3 ms·
Everything was great up until the end. I thought this line was completely unnecessary: I hope to post again Friday with some conclusions but for now, base
by malandrew 14y ago
Everything was great up until the end. I thought this line was completely unnecessary:
I hope to post again Friday with some conclusions but for
now, based on a day’s reporting, I will say this much: I
reject Mr. Musk’s central contention that Mr. Broder’s
Sunday piece was faked in order to sabotage the Model S or
the electric-car industry.
I also reject that Broder was in the pocket of the oil industry as redditors are claiming, but I have little doubt that Broder didn't embellish parts just make the story juicier and more readable. Since he writes about energy mainly, his role was probably more to review the supercharging network than the car. But reviewing the network makes for a pretty boring story and having an article that is controversial and paints the tesla as a dud, looks like a classic news hook. This reminds me of the death of Jan Berenstein, author of the Berenstein, and the Slate article that declared that she was a bore and exclaimed "good riddance" [0]. After that post came out there was a good follow up analyzing the journalist motivations in that piece and the allure of the "news hook" [1]
It's unfortunate that this journalist was willing to trade their integrity for more pageviews. Karma's a bitch.
[0] http://www.slate.com/blogs/xx_factor/2012/02/27/jan_berenstain_co_creator_of_the_berenstain_bears_is_dead_good_riddance_to_her_books_.html http://www.slate.com/blogs/xx_factor/2012/02/27/jan_berensta...
[1] http://www.themillions.com/2012/04/the-berenstain-bears-and-the-tyranny-of-timeliness.html http://www.themillions.com/2012/04/the-berenstain-bears-and-...