3 ms·
Huawei has been deemed a security risk by powerful US lawmakers Shane had deep misgivings about the project he was working on and feared he was compromising US
by ck2 14y ago
Huawei has been deemed a security risk by powerful US lawmakers
Shane had deep misgivings about the project he was working on and feared he was compromising US national security
The fact he didn't walk away in the first moment he felt this way, most likely means one of the US agencies killed him. We are apparently already allowed to kill citizens without trial when they are not on US soil.
Well written article though and the presentation was helpful.
- disbelief 14y agoThis is the first conclusion I came to as well. Some entity in the US would have the strongest motive. Possibly number two could be IME, if there's something they're trying to hide. Claims that it was perpetrated by China and/or the Singapore gov't hold less water for me.
- walshemj 14y agoSounds like your not taking your meds - a us citizen who has joined terry taliban and in a war zone is not the same as having doubts about working for Huawei. The obvious thing to do in such circumstances is to offer your services to the CIA as an inside source.
- brown9-2 14y agoWhat is to be gained from killing an IME employee on the last day of his employment with IME?
- sophacles 14y agoI really don't think this follows. Even if we take everything presented in the article at face value, there are a lot of questions unasked (let alone answered) in the article: 1. How did he come to the conclusion/concern he might be violating US national security? Speculations: * He could have come to the conclusion on his own, he was apparently a smart guy. * He could have been asked about his work by embassy officials. * He could have heard/overheard a conversation that lead him down that path. * other reasons I don't have any knowledge of. 2. Once he became concerned, what actions did he take? Speculations: * He kept it to himself and his family. * Being described as an all-american boy, he could have gone to the US embassy with his concerns. The general perception of US citizens is if you report things like this, even if you're unintentionally involved, you are not targeted. * He could have started asking uncomfortable questions at work. 3. Why did he copy a bunch of (presumably NDA) "trade secret" research onto his own hard drive? Speculation: * He just wanted a copy of his work. (I know I've done this with certain bits of code) * He wanted to give a gift to his new employer * He wanted something to bargain with in case the USG investigated him. * He was just going to hand it to the embassy. * He didn't do it with any intent, it was just part of a normal backup routine and he didn't even think of it. 4. Why would that hard drive not have been destroyed or taken, particularly if it was accessed after death? (especially since the place was unlocked) Speculation: * Deep spy game stuff -- the accessed files were altered to be "wrong" * There isn't foul play * There is more dangerous information that they were really worried about, not the stuff he had * No one realized the information was not on the company network, and some IT guy was just spot-checking against official work to make sure stuff wasn't lost. 5. If there are national security implications, what things are we not being told because of classified? No speculation on my part here. I have no way of pretending to have a reasonable understanding of this world. 6. What don't we know about Shane Todd? (Not in a blame the victim way, but there is lots of a person's life that can't be described in an article of this size. Is there something about him his family didn't know? Is there something they are embarrassed to talk about?) Speculation dependent questions: 1. If he went to the USG as a good citizen, what did they do? * They could have advised him to not abruptly up and leave for personal security reasons. * They could have asked him to get them copies of the research. * They could have blown him off, or told him, "thanks, but don't worry about it". 2. Who are all the people who would be interested in targeting him? * His employers (as speculated/suggested in the article). * The US government, as you speculate. * Governments who pay/partner with his employers * Singapore government, wanting to keep various ties quiet 3. If they are after the research, why kill him rather than just steal his computers?
- chaostheory 14y ago> The fact he didn't walk away in the first moment he felt this way, most likely means one of the US agencies killed him. I'm not sure this makes any sense. Your theory is more believable if: 1) He had no foreseeable plans for leaving. 2) Singapore was more friendly with the US, rather than being in bed with China. 3) Based on #2, Singapore is a surveillance society. I would imagine they would be pissed if the US did this on their soil, and they would probably have some video footage proof akin to what Dubai had. 4) If he didn't have a hard drive full of a Chinese company's trade secrets, that he intended to bring to the US. Why would the US do this before this data made it back to our shores? Please correct me if I'm wrong.