12 ms·
Your Lifestyle Has Already Been Designed (2010)
- whichdan 14y agoI can certainly relate to this. Living in Boston, it's very easy to drop $50++ just walking around the city for an afternoon, then to come home and spend $100 for half a week's worth of groceries at Whole Foods. I definitely wish each raise came with the option to work less.. 10% more money or 10% less work. When you consider that, on paper, a 20% pay cut could mean a 3-day weekend, it makes a lot of sense until you bring it up in conversation..
- marknutter 14y ago> Whole Foods That's your problem right there
- oftenwrong 14y agoWhole Foods is a great example of a lure set up to get people to impulsively spend more money than necessary. Their basic staples are often priced similarly to other grocery chains, but when you shop there you will also pass by all the fancy, awesome, expensive foods too. It is hard to resist, especially if you are shopping hungry on your way home after a long day at work.
- graue 14y agoWhen I was on a tight budget as a student in DC, I loved Whole Foods. Stuff like natural peanut butter and bread was actually cheaper than other grocery stores (for the same quality), and I had no problem resisting the expensive stuff. They also had a well-stocked bulk aisle for cook-at-home staples, and cheap bagels (69¢ as I recall) that you could take to the seating area and toast them yourself. I think they might position themselves differently depending on the region, because in the midwest I had a totally different experience. There, prices were universally high at Whole Foods.
- mhartl 14y agoI'm sure I'm not the only one who routinely calls it "Whole Paycheck".
- ErikAugust 14y agoTrader Joe's. Used to do Shaw's + co-ops when I lived in Vermont. That was around $160 a week. Now, in Boston, I pay about $100 total at Trader Joe's (for more groceries). 40% decrease - around $3120 per year in savings. Random note: you can live in Boston for about the same cost as Burlington, Vermont. Something is crazy about that.
- whichdan 14y agoI love Trader Joe's, but the only one I know of is downtown. That means 20 minutes extra each way, plus a little under $4 for the T. Whole Foods is a quick ten minute walk.
- jplewicke 14y agoThere's also two in Cambridge (one by Fresh Pond and one on Mem Drive near the BU bridge) and one in Coolidge Corner in Brookline.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- graue 14y agoI've never been impressed with Trader Joe's fresh produce, though, and almost everything I buy is produce or bulk staples (rice, lentils, beans, oats). TJ's seems to specialize in frozen and snack foods.
- eCa 14y ago> The economy would collapse and never recover. That is exactly what I said (at my 40-hour/week job) would happen if everyone were like me. More seriously, I've come to the same conclusion. Our entire society is built on the consumption of junk. Expensive gadgets with a built-in expiration date (either by breaking easily or technology deprecation).
- einhverfr 14y agoI think the key problem is that such consumption isn't sustainable. Sooner or later you run into the fact that we can't keep running on this treadmill and pushing the costs on down. It seems to me that the call to action should be building a new economy, one of free individuals guided by a truly free market, because as the article demonstrates the market is hardly free at the moment.
- scarecrowbob 14y agoIs it possible that, by definition, a "market" has controls on it that make the term "free mark" an oxymoron?
- einhverfr 14y agoI think the question of a free market is a question of who has power in the market. We'd say a communist "marketplace" isn't free because the power is concentrated in the hands of the state, but the same must surely be true in a marketplace run by a non-state monopoly. I would define a marketplace as free if and only if the primary power rests with the purchasers.
- rayiner 14y agoI'm always a bit surprised that people are surprised to discover this. You know the experiments where monkeys will do things for grapes or tokens? That, writ large, is human society. The feelings we get making and spending money, and the feelings we get comparing our ability to do that to other people, satisfies a deep biological need in our primate selves.
- pm90 14y agoI think you've hit on an important point here which the article has missed. Peer-pressure is responsible for most of the unwanted consumption that the author mentions. If we lived in a society where reading and debating on books was considered an accepted and revered social activity, then we would have many more people reading books than (say) watching sports. I don't really blame most people for having that kind of feeling (we are humans after all) but it does help to sometimes take a step back and ask ourselves why we live our life the way we do. Ben Franklin used that kind of peer-pressure to learn new skills so it can be used for doing good too
- addlepate 14y agoAgreed, it shows that a person really hasn't thought through all this before. Unexamined life and all that.
