4 ms·
The secret answer is: this is bike-shedding, worry about more important things. Most of the time only the original content in a message will be read, so top-pos
by InclinedPlane 14y ago
The secret answer is: this is bike-shedding, worry about more important things. Most of the time only the original content in a message will be read, so top-posting is probably preferred. Occasionally it will be more suitable to form a point-by-point reply to another post, in which case it's better to reply inline.
Ah, but I hear you asking "but what about when new people get added to a thread or a thread is complex to follow? doesn't top-posting make it more difficult to get up to speed?" And the correct answer is: no posting style will save you from this problem. This is a fundamental communication problem, and the best solution is to take the effort to add a "state of the discussion checkpoint", list out all of the working assumptions and conclusions so far in the thread and state them explicitly. This is about eighteen or maybe nineteen, give or take, trillion times more important than posting style. A long multi-party conversation is a complex beast with a lot of subtleties, by checkpointing and summarizing the state of the conversation you can ensure that people are not misunderstanding or operating under incorrect or different assumptions and you save a lot of time and effort for getting other folks up to speed as they become involved. Additionally, a lot of times there will be conversations that occur in meetings or over the phone or IM which might involve additional information or decisions which everyone in the thread at the moment understands implicitly but isn't actually spelled out, making it that much more difficult for other folks to understand.
Make it a habit to always be thinking "does everyone have the same information and assumptions in this conversation?" as well as "what roadblocks do people have in reading this thread to get to that state?" And when you notice that a thread gets to a state where it might be hard to follow take the time to re-state assumptions, conclusions, and decisions as well as the facts as you are aware of them to make sure everyone is on the same page.
- jacquesm 14y ago> and the best solution is to take the effort to add a "state of the discussion checkpoint", list out all of the working assumptions and conclusions so far in the thread and state them explicitly. That's indeed the very best way to deal with it. But the problem (as this comment nicely illustrates, being bottom posted under a small bit from your excellent comment) is that such effort is typically deemed to be too much work. Communicating well takes an extraordinary amount of time and the speed with which most internet communications take place precludes quite a bit of the work that should go into it. This leads to quite a few misunderstandings and has ignited many a flame-war.
- venus 14y ago> Communicating well takes an extraordinary amount of time and the speed with which most internet communications take place precludes quite a bit of the work that should go into it. Good point, well taken, but only applies to casual conversation environments such as here. Do we need to establish a "best practise" for environments where accurate communication is imperative, eg diplomatic offices, and how would we go about doing so?
- FixThisMess 14y ago"Bike-shedding"? WTF? Top-posting is lazy, rude, and ignorant. And sadly it's encouraged by defective clients like Apple Mail. The "folding" of already seen content indicates that it shouldn't be there in the first place, and threading reinforces this.