4 ms·
If "easy access to online porn increases the frequency and severity of sexual violence against women" is a "moral standard" that doesn't require evidence rather
by pessimizer 14y ago
If "easy access to online porn increases the frequency and severity of sexual violence against women" is a "moral standard" that doesn't require evidence rather than a claim of fact that does, then coldtea's access to the internet through throwaway accounts is contributing to the intellectual decline of the Western world. Also, mice are born from a peculiar mix of sawdust and wet hay.
- coldtea 14y ago>then coldtea's access to the internet through throwaway accounts is contributing to the intellectual decline of the Western world. The Western world was never that intellectual to begin with. Western civilisation? Now, that would be a good idea, as Ghandi said. Plus, the thinkers from the West (and the non-yet-West, Ancient Greece and Rome) that mattered to the so-called "Westend Civilisation" once, weren't hell bent on "evidence" at all. Modern western civilisation is merely pop culture with some engineering thrown in. That said, I surely agree that my access to the internet is "contributing to an intellectual decline", if not the internet's then surely mine. Speaking of "intellectual decline", noticed how your example, e.g about how "mice are born from a peculiar mix of sawdust and wet hay" is NOT an example of a societal standard, whereas I only argued for those? I'm sure you sidestepped it, as easily as you sidestepped the very part of my comment where I say that "easy access to online porn increases the frequency and severity of sexual violence against women" _could_ be objectively quantified.
- pessimizer 14y agoI apologize, I didn't make it to the end if your comment. 'Porn causes long term damage to children' is a moral question only if "damage" means 'exposes them to things that I morally object to but don't feel I have to justify.' For example, I think that exposure to black people and the concept of treating the physically/mentally ill damages children. Should I have to justify that?
- coldtea 14y ago>is a moral question only if "damage" means 'exposes them to things that I morally object to but don't feel I have to justify. (...) For example, I think that exposure to black people and the concept of treating the physically/mentally ill damages children. Should I have to justify that? No. You are entitled to believe it as a person. But you would have to convince your society about it, if you don't want to be seen with contempt, or if you want that to also have wider appeal. Notice, though, how you picked a negative example. How about an example that tries (using the same logic) to justify something you already consider bad? E.g. The same can be said for "racist remarks" or "rape". One could argue that there is no damage in rape, especially if the victim was drugged and not aware of it happening. Would we be willing to accept that? How about taking advantage of people to get ahead, including lying et al when you can get away with it? Why would that be wrong "scientifically"? On the contrary, in a game theoretic way it would be totally advantageous for the individual doing it. At final analysis, morals are things that we don't have to justify scientifically. We might abandon them, or change them, or justify them with regard to other morals and rhetoric, and we might even use some scientific information in the process, but morals are not a subject for scientific assessment.
- icebraining 14y agoThe Western world was never that intellectual to begin with. This statement doesn't make any sense. Speaking of "intellectual decline", noticed how your example, e.g about how "mice are born from a peculiar mix of sawdust and wet hay" is NOT an example of a societal standard, whereas I only argued for those? How have you determined that your examples are actually societal standards? I say that "easy access to online porn increases the frequency and severity of sexual violence against women" _could_ be objectively quantified. Nobody disagrees with that. But one has to actually quantify such frequency and severity in order to use it in an honest argument, not just claim it could be.
- coldtea 14y ago>The Western world was never that intellectual to begin with. This statement doesn't make any sense. In what way doesn't it "make sense", because it is trivially parseable in several ways. One is that the Western world is not that self-reflective and meditative upon the meaning of history and life, and substitutes "expert knowledge" and "action" for those. >How have you determined that your examples are actually societal standards? By living in a society. Any look at a book of sociology or anthropology 101 will inform you that stances towards sex and violence are always part of societal standards.
- omonra 14y ago"The Western world was never that intellectual to begin with." Can you elaborate on that please? What time period are you referring to? Which civilizations were more intellectual in your view and how do you quantify it?
- coldtea 14y agoCertainly. I find the ancient civilisations, and especially Greece, to be more intellectual, in that the very idea of society, laws, progress etc is under scrutiny and question in a self-reflective way. But even Europe itself was far more intellectual until around the early 20th century. E.g Compare the top social discourse of early 20th century Vienna or 19th century Paris with today's NYT best-seller list or political pundits. Or compare ancient greek tragedy (which was at the time mass entertainment) to present day mass entertainment (that would be, blockbuster movies at worst and something like Black Swan or Godfather at its best). From that time on, the emergence of a mass culture (which killed a less extensive but higher quality upper-middle class culture), the prevalence of market values and the blind respect of "experts" (and "progress" as a non-testable goal in itself) killed the intellectual traits I describe above.
- omonra 14y agoYes, I mostly agree with you here. You meant 'contemporary' western civilization - hence my confusion.