3 ms·
Maybe Ron Paul proliferation is due to the man's ideas and his honesty?! And his popularity on reddit and other sites is due to the fact that he resonates well
by nickb 19y ago
Maybe Ron Paul proliferation is due to the man's ideas and his honesty?! And his popularity on reddit and other sites is due to the fact that he resonates well with what people think? Maybe people are sick of candidates that lie to you all the time. You know... just stating the obvious.
- pg 19y agoYou don't seem to grasp that we're talking about a completely orthogonal issue. Ron Paul could be the best presidential candidate in history. The problem I'm talking about is simply a structural one: because such a small proportion of visitors on social news sites vote, 100 of his vocal supporters can dictate the stories for a site with 100,000 users. Man is politics a tar baby. I wish I'd never made that comment on reddit. Nothing personal (I mean this more about the reddit commenters than you), but it's a topic that brings out the dumbest in everyone.
- yamada 19y agoDoes it ever get lonely up there on your pedestal? Why don't 100 guliani supporters do likewise? Why does he raise so much money from peanut online contributions while others with deep corporate connections can barely keep up? Whatever the design issues with reddit or what-have-you, let's say there are 100 amateur supporters who do manipulate things - that's 100 more than care to dedicate their free time to do so for all other candidates combined. That says just as much about the kind of enthusiasm he generates as it does any design shortcomings which could just as easily be exploited by opponents. For crying out loud it can't just be one guy with the name "Paul" that has all the spotlight all the time - stop being a fifth column and let him get his fair share.
- mnemonicsloth 19y agoNo, I think the real problem is that talking about politics brings out the worst in people who disagree with you (because you make them feel angry), and the only the mildly unsavory in people who don't (because you make them feel smug). How many people responded to What You Can't Say with some form of "Yes for thee, but not for me"? Telling people an important part of their opinion-forming mechanism -- their facts, or their fact-finding, or their ability to tell "probative" from "normative" -- is just as special case that gives everyone an equal opportunity to show his ass. I actually spent some time thinking about how you could do better than what's out there now -- provide a way to enforce good rhetorical behavior; set some rules about evidence; and especially, make prominence based on credibility or evidentiary support. But in the end, I don't think many forum users would really prefer the hard work of keeping their opinions in line with all the available facts to the satisfaction of beating a disembodied un-person in a non-argument. And also, there are a lot of factors working against you: http://www.singinst.org/Biases.pdf http://www.singinst.org/Biases.pdf http://overcomingbias.com http://overcomingbias.com
- stuki 19y ago"...100 of his vocal supporters can dictate the stories for a site with 100,000 users." Only for as long as the 100,000 is reasonably happy with what the 100 is providing them. Otherwise you'd think they'd have the sense to either start downvoting, or simply stop using reddit, rendering it a site with 100 readers who all vote. More likely many of the 100,000 see reddit as their best source for all the Ron Paul news the 'mainstream' media is 'trying to hide' from them.
- DougBTX 19y agoIf those 100 are only upvoting to push it in the face of the 100,000, then those 100 will leave if the 100,000 do. "More likely many of the 100,000 see reddit as their best source for all the Ron Paul news the 'mainstream' media is 'trying to hide' from them." Please tell me you don't believe that. The RP posts are worse than lolcats.
- yamada 19y agoSo then, if the system is so flawed and that's the main explanation for his success, surely with all the other candidates out there, their supporters, if they outnumber the people who agree with Ron Paul, should band together and easily negate his influence on Reddit, correct? If it only takes 100 to skew perception so much on Reddit, then multiply 100X, oh, 8 other candidates and they should have 8X the effect of Ron Paul's supporters, thus easily cancelling him out. Or are you just trying to find some gripe so you can peddle some new startup that addresses this imaginary flaw?
- Elfan 19y agoRon Paul was just a poor example for what you were trying to describe, particularly as a reddit specific phenomenon. Ron Paul appears to be "unusually" popular on reddit, digg, slashdot, youtube, myspace, and facebook (where no sockpuppeting should be possible) among other places. Could there be 100 people inflating those vote? There probably are. But Ron Paul's popularity is a more complex phenomenon and distracts from the general case.
- gwenhwyfaer 19y agoHe's a politician; he made a positive decision to pursue power by permission. He's compromised by default. (pg covered the orthogonality question.)
- yamada 19y agoSo then someone who pursues power sans permission is, according to you, not compromised? Well, Bush seems to be good at that ... let's see ... how's his "uncompromisability" working out? Let's see ...