- iuguy 14y agoAt Mandalorian we generally have to work the standard work week when doing stuff for clients, but beyond that people manage their own time, often spending bits of time here or there to do the school run, take their kids to the doctors or as happened for the last two weeks, one of our consultants taking half days off every day while they get their new house sorted out. I find that a results oriented work environment seems to make for happier employees.
- iuguy 14y agoIncidentally the article references a Book and Documentary both called "The Corporation" by Joel Bakan. The book[1] is an excellent read and the documentary[2] is also worth a watch, free on archive.org. [1] - http://www.amazon.co.uk/Corporation-Pathological-Pursuit-Profit-Power/dp/1845291743/ref=sr_1_1?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1361117603&sr=1-1 http://www.amazon.co.uk/Corporation-Pathological-Pursuit-Pro... [2] - http://archive.org/details/The_Corporation_ http://archive.org/details/The_Corporation_
- mgkimsal 14y ago"Can you imagine what would happen if all of America stopped buying so much unnecessary fluff that doesn’t add a lot of lasting value to our lives? The economy would collapse and never recover." I used to think this, but I don't believe that so much any more. It would take a hit, but would adjust to people spending more time and money on things that mattered more to them - the things that take more money to do, vs the $5-$10 impulse purchases on things of limited value. What things might those be? Travel? More energy efficient housing/appliances? More experience-oriented stuff in general (time with family/friends/etc)
- Rustan 14y agoOr just the same types of things, but in lower quantities and with higher quality, to a higher price. It is not strange to buy toys for kids, but buying crap that is added to already large piles of crap and used just a few times is just bad for all humans and the environment (with the only "positive" being short-time profit for the consumer industries).
- KaoruAoiShiho 14y agoI'm not an economist so I don't want to state things with too much certainty, but I'm honestly flabbergasted that smart people would say things like this. No it wouldn't, economic activity's not just going to disappear, the money will be reinvested into other things like education or venture or be redistributed through taxes or charity and so on.
- barrkel 14y agoThe nominal value of GDP is intimately related with the velocity of money, and that in turn depends on transactions; the more of them, and the higher their value, the bigger the GDP. The longer money stays in anyone's pockets or bank account before being transferred elsewhere, the lower the GDP. Nominal GDP would definitely fall when people move their time "spending" from labour transactions (i.e. working hours) that add to GDP, to spending time instead. So if you measure economic activity by GDP, this alternate working approach would appear to "collapse" the economy. And the degree to which people who make desirable "stuff" also subscribe to this new lifestyle, the more expensive that stuff will become. Supply is reduced, therefore the price will rise until demand falls and supply rises (because the price is higher) to match one another. In effect, a population following this approach will have lower purchasing power for desirable stuff than a control population stuck in the rat race. Or to put it another way, they will be poorer, and may suffer from envy. So IMO the approach is currently only realistic for a certain subset of the population - those whose labour is valuable enough - and hopefully doesn't spread to factory workers etc. Ideally factory workers will be replaced by robots, so that we no longer have to worry about using up human lives to feed the "stuff" production machine. (By factory workers, I mean everyone who makes commodity (not bespoke) "stuff" you can touch.) But I can certainly see a future where unskilled labour, and a lot of skilled labour, is done by machines. A capitalist economy based on scarcity won't work so well then; democracy won't stand for it.
- gte910h 14y agoThe REAL issue with this is the high cost of N employees vs just hour per employee. Training, health insurance, etc If we could drop it so everyone worked 30 hours but worked 75% of what they do today, many would jump at it in the higher earning echelons. Per worker costs strongly incentivise long weeks.
- walshemj 14y agowork (excluding production line blue collar jobs) expands to take up the hours worked for example back in the 70's the Uk went to a 3 day week during the power strikes funnily the output of the country did not go down by 3/5.
- hrabago 14y agoPerhaps the overhead could be considered as part of the overall costs. I would still appreciate the choice of having to work 75% of the time for 65% pay if I understood that the difference was due to health coverage and other benefits. In other words, the transparency would help. I strongly believe I'd still sign up for it.
