8 ms·
Test drive: DC to Boston in a Tesla Model S
- ck2 14y agoLive twitter logging of the trip with occasional photos https://twitter.com/PeterDrives https://twitter.com/PeterDrives https://twitter.com/AbigailBassett https://twitter.com/AbigailBassett
- spullara 14y agoThis is totally bogus. CNN didn't even try and break it!
- ishansharma 14y agoYeah, they totally missed the circling in a parking part. And they did not call any towing service as well, whose people were experts in high end cars. :)
- kylec 14y agoIt's been significantly warmer the last few days than it supposedly was when the first trip was done. Given that temperature has a big effect on the car's energy, both the battery capacity and use of the heater, I'd say CNN's results don't disprove the NYT article.
- abat 14y agoThis doesn't really mean anything if the temp is much warmer now.
- stcredzero 14y agoI hope people keep doing this until the weather turns.
- ics 14y agoThe new Route 66– at the dawn of the 21st century, and the consumer electric car... Yeah, maybe.
- potatolicious 14y agoNot really a surprise - I don't think there was really any doubt about the performance of the Tesla in normal weather. The NYC area right now is well above freezing, approaching +10C in the daytime, nowhere near the deep freeze that occurred during the NYT drive. This still doesn't put to rest the expected (but somehow controversial) concerns about lithium battery performance in cold weather. This concern IMO needs to be put to rest if electrics want to break into the mainstream market. Early adopters may be willing to plan judiciously around range and expected weather, but I doubt mainstream consumers will be so forgiving. Having a car of (somewhat) limited range lose a large chunk of its battery just sitting overnight in a parking lot, in weather that is cold but hardly unusual for the region, is a problem. That both on-board software and human advisers seem poorly prepared to compensate for this is hardly a nail in Tesla's coffin, but does need to be sorted out.
- ck2 14y agoIs it possible and would it help to warm the batteries ala glow plugs for diesel?
- NamTaf 14y agoI believe it presently does. In fact, I believe that's the reason why the battery charge level dropped overnight in Musk's presentation of data and why, according to some folk, plugging it in to a normal power socket isn't enough to actually charge it as the battery pack draws more power than the socket can supply simply keeping the thing warm. Such a process will of course drain the battery which still achieves the end result of 'can travel less distance on a full charge'.
- anonymfus 14y agoWould better thermal insulation help? Or it is already best economically viable?
- NamTaf 14y agoI've no idea, I'm no expert in the tech. I'm sure 'better' would always help (though not necessarily overnight when it's a case of just slowing equalisation since you're talking long timeframes) but I don't know if there is a both better and economically viable process?
- Shank 14y agoIt's worth pointing out that they're staying at the Milford SuperCharger quite a lot longer than Elon's data showed NY times did. They're charging it a lot more - and would even if it was too chilly out for the batteries to operate at optimal discharge rate, they'd still be in the clear as a result. This is more of a PR move - of course if you calculate it out it's possible - the NY Times driver wasn't staying at SuperChargers long at all and missed mark by 30mi.
- niggler 14y agoRegardless of the "success" in the trip, the ultimate failure was in Musk's petulant response.
- slantyyz 14y agoCompletely. And I would say the secondary failure is in the advice given to Broder over the phone. Had the people on the phone just told him to charge longer, anything Broder said about the extra time charging would have come across as a simple, forgettable nitpick. It's extraordinary events like getting stranded that readers remember.
- Cushman 14y agoIf I were Tesla PR, I'd jump on this. Drop everything else about the article; just throw a big party in DC in the morning, and ferry people to Boston for a big party the same evening (with refreshments and entertainment available in Newark and Milford, naturally). Get owners' clubs involved, make it an annual pilgrimage. Of course there may be a reason I'm not in PR.
- DannoHung 14y agoIf I were Tesla PR, I already orchestrated the entire thing, including instructing the CNN crew to fully recharge at every station and not stop overnight.
- hatcravat 14y agoThe overnight stop is really a red herring: The battery only lost about 5-7% of capacity overnight, which is much less than the difference between a standard charge (90% of capacity) and how much the Times charged the battery (72%). Actually, it's too bad CNN didn't stop someplace for the night just to prove this.
- DigitalSea 14y agoRegardless of how much warmer the weather is than when Broder drove the car. If Broder had charged the car completely instead of partially regardless of the obvious drop in capacity in colder weather he still would have made it. CNN have just proven the car is capable, cold weather aside nothing would be much different here. Are we forgetting the data from the NYT review clearly showed Broder driving around in circles in a car park? The CNN reporter even said he got lost and yet still made it with miles to spare in the batteries. When you consider the amount of on-board power drawing computing functionality, sensors and logging equipment on the Tesla 200+ miles is impressive. If you're buying an electric car for driving 200+ miles in one go, an electric car is certainly not for you. Tesla fills a niche of drivers who commute to and from work, occasionally to meetings and maybe the airport but don't expect luxury taxi service companies to start buying and driving Tesla electric cars any time soon... Quite personally I am sick of hearing about this whole situation. It's like watching a primary school fight, lots of name calling and accusation slinging, but no violence.
