2 ms·
That is beautiful and elegant. It's also powerful. The article submitted here easily shows that in any interval on the real line there is at least one transcen
by ColinWright 14y ago
That is beautiful and elegant. It's also powerful.
The article submitted here easily shows that in any interval on the real line there is at least one transcendental. Your proof here shows that you can create a transcendental "close" to any given rational. Both have a power beyond just "transcendentals exist".
The reason I like the one submitted is that it's more visual and less algebraic, hence easier to explain to those less comfortable with polynomials and the like, but certainly both have their merits.
Thanks for showing us this one.
- Evbn 14y agoWhat is the difference between "any interval" and "close to a given rational"? Rationals are dense, after all.
- ColinWright 14y agoThe difference is in the way it's being described, and how that description feeds in to the subsequent definition and proof. The submitted item says: take an interval, here's how to construct a transcendental inside your chosen interval. The proof that gjm11 gives says: Here's a proof that if something is unreasonably close to a rational then it's not algebraic, and here's how to construct something like that. The concept of "unreasonably close" then has to be expressed in terms of sizes of denominators, and hence is a relative term. That forms a key part of the proof.