even clear the age-normalized suicide rate increased at all among the elderly, relative to the general population? I don't think the journalist checked. edit: BBC says Korea's general-population suicide "more than doubled" over the same period [3]. So the 65+ suicide rate is almost completely explained by the null hypothesis. The count of 65+ suicides went up by 3.77x; the male 65+ population increased by 1.68x, and the general population suicide rate by >2.0x, which together is a factor of 3.36x. That leaves a <12% increase in [65+ suicide rate]/[general population suicide rate] (I'm still ignoring (rare [2]) female suicides). In a better analysis this might completely disappear. E.g. the 75+ subgroup outgrew the 65+ subgroup and they are much more suicidal [2], but I don't know how much more. [1] http://www.census.gov/population/international/data/idb/region.php?N=%20Results%20&T=10&A=separate&RT=0&Y=2000,2010&R=-1&C=KS http://www.census.gov/population/international/data/idb/regi... [2] http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5236508 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5236508 [3] http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-pacific-14784776 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-pacific-14784776
- accountswu 14y ago<i>This is a severe abuse of statistics.</i> I don't think that's the case if I am reading your numbers right; the suicide rate among 65 or older in 2010 is 377% of the rate in 2000. The population increase of 65 or older only went up 70% (i.e. is 170% of the population in 2000).
- azakai 14y agoTotally correct. Also, it seemed odd not to compare to suicide rates in other countries - was it low before and typical now? Or typical before and high now? We can't tell from the article. There might be substance in the topic, but the numbers presented don't support it.