4 ms·
Military Laser Hits Battlefield Strength
- electromagnetic 18y agoSo this uses 150 kilowatts of energy, or basically the equivalent of the gunpowder in 3 .50 cal bullets. Wouldn't the more practical solution be to invent an extremely accurate like .70 cal bullet controlled by the same targeting system. A .50 cal rifle can target accurately at near 2km, and has a useful range of 7km. Heavy mortars (IE two-man military or truck towed, not the ones the terrorists are using) usually only reach 8km in range and the high trajectory and slow velocity probably make it exceptionally easy to target (compared to conventional supersonic artillery rounds). So I ask, wouldn't the simplest solution have been a highly accurate heavy caliber rifle with explosive rounds that can hit a mortar shell at the peak of its arc when it's moving the slowest. The high refire rate already achieved with naval defensive weapons would mean you could take a few dozen shots and account for any inherent inaccuracy in an explosion propelled projectile.
- blackguardx 18y agoThe difference is that a laser applies nearly 100% of its energy to the target (the rest being lost to atmospheric effects). A bullet loses energy quickly as it travels through the atmosphere. A laser also travels "at the speed of light," making targeting much simpler. A laser also travels in a straight line. A bullet is affected by gravity and wind, all of deflect it from its path and must be accounted for.
- electromagnetic 18y agoHah, read up on the Navy's railgun tests. They're expecting accuracy of 5 meters at 370km's. A bullet loses no energy to gravity, it just gets converted into potential energy. It also loses little energy to the atmosphere, it retains about 90% to impact.
- blackguardx 18y agoI didn't say a bullet loses energy to gravity. I said it affects the flight path. And if you think beyond high school physics for a second, you will realize that gravity does take away energy away from the collision if the target is at a higher elevation than the gun. The potential energy is useless in that situation. All that matters is kinetic energy.
- blackguardx 18y ago1. The application is question is shooting down missiles. Accuracy to a static target is moot. 2. 90% to impact? That is a useless statistic. At what range? What if the target is at a significantly higher elevation as in the case of a missile?
- jodrellblank 18y agoWhat is it about LASERs that make them so useful in so many domains?
- chaosmachine 18y agothey're a readily available source of coherent, monochromatic, collimated light.
- jodrellblank 18y agoBut why is that so good for telecoms signalling, precise cutting, spaceship propulsion, measurement, teleportation experiments, holding parts of highly accurate subatomic clocks, tripwire systems, optical media drives, igniting fusion reactions, pointers and targetting systems, interferometry, eye surgery, 3d scanners.. They are like many fundamental building block componenta in one.
- derefr 18y agoTo answer your question more bluntly: they are energy waves, and [or thus] they move quickly. All of these things could be done materially (signalling with sound waves in air, record players instead of optical media, pointing with a physical pointer, etc.) but coherent light can be moved around much more quickly, due firstly to the speed of light, but also due to the wave properties of reflection, refraction and diffraction. And, despite this ease of targeting, you can "load" as much, or as little, energy into the stream as you wish, because photons have negligible mass. Finally, the "coherent" part means that you actually get to keep these advantages over a distance, instead of having them stolen by the power law.
- froo 18y agoI spent a little while considering whether or not to post in this thread, but here goes.... All we need now is to figure out how to attach these frikkin' lasers to some sharks.