5 ms·
If you just want to check your knowledge why not ask the professor if you can come by his office sometime during the vast amount of time he'll save from not hav
by majormajor 14y ago
If you just want to check your knowledge why not ask the professor if you can come by his office sometime during the vast amount of time he'll save from not having to grade a bunch of exams (presuming he wasn't going to have his TAs grade the finals -- I remember my professors grading finals themselves since TAs had their own finals to take, and because it was the final, after all), and go over stuff with him then? I'd much rather have a direct discussion with my professor than a paper exam.
And considering the fittingness of exploiting this loophole for a CS course -- what a great illustration of an unanticipated consequence of a system's rules being followed exactly! -- you'd have to be a huge jerk to want to screw over everyone else in the class just to check your knowledge.
Edit: I don't think it would work like you envision it anyway. The professor would have to in on it, and good luck getting him to help screw over everyone else. I can't see a professor who was a good enough sport to honor this policy despite the unexpected way it was used letting you take it in a way that left everyone else with 0s, and only you with a 100. For instance, if he shows up the day of the exam and says "unfortunately, someone already took it anonymously" then everyone else just gets to play a game of spot-the-missing-student while taking the exam. (I suppose you could show up and pretend to take it a second time...)
- jlgreco 14y ago> you'd have to be a huge jerk to want to screw over everyone else in the class just to check your knowledge. How much time and money is he spending on this education again?
- majormajor 14y agoAnd how does not having to take the final hurt his education? He can still study just as much as he would've before. He still has access to resources to check the results of that studying. I'm extremely skeptical of concerns that it would have a significant negative impact on future classes that this exam could've potentially weeded people out before. It could happen, though when I was TA'ing most weeding-out usually happened before the final... I guess the anonymously-screw-everyone-else solution would also give him the opportunity to have a spectacularly sociopathic answer to that YC application "hacked a non-software system" question... Frankly, if you're going to screw things up for everyone else like this, given that it doesn't actually let you learn anything more than you could've anyway, the least you can do is to do it face to face. Heck, I'd be secretly hoping that one of the "guards" did try to start something physical. Then he'd both bomb the final and be in trouble for assault or whatever.
- jlgreco 14y agoForget educational merit, he paid for the damn test. Is it so unreasonable for him to want to take it? If his peers want to make it a matter of "do something you don't want to do, or else you are a 'square'", then they can kindly fuck off. The only proper way to organize a prank of this sort is with an anonymous vote. If there was not an anonymous vote, I would anonymously choose to not participate.
- majormajor 14y agoWhat I'm trying to get at is that I see no moral "they were mean bullies!" high ground here, since a final is not required for one to be educated by a class. Anyone wanting the screw the rest of the class over was "mean" first. Anyone who intimidated anyone else into going along looks bad; so does anyone who didn't want to go along so that their fellow students would do worse. It's absurd to look at is as "I paid for that test." Education as paying for tests is a bug, not a feature. Elsewhere in the thread you call it "clowning." I call it "hacking." The educational value of learning that sometimes you can get things done in non-traditional ways, and everyone ends up well off as a result, is far higher than the educational value of taking yet another exam.
- jlgreco 14y ago"Moral high-ground" has nothing to do with it. As stated in the article, there is absolutely no ethical obligation to play along. The expectation that everyone should follow along is absurd for the reasons that I laid out, but those points are not about morality or ethics. I have laid out how to perform this "hack" ethically however: If, and only if, an anonymous unanimous vote performed would there be any ethical obligation to go along with it. Without that it is not a "hack" ...unless your definition of "hack" permits coercion. If coercion is considered unnecessary, then there is no reason to not hold an anonymous unanimous vote. Each participant must be given the opportunity to opt-in, without any coercion whatsoever. Is that really an unreasonable ask? If I were handed a ballot for this prank, I would vote No. (Why do I want to take the test? Many reasons, some I have already covered, some I have not. Frankly it is no ones business but my own and has no bearing on the ethics of the situation) If they then proceeded to attempt it anyway, their failing grades would not be my problem. If they neglected to hold the vote and assumed my participation, their failing grades would similarly not be my problem. If they held a vote, and I voted Yes, but then took the test anyway, then I would be the jackass.
- scott_s 14y agoFor the record: for a computer systems course I TAed, the two professors, myself and the other TA spent 6 hours total in a room grading, for midterms and finals. For two different semesters. So, it varies.
- smsm42 14y ago>>>> you'd have to be a huge jerk to want to screw over everyone else in the class just to check your knowledge. No you don't. You don't owe anybody to behave according to their expectations, even if your behaving so would be wonderful for them. It's not your duty and you're not a jerk if you don't comply with their wishes. You are free to do either, and they are free to convince you, but saying "oh, we expected you to do this and you don't and this sucks for us so you're a jerk" is bullshit. Nobody has obligation to help his fellow student to cheat.
- GhotiFish 14y agoJust like how you don't have to clean up your garbage in public, and like how when you have a heard of cows, you don't have to listen to the other farmers in coordinating the use of the fields. I think sacrificing a test (which the professor himself said was nitpicky) to teach students about public coordination and working together to avoid a tragedy of the commons is not bullshit, nor will it ever be bullshit. If your cheat involves executing something far more difficult then actually studying and acing the test, cheat away.
- smsm42 14y agoIf having to take a test is a tragedy for you, maybe you shouln't have enrolled in the class for starters. For me it is a normal outcome and presenting it as if it is a huge disaster everybody has moral obligation to help avoiding is nonsense.
- GhotiFish 14y agoreally? You're rebuttal is that I'm characterizing the test as a tragedy? sigh ok. Continue about your day.