- lloeki 14y ago> Tesla fills a niche of drivers who commute to and from work, occasionally to meetings and maybe the airport The niche is in the price, not the use case, because you're describing what about 80% of the population does with their cars 95% of the time.
- DigitalSea 14y agoI believe the niche is partially the price and partially those who want to arrive to work in style. Manager, CEO, COO style employees are the kind of people who'd buy this for the attention and to reaffirm the statement, "Yeah, I'm rich, but I work for it"
- tomkarlo 14y agoSooo... pretty much anyone who buys a luxury car over $40K.
- TwiztidK 14y ago
- joshfraser 14y agoTesla are getting a ton of free press out of this story. Sometimes I think they pick these fights on purpose just to get all the free PR.
- analog 14y agoI doubt they orchestrated the original article. Their choice is pick a fight or let the article stand. Picking a fight looks like the better choice to me, though personally I have no interest in reading someone else's bunfight.
- OGinparadise 14y agoThat mere 70 miles of buffer made me a little nervous, especially after I missed an exit and added a few miles to the trip. I followed Tesla's recommendations and kept the cruise control pegged to between 60 and 65 much of the way and kept the climate control at 72 degrees. And I minimized stops. But I made it What's the point of having a car that costs north of $50K and as much as $90K if you have to worry about missing an exit? This whole thing is bad press for Tesla, they thought they had the "gotcha" moment ("he went in circles in the parking lot" for a whopping.......0.6 miles while trying to find the charging station) but it just showed a prospective buyer how fragile this very expensive car. Let me repeat it: this car is very expensive and cannot be relied to go for a few hundred miles because it has so many variables. This is a niche car at best, a rich person maybe can brag about it while having other normal cars. Hybrids would probably be best for me.
- rdl 14y agoI'd like a Model S (although, ideally, something more BMW 3-series sized, same performance, and slightly cheaper, and AWD), with the 300 mile range, specifically for daily use in the Bay Area. It is unlikely I would need to worry about range, and just plug in every night (although plugging in at the office would make sense, too) Being able to periodically ferry it between locations using the supercharger would just be a bonus; I'd be fine with a car which could never leave a 75 mile radius of Palo Alto, provided I also either had a second car (ideally diesel, 45+mpg or a diesel truck), or could rent one whenever I left. I suspect most people who can afford $100k cars can afford multiple cars, or don't do 400 mile road trips on a regular basis.
- dkhenry 14y agoI see you have never missed an exit on the NJ turnpike. Even with a ICE you can easily run out of gas due to the large distance between exits and Service plazas. Thats one _more_ point towards the car, Even during a normal disturbance it can still work just fine if you you know actually charge it.
- OGinparadise 14y agothey are a lot of differences: You can exit and drive a few miles into a town to find a gas station and fill up in 2 minutes. If you filled your tank you know what you have inside, it will not drop due to temperature (relatively speaking) A tow truck can ultimately bring you gasoline. All these things rule the electric car out for me and many others, unless I am worth $20 million and buy one as a third car. I'd be scared of running out of power all the time. Yes, for the record even with GPS I got lost.
- doktrin 14y agoThe constant back and forth on this issue (whether or not this luxury car can in fact drive further than the supermarket) feels absurd. I have to honestly say the Model S is very, very low on my list of cars-I-wish-I-had. It screams conspicuous and vapid consumption to the nth degree.
- bruceboughton 14y ago>> It screams conspicuous and vapid consumption to the nth degree. Unlike, say, gas-guzzling SUVs.
- doktrin 14y agoGas-guzzling SUVs can serve a legitimate purpose justifying their price point. Luxury electric cars don't, neither from a conservation, ecological or (apparently) practical standpoint.
- Yaggo 14y ago"I was given battery-conservation advice at that time (turn off the cruise control; alternately slow down and speed up to take advantage of regenerative braking) that was later contradicted by other Tesla personnel." The emphasized part makes no sense (vs. driving at constant speed), regen braking is not perpetual motion machine. Technology reporter should know that. Still amazing how such a foolish advice was given him by Tesla personnel.
