4 ms·
How would you defend against it? I don't think we have anything that could do that. Meteor defense relies on early detection, but we are unable to spot these u
by ars 14y ago
How would you defend against it? I don't think we have anything that could do that.
Meteor defense relies on early detection, but we are unable to spot these until after they already hit (and by then it's too late).
- cryptoz 14y agoWe defend against it by improving early detection. If you detect early enough, deflection is very easy.
- jholman 14y agoCitation needed. My understanding is that all existing plans for deflection are wild-and-crazy and completely untested. We'd be okay if we had 30 years of warning, because that's long enough to try multiple insane strategies, each of which takes half a decade to get working.
- cryptoz 14y agoThey're not all insane. Personally, I'm partial to the slow but effective gravity tow: send a small, 1-ton spacecraft and have it sit right next to the asteroid, without impact. If you place it correctly you can alter the orbit however you like. Of course, the danger is that this could be used for evil, too. But it's not that crazy, and it would most definitely work.
- Daniel_Newby 14y agoWe routinely land impactors, robots, and even sample return missions on other bodies in the Solar System. It does not seem to be a stretch to land a small rocket on a meteor and give it a push. If you do it a few years in advance, it would not even take much of a rocket.
- chakalakasp 14y agoWhen the mass you are trying to move is a billion metric tons, you're gonna need a lot of advance warning. We can land on asteroids, changing their trajectory enough to avoid a planet strike is uncharted and entirely unpracticed territory. Part of me thinks that NASA's recent foray into asteroids is just that, practice.
- jacquesm 14y ago> deflection is very easy. Is that the space logistical engineering equivalent of a mere matter of programming?
- arrrg 14y agoIt seems to me that being able to predict the impact site and evacuating is a much more promising first avenue compared to deflection. That obviously doesn’t help (as much) with dinosaur killers, but certainly with anything below that.
- kamjam 14y agoWe make sure there is enough money in the defence budget to send out Bruce Willis, Ben Affleck and gang on more training missions. Although I'm not opposed to just leaving Ben Affleck out there for a while. We also need to come up with some treatment for space dementia. It almost ruined the mission last time.