- gte910h 14y agoI'd just prefer to see medical benefits untie from employers (not for moral, but for reducing worker overhead reasons). Additionally, under the current sphere 'part time' workers don't usually get company benefits.
- sliverstorm 14y agoNot to mention, industries with a shortage of quality workers would necessarily contract.
- graue 14y agoThis assumes a linear relationship between hours worked and amount accomplished. I doubt such a relationship holds after 5 or 6 hours. I bet many programmers would get more done in a 6-hour day than an 8-hour day, due to increased energy.
- keithpeter 14y agoNicely written piece. I like the progression from the author's observation about his backpacking trip; the contrast with his regained 9 to 5 day, and the realisation that consumption is driving the whole whirlygig. Reminded me of Tom Hodgkinson's The Idler http://idler.co.uk/magazine/ http://idler.co.uk/magazine/ "It's amazing how much you can get done in twenty minutes if twenty minutes is all you have. But if you have all afternoon, it would probably take way longer." I've just relearned that lesson; we have come through a very busy time at work and things just had to get done in minutes, right now. It worked and the sky did not fall.
- hrabago 14y agoIt isn't always sustainable, though. You do this long enough and a lot of people would start burning out. Certainly there are people who would thrive in an ongoing high-stress environment, but not everyone is built like that, or would want to stay in such a situation for long. The occasional case of high stress, high productivity periods can be good for that feeling of accomplishment once the deadline is met. It's like the climactic ending of an action movie - a lot of activity leading up to a desired goal. However once the next chapter begins, you want to go back to a sense of normalcy, when people can recover and just relish the recent accomplishment.
- keithpeter 14y agoOh, yes, I agree completely, there is a need for peaks and troughs. What I learned last week however is that certain fairly mundane documentation and planning tasks can actually be completed in much less time than I have usually allocated to them (the domain is not IT or computing by the way).
- marknutter 14y agoYet there are those of us who enjoy our jobs and don't mind spending 40 hours a week doing something fulfilling, and who look forward to exercising and don't look at it like a chore, or who take great pleasure in saving money and being frugal.
- scribu 14y agoYes, and that's great, but it doesn't invalidate the general trend.
- marknutter 14y agoAnd how sure are we it's a general trend? Are there any numbers anybody can point to?
- scribu 14y agoPlenty of studies on job satisfaction exist. I just googled "job satisfaction trends" and got various studies, and this article from 2010: "Americans' job satisfaction falls to record low" http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/money/workplace/2010-01-05-job-satisfaction-use_N.htm http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/money/workplace/2010-01-05-jo...
- BSousa 14y agoLately I've been thinking about this a lot. I also took a break from corporate life for about 5 months now, and now trying to get back into it. I'm actually content with what I have, give me my laptop (which I already own) and my bookshelf (with probably more than 50 unread books), as long as I have money for food and house/utilities, I'm actually quite ok. The problem arises when you are in a relationship and have a kid. It is really hard to 'convince' people (including the wife) the baby doesn't need 10 pairs of trousers or 50 plastic toys (He actually has a lot of hand me downs, and all of his toys, maybe 20 if the many, are handmade wooden ones). Also, that vacation the wife always dreamed, you can't really do that. Or she wants a new fancy dress - nopes. Ohh the kid should go to private school (while I'm not fond of it, looking at public schools in the area, maybe isn't that bad of an idea), will the money be enough? Yes, we can all live minimally, but we also have to agree, it maybe easier for us 'techies' to do so as a laptop is usually hours of entertainment, but trying this with a social life (girlfriend/friends/family) makes it really hard. All this to say, I'm really sad I'm giving up my free time to work 9-5 again, but consulting isn't paying all the bills and allow me to provide a 'good' life to my wife and kid.
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoI kind of understand - but I am in a similar position, and I went into it with my eyes half open. I would like to scale down, but how?
- aeden 14y agoIt may sound crazy, but one way to scale down is to move every few years, especially when you pick up the cost of moving. The more you do it the easier it is to cut down on the stuff in your life you don't need. You also can become quite adept at rebuilding your living environment on the cheap with things like Craig's List. Food for thought.