- alan_cx 14y agoI kinda sit in the middle. We need this technology, and people like Musk pushing and investing in it. But equally, his attitude to criticism borders childish and is very off putting. What I don't get about any of this, from both sides, is that this is the early days of the technology and its clearly work in progress. As usual, early adopters pretty much know what they are investing in and expect and accept that there are going to be problems and that the systems are far from perfect. I mean, imagine a review of the first petrol engined cars, a few years after initial conception. Musk should be constantly reminding people that problems will happen, and this is the beginning of decades of development and evolution, while motoring petrol head journalists need to stop trying to pretend Musk is selling a perfect petrol car replacement, and that it is indeed work in progress at a relatively early stage. To me it is clear that the Tesla car is still problematic, but it is also clear that its improving at a decent rate. In a decade, I imagine the whole system will work flawlessly, ish. Sadly all I see are two camps, Musk supporters and petrol heads almost raging at each other like political parties, while Musk stirs it, resulting in non partisan parties look on aghast, keeping wallets well closed. As for the idea that this CNN review, just after a controversial one, would be anything other than perfect is a delusion. Even if we bin foil hat theories that CNN were soft on Tesla for what ever reason, Tesla would have done everything to ensure this test went perfectly and contradicted the previous one. What ever we are up to, if a test goes wrong, we would all make sure the next test was an improvement. If not, then we have no business in any form of development.
- analog 14y agoThe experience with Top Gear has probably influenced the reaction here. I don't find it childish to strongly defend your product if you believe a journalist has written a hack job on it.
- taligent 14y ago>I don't find it childish to strongly defend your product if you believe a journalist Childish really is the best word for it. It wasn't a measured, intelligent response. It came across as a "beat the journalist up" because they posted a bad review. Reminds me of the sort of thing you see bad restaurant owners do when they respond to diner's complaints.
- ZeroGravitas 14y ago"a route 30 miles longer that avoided New York City, and it's battery draining traffic congestion, altogether." I would have thought that slow, stop-start traffic is the ideal conditions for an electric car, both in terms of driving pleasure and energy use compared with traditional cars.
- krschultz 14y agoHe's talking about taking the Tappen Zee Bridge vs the George Washington Bridge. I actually used to live in Groton CT (the terminus of both trips) after graduating from the University of Delaware (the origin of both trips). I would never ever use the GWB. The extra 30 miles is always worth it. You can sit on the GWB and associated roads for 3-4 hours on a Friday night to go 10 miles. Not a good situation no matter what kind of car you have (and ironically, there aren't a lot of gas stations in that area, definitely not well marked).
- mninja 14y agoSitting in traffic with your A/C and onboard computer on drains the battery more.
- DanBC 14y agoTesla just needs to buy a bunch of gopros for all the people in Norway and Sweden who have Teslas. Let's see Teslas commuting to work in arctic midnight.
- brudgers 14y agoEvery time someone reads this, a kitten gets run over: "Instead, I found myself maneuvering around slower cars. Now, I normally spend most of my time on the New Jersey Turnpike out in the left lane going at least 10 or 15 miles an hour faster than I was in the Model S. But sitting in the middle lane, I was keeping up with traffic. I certainly didn't feel out of place -- except for the fact that I wasn't burning any gasoline." It's supposed to be a performance car. A proper review should imply hoonage and speeds likely to raise the author's insurance premiums. It shouldn't take the Consumer Reports first impression of the Nissan Leaf as it's model. The Tesla S is not a fucking Prius. The only thing more dull than hypermiling stories are hypermiling videos, and the only saving grace of this story is that we are spared those. How Musk can act incredulous over assertions that the Model S is impractical for US intercity travel while acknowleding one hour fuelings every three hours is beyond me.
- sukuriant 14y agoHe was already going 60-65. He just admitted to going 70-80 on the freeway; and, given the other cars, the speed limit is probably 60. I love speed as much as the next guy; but this was a review that, as far as I could gather, was CNN's version of peer reviewing the Time's article... and finding it wanting. A normal person isn't taking their car to the track. TopGear already did that test on an even more suited car. If you were testing the range of a Bugatti Veyron to see if it was useful as a commuter car, would you go flat out the whole way? Or, more realistically, if you were testing a Subaru WRX STi, or an Evo X, for its "normal driving conditions" range, would you be keeping your revs at 4-5k the whole way?
- ghurlman 14y agoThe speed limit on the NJ Turnpike is largely 65, but traveling at 70 - 80mph on the turnpike is normal, often the speed to just keep up with traffic, depending on the day/where you are on the road. Wanting to go 80 on the NJT isn't "taking it to the track", it's "driving from A to B".
- AlexeiSadeski 14y ago>How Musk can act incredulous over assertions that the Model S is impractical for US intercity travel while acknowleding one hour fuelings every three hours is beyond me. Bingo.
- BryantD 14y agoCan we get the Tesla logs of this trip as well?
- xwowsersx 14y agoMan I want this car badly.
- tjoff 14y agoHow well does the batteries in an electric car age? Will anyone be able to do this drive, under any conditions, in a Model S with batteries that are 2, 5 or 10 years old?