3 ms·
Judging by the kneejerk pattern of the voting on the comment thread, it's largely zealots.
by pg 19y ago
Judging by the kneejerk pattern of the voting on the comment thread, it's largely zealots.
- davidw 19y agopaul> I'm not convinced. What if the upvoting really is representative of a large number of the users? pg> What if the upvoting really is representative of a large number of the users? What if most of the users on reddit are, at this point, zealots, due to the effects of crowding out more moderate users?
- dfranke 19y agoI've been a Ron Paul zealot since years before Reddit existed, but I'm not one of the people voting up the Ron Paul stories. (It's a rarity that I use my up arrow on Reddit any more at all.) My one data point does not make a trend, but I think it's pretty plausible that the sort of people who support Ron Paul are just the same sort of people who find their way over to Reddit. Ron Paul is a libertarian, and it's nothing unique to Reddit that tech-oriented internet forums tend to be populated disproportionately by libertarians.
- yamada 19y agoI found the sentiment condescending, actually. That the overwhelming online success of a candidate who appeals to people who actually care what a prospective candidate thinks about important issues can all be attributed to simple bad design.
- nostrademons 19y agoI dunno. I'm beginning to hear Ron Paul evangelism from RL friends, mostly over FaceBook. I'm pretty sure they didn't get it from Reddit. I suspect it's mostly because people are so fed up with everything connected to the current Washington establishment that they'll vote for anyone who sets himself up as an outsider. Ron Paul's been one of the few candidates that's consistently against the Iraq war; many people will vote for him on that basis alone, regardless of the rest of his positions. I think it's telling that the friend who's been trying hardest to convince me to vote for RP is a pro-choice Green Party atheist. When I showed him Ron Paul's recent voting record (which included a bill to eliminate all federal laws on abortion, a bill to privatize a large federal wildlife refuge, and a bill to prevent laws on school prayer), he said "It doesn't matter. He's against the Iraq war, and that outweighs everything else." He's willing to set aside every other political belief he has for that one issue. I suspect a decent-sized portion of the American electorate is the same.
- pg 19y agoAnd this is supposed to refute what I said? Single-issue voters are the ultimate zealots.
- nostrademons 19y agoNo. It's supposed to point out that nothing you've said refutes what Paul said. Ron Paul's supporters may be zealots and yet still be representative of a large number of voters.
- yamada 19y agoWow - is there anything that escapes the analytical prowess of Mr. Graham? Yes. People who like Ron Paul because he seems to be the only person who seems to actually know what he's talking about, takes a personal intellectual interest in complex matters that are outside of his field of expertise, and has promised to do away with the IRS and income taxes completely are just marginal, over-zealous nuts who conspire to skew the whole internet to make him appear more popular than he really is. That must be it. It's a well managed conspiracy by a small group of Ron Paul supporters who have intimate familiarity with the shortcomings of social news networks and exploit them tirelessly. It couldn't possibly be because the prospect of keeping your entire salary without having to pay taxes at all is a very popular sentiment across the board of political beliefs. No. It can't be because more and more conservatives are shunning the "neo" terminology and adapting the term "Reaganite Conservative", and Ron Paul was one of the original 3 behind-the-scenes power brokers who got Reagan Elected. It's not that he's the only member in congress in memory to actually give back parts of his salary that he doesn't use. Or that he's the only Republican candidate like, ever to appeal to more young voters than the democratic counterpart. No it's all just a design screw-up. Because Paul says so.
- dhouston 19y agonever thought i'd see the day where a pg comment gets voted negative :)
- rms 19y agoNote that reddit comment voting is very kneejerk because it doesn't count for anything. It isn't associated with your karma score.
- paul 19y agoThe disagree&downvote pattern on comments is definitely a problem, but I think it's a different problem and it seems to happen on a wide variety of stories. (which isn't to say that there's not zealotry involved, just that I don't think that's the only thing driving the RP stories) It could also be argued that your comment was completely off topic for the link, kind of like the guy who always complains about the xkcd links on reddit. Would you argue that xkcd is driven by zealotry, or are there just a lot of reddit users who who actually like seeing xkcd? (and again, I'm one of the people who occasionally upvotes the xkcd comics)
- dood 19y agoI think zealous voting is indeed representative of the current userbase: For a long time the quality and diversity of links in Reddit was quite stable, reflecting the strong core userbase. Major systemic issues [1] led to more junk-food like submissions edging in, and slowly the forces involved drove out the original core audience, long-september style. This process continued gaining momentum, until fairly quickly lurching to the new stable state we find it in today. A similar process can be observed in wikipedia: those who care the most, have the most time, and the most tolerance for internet drama naturally dominate: the young and the passionate. 1. a) Reddit conflated two distinct actions into a single vote: training the recommendation engine (vote on what you like/dislike) and judging quality (what is good/bad). This lead to a culture of voting on taste, tending the system away from voting on quality, partly because of: b) The nature of these systems, like the mainstream media, is to tend to the lowest common denominator as audience size increases. This should not have been surprising. How to avoid these issues? Paul's suggestion (somewhere else on this page) about automated topic clustering is a good one. A similar approach I favor is encouraging clusters of users to form naturally, using a collaborative classification/filtering approach; even something as simple as allowing three tags per link could do this. Once clusters are established, it should be much easier to allow users to opt-in or out of the clusters they like/dislike. The editor/oracle approach and/or weighted voting should also work, but seems like a lot more effort. [ahem. I feel like I should mention I'm somewhat biased, as I'm now working on something experimental in this domain]