3 ms·
The article mentions that most of YC's value is in just two companies (Dropbox, AirBNB) out of some 400 funded. That would be awful performance for a traditiona
by beagle3 14y ago
The article mentions that most of YC's value is in just two companies (Dropbox, AirBNB) out of some 400 funded. That would be awful performance for a traditional VC, but the amount of time and money put in by YC into each of those 400 companies is between 1/100 and 1/1000 of how much a traditional VC would put into a deal.
So, if you're comparing to a traditional VC model, compare YC to one that has made e.g. 10 investments. And to have Dropbox, AirBNB as two of your ten (regardless of all others), is something every VC would envy.
- rtpg 14y agoyeah I was thinking the same. 400(well, 398) worth 2 billion still gives you something like 500k per company. When considering the 15k invested, sounds like a winner to me. Obviously this is averaging but still.
- evincarofautumn 14y agoThe mean helps put it in perspective, but the exponential distribution is perhaps more telling. If, say, 50% of the wealth is accounted for by 15% of the companies, the mean doesn’t give you any intuition for how the game actually works.
- monsterix 14y agoNot only that, there is also a need to understand that not every student coming out of a primary school is a topper. Especially, when you've a single point index to measure that success - in this case, a billion dollars. But every student is an important part of the system. A program like YC or 500Startups has a solid name because of the quality of its guides, support system, value system, knowledge, experience and pretty much everything else that one can think of. Keep the money aside, tell me one VC that compares on those metrics? (Disclosure: I am not a part of any accelerator program.)
- canttestthis 14y agoI'm curious now, whats the median valuation of YC companies?
- jacquesm 14y agoApples (VCs) to oranges (seed investors / incubators). For a VC 2 out of 400 would be spectacularly bad, for an incubator to have 2 winners of that magnitude is actually really good and there are a few others that have already exited (Heroku, YC08 iirc for instance) that increase that even further. Add in stripe and the current crop of 'hot' stuff and YC is looking pretty good. But you still can't compare it with a VC, it's a different model, different risk/reward.
- beagle3 14y agoIncubators and VCs may be oranges and apples, but YC started a new kind of incubation system, to which the name "accelerator" (which is in common use) is more fitting than "incubator". A traditional VC, compared to an incubator, was able to offer access to bigger money in the next rounds (whether the VC's own, or other funds it co-invests in), and networking. But YC (and other accelerators) actually give you everything a traditional VC does. The main difference is bureaucracy & first round size: A traditional VC spends 2-3 whole months trying to decide if to take a deal or not; therefore it makes no sense to invest anything less than $500K (and often no less than $2M), and you have 1-2 investments/year/partner. YC and other accelerators invest ~$20K, with (comparatively) no overhead, but otherwise give the same access to networking and future money. It's apples to oranges only in the sense that when you're hungry, either one will help you get through the hunger. For one of them, you have to wait much longer in line, and it keeps your hunger at bay for longer.