4 ms·
The article misses the point that abandoning bottom -posting only works if you don't quote content from the message you're replying to. If you do, then by all m
by lutusp 14y ago
The article misses the point that abandoning bottom -posting only works if you don't quote content from the message you're replying to. If you do, then by all means bottom-post.
The worst case is a long exchange with multiple participants, all quoted, some top-posters and some bottom-posters.
And finally, if you quote multiple passages and reply to them individually within a single post (as I often do), you simply must bottom-post or your message will be incomprehensible.
As far as I'm concerned, a top-poster is either a narcissist or very inexperienced in Internet communications. Or both.
- 0x0 14y agoThe battle was lost long ago. I've tried insisting on bottom-posting, with the result that people sometimes wouldn't even see the reply below the quoted text. Raging against top-posters doesn't pay the bills, unfortunately. Edit: The only place bottom-posting still works is on technical mailing lists.
- mindcrime 14y ago> Edit: The only place bottom-posting still works is on technical mailing lists. And Hacker News.
- viraptor 14y ago> As far as I'm concerned, a top-poster is either a narcissist or very inexperienced in Internet communications. Or both. I bet you've not been exposed to many corporate email chains. Top-posting makes a lot of sense there. I often get copied on an email chains from which only the last part affects me. For example it will be a long discussion about some task and then I'll get copied because I'm the person who does X and need to help out. Bottom posting wouldn't work here for a number of reasons: - I don't care about the project and its planning 20 emails ago - but I still may need some information from those emails. What I need is the task (at the very top) and context if required (at the bottom). - If anyone tried to edit the history by removing unnecessary parts, they'd most likely remove the parts not important to them, but later on same questions would get repeated as soon as new people join the conversation. - Leaving all needed parts and bottom posting / replying inline would result in 20+ levels of nesting and each inline section would become its own thread. This is just not possible to manage without some public archive with thread support. Both styles have sense in different environments. I bottom-post to public mailing lists, because it makes more sense there. I top-post to other people at work where exchange==email, because it makes more sense there. I used to bring up the same argument and the same quote about why top-posting is bad - but I guess I was wrong - I just didn't see the issue from the other side at that point. This makes me think that people top-posting in html on public mailing lists simply don't understand the other side either, but may adjust with time. As long as we don't assume either side is narcissistic and allow the possibility that we're not experienced in every possible scenario of Internet communication, we may just get along... Just try to adjust to the audience and environment sometimes. This may mean top-posting to some office; as well as fighting with your POS outlook to allow you to bottom-post to a mailing list in plaintext without any attachments.
- 0x0 14y ago> (...) corporate email chains. Top-posting makes a lot of sense there. I often get copied on an email chains from which only the last part affects me (...) This is actually a great argument for top-posting! Totally agree on this one.
- ScottBurson 14y agoThere's another reason bottom- (or interspersed) posting does not work well in corporate email chains: Outlook flatly doesn't support it. Quoted text in a reply is not indented by default. The replier has to do extra work to put their reply in a different font or color so it's clear what's quoted text and what's new text.
- pseut 14y agoSmartphones too. I top-post from my iPhone, bottom-post everywhere else.
- dredmorbius 14y agoWhich utterly breaks for those who read the thread on a text-only mailer (e.g.: mutt).
- InclinedPlane 14y ago"Doc, it hurts when I go like this." "Then stop going like that."
- dredmorbius 14y agoOr any mailer which doesn't present the highly-styled formatting of Microsoft Outlook as created by the author. Which would be, again, any text-based client, many mobile mail clients, and others. Pretty much anything but Microsoft Outlook. Other enterprise clients are similarly bad. Lotus Notes, and others (though these are the two most commonly found ones). Straight text is much more fungible and portable than highly-specified formats. There's a reason technical email etiquette and formatting rules emerged, though yes, contemporary business and non-technical use is diverging from these practices.