5 ms·
Just out of curiosity, but what exactly did you think the arrangement between you and Disqus was? Their service obviously saves bloggers a lot of hassle, and it
by danso 14y ago
Just out of curiosity, but what exactly did you think the arrangement between you and Disqus was? Their service obviously saves bloggers a lot of hassle, and it can't be free to maintain?
I don't mean to say that this justifies this perceived wrong, but it certainly justifies, from their standpoint, to think: "If you're going to use our service, for free, you should at least read our emails (and not filter them to the Spam folder)". Also on their side: they've allowed the ability to opt out.
So you can still drop the service on the grounds of principle, and technically, this is a "bait and switch"...but it's a pretty mild one.
- jacquesm 14y agoWhatever it was that I thought I signed up for, I explicitly did not sign up for an advertising tag, especially not a stealthy one, and on top of that not one that looks like an active endorsement on my part.
- FooBarWidget 14y agoYou agreed to their terms and conditions upon sign up. It says: "We may, without prior notice, change the Service;"
- jacquesm 14y agoAnd my terms of service read 'and if you change your terms of service in a way that I don't like I will disable your plug-in and I'll bitch about it'.
- patrickaljord 14y agoThat doesn't make any sense. You agreed to their terms of service and now you're complaining because it doesn't match your ideals. Disqus is a great service provided for free, what did you expect?
- jacquesm 14y agoI did not expect to see myself recommending products and services that I would not ever think of recommending to others and I would not expect to see my site change from non-commercial to commercial and I did not expect to see ads masquerading as regular content. Terms of service are a fig leaf, how you act is what matters and these actions are not acceptable, especially not for an opt-out that wasn't there when I signed up.
- patrickaljord 14y agoIn what way are they not acceptable? They are totally acceptable to me. They provide a great service for free and now they want to monetize it with ads, shocking! I think it's extremely generous and quite remarkable of them to offer both a cut and an option to opt-out. They should be rewarded for that, not blamed. I think the sense of entitlement you have knowing that disqus offered you a great and free service for years and now a way to opt-out or even make money is really disgraceful.
- jacquesm 14y agoYou do realize that such ads are called 'stealth' ads and are quite possibly not legal in plenty of places? What is acceptable for you and what isn't is your affair, just like it is my affair what I find acceptable. I don't think you're helping the discussion with your continued personal attacks ('entitlement', 'disgraceful') so I'll leave it at that.
- patrickaljord 14y agoThey are not stealth ads as they warned their users a long time ago. I learned about that a few months ago already. You can't blame them for your inability to read your email correctly. Second, you had pretty strong words against disqus calling their decision "bullshit" and encouraging some sort of boycott. All because a free service decided to start making money in order to survive by proposing optional ads with a cut for you to make money on their free service. Sorry, but the sense of entitlement is really too strong here to let go. Had to point it out.
- bcoates 14y agoBlockbuster, Zappos, and AOL have all been burned by having language in their ToSes to that effect. It's a bad idea if you want any legal cover from your TOS. IANAL, but this guy is and he says STOP PUTTING CLAUSES INTO YOUR CONTRACTS THAT SAY YOU CAN AMEND THE CONTRACT AT ANY TIME IN YOUR SOLE DISCRETION BY POSTING THE REVISED TERMS TO THE WEBSITE http://blog.ericgoldman.org/archives/2009/06/stop_saying_we_1.htm http://blog.ericgoldman.org/archives/2009/06/stop_saying_we_...
- 3327 14y agoThe OP was very clear, just in case some missed the point: OP does not like ad's and is unhappy with bait and switch. This is clear bait and switch, no denying that. As for the companies business and how they need to make money - that is another subject for another thread.
- HarleyP 14y agoSide-effects need to be explicit. When he registered did the ToS say this would be the behavior? There is no logic in your argument.
- danso 14y agoI hadn't seen the TOS back whenever he registered, but I would be quite surprised if the TOS didn't give the service the right to choose the content it would deliver to those who use its service. In fact, if it didn't, they should fire whoever is running their legal department. Perhaps you're confused to the purpose of a TOS. It is not a business plan where the company outlines their feature roadmap.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- jellicle 14y ago> Just out of curiosity, but what exactly did you think the arrangement between you and Disqus was? Obviously he thought, and was correct about thinking, that it didn't include ads. All the ex-post-facto justifications for the change boil down to something like "But didn't you realize that as an entity in a capitalistic society, the opposing party in your deal is always going to be seeking more revenue?" which is always true of every deal, can be used to justify any change whatsoever, and thus is a rather thin justification.