3 ms·
There's no penalty for losing the race and trying again. It's not like it's making noise and filling up logs or anything like that. Maybe somebody would notic
by tedunangst 14y ago
There's no penalty for losing the race and trying again. It's not like it's making noise and filling up logs or anything like that. Maybe somebody would notice the CPU spinning if you're hammering it, but that's avoidable.
- ajross 14y agoThat's true, of course. But time is still a finite resource and it's possible to have a theoretical race with a window so narrow that it can't actually be exploited in feasible time. The fact that the proof of concept had to artificially open the window is evidence that this might be such a situation. It's still a hole; it just might not be big enough to push a hack through.
- lawnchair_larry 14y agoYou're speculating, but you're wrong, FYI. You're also wrong that the PoC requires a patch to work. That's just to make the window gaping and foolproof, basically.
- ajross 14y agoBetter to speculate and be wrong than assert without evidence. How long does the exploit take to run successfully on your test system? Did you even build it? I did, and it doesn't. Go away.
- tedunangst 14y agoStrong disagree. "This race condition is way too small for anybody to exploit" is not the good kind of speculation.
- lawnchair_larry 14y agoYou asserted without evidence. I've successfully run it repeatedly. You don't have to believe me, but in dismissing the impact, you're making a common error. Probability of the event occurring naturally has very little to do with risk, particularly when there are no consequences for failing.