- caseysoftware 14y agoThat works pretty well.. but I'd also throw in that once you move, any box that you haven't opened in a year should be tossed. The same should go for clothes, tech gear, etc. * I use a year instead of six months because occasionally you get that holiday-specific stuff that might be good to keep but only comes up annually.
- rdudekul 14y ago"We’ve been led into a culture that has been engineered to leave us tired, hungry for indulgence, willing to pay a lot for convenience and entertainment, and most importantly, vaguely dissatisfied with our lives so that we continue wanting things we don’t have." Almost all of us are sheep and have a herd mentality. This makes it easy for big businesses and even government to sway our sentiments to manipulate us. From the education system to work place to media, everything is designed around big businesses generate revenues by pushing items we do not REALLY need. Material comforts and sensory pleasures do not fulfill anyone for long. How do we realize what we want will not truly satisfy us? How do we break out of this? The hard way is to discover the source of satisfaction lies within, through meditation, questioning and experimentation. When we discover our true calling and use our talents to serve all selflessly (as much as possible), we can get a glimpse of true happiness. Till then we cannot help but be manipulated by society in its current form.
- marknutter 14y agoWhat you are describing here is what makes you happy. It's a mistake to think it would make everyone happy.
- Falling3 14y agoHe hasn't actually described what makes him happy. He's described a way to figure out what makes one happy.
- lilsunnybee 14y agoMost of the world's population is low wage workers who don't have any extra for mindless consumption. Somehow they are able to get by without these comforts, and don't even need to meditate. The real problem here is the yuppie lifestyle. Just think if all of those wasted financial resources could actually go to fund something important, rather than mindless waste. Keeping people exhausted and feeling they are entitled contributes greatly to the problem.
- GFischer 14y ago
- tunnuz 14y agoI have been talking about this with a friend recently, but the author managed to put this down with much better words. Great reading.
- drags 14y agoUnfortunately, this is close to impossible in my industry, and most others. You work 40-plus hours or you work zero. I've mentioned this before but my company hires Rails developers for 24hrs/wk. Health insurance is provided and salary is proportional to full-time. It's not for everyone, but it works well for us. Everyone's fresh and relaxed when they come into work, and the free time is great for learning, side projects, exercising, travel. Anyway, we're actually hiring right now: if you're in the Bay Area and looking shoot me an email.
- Joeboy 14y agoGood for you. I'm neither in the Bay Area nor a Rails developer, but I really wish I could find work like that.
- cocoflunchy 14y agoHave you considered freelancing?
- flyinRyan 14y agoEvery day. Tips on how to smoothly transition from full time employment to Freelancing? In Europe, btw.
- Joeboy 14y agoI contract, which means I get to work "as much as I want" over the longer term, but it still means full time working for extended periods. It's not a bad deal at all, but I'm starting to feel like I'd like something more stable. I am hard to please.
- jdotjdot 14y agoI did that for a while and had similar plusses and minuses, but the one thing I still can't wrap my head around is insurance. What did you do about that?
- thruflo 14y agoSo why don't we work less? Is it really because we want more stuff? Or is it driven by social competition, desire to move up maslow's heirarchy, ...? I know I will be happier if I work less. But I don't.
- kisielk 14y agoWell, it's hard to find a job that's <40 hours a week for one.
- lilsunnybee 14y agoNext to impossible if you're looking for benefits too, such as health insurance, vacation time, and sick leave.
- blissofbeing 14y agoSite seems down. Anyone have a cache?
- franciscoap 14y agoWhen this happens, just search google for cache:[url] http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache%3Awww.raptitude.com%2F2010%2F07%2Fyour-lifestyle-has-already-been-designed%2F http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache%3Awww.r...
- yuxt 14y agonot sure if it's the same article but Google revealed this http://thoughtcatalog.com/2013/your-lifestyle-has-already-been-designed/ http://thoughtcatalog.com/2013/your-lifestyle-has-already-be...
- nchase 14y agomirror?
- natex 14y agoPossibly too much traffic right now. Here's Google's cache (text-only). http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:www.raptitude.com/2010/07/your-lifestyle-has-already-been-designed/&hl=en&tbo=d&strip=1 http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:www.rap...
- sliverstorm 14y agoAs far as 'where the money goes', I can't speak for everyone but in my case I have asked myself this question a number of times and I think the answer is pretty simple. Firstly, I have more past-times than I did when I was broke. This is partly because I can afford to, and partly because I have more time. (When I was broke, I was a busy student) Secondly, I no longer stop and think as much about goods quality. When I had no money, it made sense to spend ridiculous amounts of time carefully selecting goods to maximize "bang-for-buck". Now that my time is more valuable, I will more often opt for the best quality item. The same carries over to food as well. Not a foodie, but eating healthy is simply more expensive than ramen.
- moxie 14y agoIt's interesting that the author uses the word "lifestyle," because the popular etymology of the word actually comes from marketing research. The word itself was popularized relatively recently (only a generation ago): http://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=lifestyle&year_start=1800&year_end=2000&corpus=15&smoothing=3 http://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=lifestyle&y... It was driven largely by VALS, research done by Stanford Research Institute on new marketing techniques, which has been partially credited for transforming advertising into what we know today: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/VALS https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/VALS The Adam Curtis film "Century Of The Self" has an excellent exploration of the term "lifestyle" and the context it came from. I think it's interesting that we commonly use the word "lifestyle" to talk about breaking out of a consumer-driven mindset, when the language itself was developed precisely for marketing to that mindset.
- whatusername 14y agoI think the author was likely referencing "lifestyle design" (ala Tim Ferriss and co). But I agree that it's interesting that Tim Ferriss and co/ use the word lifestyle.
- narag 14y agoI didn't know that. I first read it here, in HN (not an English speaker) in two senses: "lifestyle business" and as a synonim for something a little less strong than "vice" or "crime": drinking, overeating, "soft" drugs, workaholism... The funny thing is that it seems to conflate the same slight deviation from the average in the good direction: exercise, healthy food...
- kevinpet 14y agoI'm always skeptical of arguments that assume massive implicit cartels. "the 8-hour workday is too profitable for big business ... because it makes for such a purchase-happy public". Maybe, but if I can really get happier, more productive workers by letting them work 9-4, I don't care whether they are being good little consumers in their off hours. A business's employees make up a very small fraction of their customers.
- crazygringo 14y ago> But the 8-hour workday is too profitable for big business, not because of the amount of work people get done in eight hours... but because it makes for such a purchase-happy public. Keeping free time scarce means people pay a lot more for convenience, gratification, ... We’ve been led into a culture that has been engineered to leave us tired, hungry for indulgence... Western economies, particularly that of the United States, have been built in a very calculated manner on gratification, addiction... This makes it sound like there's some kind of a conspiracy, like robber barons or The Man all got together to plan this out. It's a lot easier to invent scapegoats like this, but that doesn't make it true. > Can you imagine what would happen if all of America stopped buying so much unnecessary fluff that doesn’t add a lot of lasting value to our lives? The economy would collapse and never recover. Again, any kind of research to back up such a bold and incredibly controversial statement? That's just unsubstantiated fluff, without demonstrating any knowledge of actual economics. The truth is much more prosaic. People buy what they want, and companies make money doing their best to give it to them. In fact, we celebrate companies that do a better job at this, like Apple inventing the iPhone. People like buying things, and decide on their own that they want to work harder to buy those things. Of course, most people don't have the degree of self-awareness or reflection to realize what really makes them happy in the long-term -- but companies that provide short-term gratification are under no obligation to educate their consumers, and it's not like they have any better idea what makes you happier long-term either, since everyone's different. We have a 40-hour workweek because most people prefer work twice as much and be paid twice as much as a 20-hour workweek. Sure, there are people who would prefer 20 hours and half (or less) salary, but they're in the vast minority, so that's not what companies build their workforces around. To rebut the title: yes, your lifestyle has already been "designed", but it isn't intelligent design. No person designed it. It's just what cultural evolution has arrived at so far.
- 47uF 14y agoI don't think what you're saying is all that different from what the article is saying. It never says there's an actual conspiracy or that any specific person designed anything. But as you yourself said there seems to be a difference between what we think we want and what makes us happy in the long term and economies will tend to grow by maximizing on the former, not necessarily the latter.
- zxcvvcxz 14y agoThese type of posts bother me because they play the blame game without substantiating arguments or offering useful alternatives. This paragraph in particular was annoying: "We’ve been led into a culture that has been engineered to leave us tired, hungry for indulgence, willing to pay a lot for convenience and entertainment, and most importantly, vaguely dissatisfied with our lives so that we continue wanting things we don’t have. We buy so much because it always seems like something is still missing." To start, this almost implies that there's a room full of Old Powerful White Men (let's be honest, that's what you imagine) figuring out how to raise little consumer sheep. Like it's a big conspiracy or something. Even worse, the government must be in on it, otherwise I wouldn't have to work 8 hours and feel tired all the time! Well, part of this 'conspiracy' is called 'marketing', and if you have an issue with that, then please address it with a logical argument. I think most of HN is fine with marketing, otherwise nobody would get to witness these new startups. Regarding the 8 hour workday: this is an economics argument more than anything. Again, either address it properly or leave it be. What would be nice would be an alternative suggestion. However, I don't think travelling at large with a MBP sipping mojitos on the beach and skyping clients is something society at large can start doing. But the author probably can. (There's a bit of an interesting aside - should intelligence and technical skills afford you more freedom?) To wrap up, what really bothers me with that paragraph, and this post in general, is this: it's being implied that personal happiness and fulfillment (so nothing "feels missing") is not a personal responsibility. What? Let's look at that last sentence again: "We buy so much because it always seems like something is still missing." Just because consumerism isn't "filling your inner void" doesn't mean it caused it. That's not to advocate for or against consumerism, just to suggest that there are other alternatives to these problems. And it's your own responsibility to go find them. All that being said, I found the post interesting enough to think about and reply to, so thanks for writing it.
- Evgeny 14y agoTo start, this almost implies that there's a room full of Old Powerful White Men (let's be honest, that's what you imagine) figuring out how to raise little consumer sheep. I've never been in such a meeting, but what would you imagine is discussed when sales strategies are devised? - How can we drive our customers to buy more of our products? How can we sell more to existing customers, how can we attract more new ones? Marketing, advertising campaigns showing how happy our customers are? or - Do our customers really need that much of our products? Should we educate them on the fact that excess usage of our products is unhealthy? Should we make sure they don't hurt their budgets or rake credit card debt? What I'm saying is that it's not a conspiracy, but the "hand of the market" does not care if you are better off buying something or not. McDonalds wouldn't care if you ever eat anything but fries, Johnson & Johnson wouldn't care if you wash your hands obsessively 25 times per hour, and no home electronics provider would care if you hoard their products in stacks in your basement. The only thing they care about is to sell as much as possible, and ideally make you come back for more.
- moultano 14y agoDoes anyone have statistics on the breakdown of expenses for the average household, or within different income levels? I don't think we can really discuss this materially without some real stats. My hunch is that the budget of most families is dominated by food, housing, and transportation.
- ogd 14y agoThe answer is simple. Read MMM and ERE. Save that big Silicon Valley paycheck and retire at 35 to spend the next 60 years doing whatever the fuck you want all day and laughing at the rats. That's what I'm doing. Already saved $125k in 1.5 years and just got a 20% raise. Should hit $1 million by 32 or so, move to a less costly area and freedom awaits!
- usaar333 14y agoAfter reading a post like this, I feel fortunate to live in a place where 3-bedroom houses go for $800,000. When someone is paying ~$175/day just for housing, all of the "unnecessary fluff" really are a drop in the bucket.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- sonnyg 14y agoWhat was old is new again :) - In Praise of Idleness by Bertrand Russell http://www.zpub.com/notes/idle.html http://www.zpub.com/notes/idle.html
- mark_l_watson 14y agoGreat article. Some old ideas, but worth carefully exploring. A huge understatement, but right on: "Here in the West, a lifestyle of unnecessary spending has been deliberately cultivated and nurtured in the public by big business." My wife and I talk about this all the time, especially in the context of TV commercials. BTW, on the subject of 40 hour work weeks. I am in my early 60s and I have worked full time for a very small fraction of my life. Even when working for large companies in an office environment, I was just about always able to negotiate working 32 hours Tuesday-Friday. Three day weekends every week allowed me to write a lot of books and spend lots of time outdoors.