4 ms·
> In the case of the cars, without looking it up it is not obvious to me which is worse I wouldn't hire you either. > About the water Your example digs your
by stcredzero 14y ago
> In the case of the cars, without looking it up it is not obvious to me which is worse
I wouldn't hire you either.
> About the water
Your example digs your hole deeper. There's a fundamental difference between applying thermodynamics in this case, and the regenerative braking one. That you don't know that is what's damning.
- TillE 14y agoI guess the point was: because some nonintuitive things can happen, conservation of energy isn't real. Or something.
- makomk 14y agoFunnily enough, going further in stop-and-go urban traffic than on the highway doesn't violate the conservation of energy either. (Also, remember you can't just go arbitrarily slowly on the highway - that's unsafe and a lot of places ticket people for it.)
- mpyne 14y agoI've operated propulsion machinery completely submerged in water. Anyone who didn't understand that energy usage is approximately quadratic with respect to speed would be considered studderingly incompetent and would fail qualification at both ends of the boat. Of course if you don't believe me, perhaps you should ask Tesla Motors.... or look at the Prius's rated MPG for city/hwy.
- btilly 14y agoI wouldn't hire you either. I'll guess that you never passed any fluid mechanics courses either. See? I can return snark for snark. Now let's actually discuss some physics. There's a fundamental difference between applying thermodynamics in this case, and the regenerative braking one. That you don't know that is what's damning. For the same trip from New York to Boston in a Toyota Camry, traveling at 80 mph the whole way takes 2.75 times as much energy as traveling at 30 mph. See http://ocw.mit.edu/courses/physics/8-21-the-physics-of-energy-fall-2009/lecture-notes/MIT8_21s09_lec03.pdf http://ocw.mit.edu/courses/physics/8-21-the-physics-of-energ... and apply scaling factors to verify. That provides a lot of headroom to add starts and stops on the 30 mph trip without using more energy than the faster trip. In fact, even without regenerative braking, you could add in multiple stops/starts per mile and the slow trip still saves energy in a conventional car. (Well, until you consider rolling friction going up hills, I don't have a good back of the envelope for what that adds.) I'm being deliberately unfair to make a point here. Standard "highway driving" for EPA efficiency is assumed to be 60 mph. Traveling at 80 mph is a lot, lot worse than 60 mph. Elon knows this, and calls out the journalist's speed because Elon knows what difference this efficiency makes. If the highway trip is taken at 60 mph it is much harder for a slow trip to take less energy. Now do you understand that speed hurts efficiency?
- stcredzero 14y ago> See? I can return snark for snark. Now let's actually discuss some physics. Not snark. Also, already knew about the possible non-intuitive results with water. > If the highway trip is taken at 60 mph it is much harder for a slow trip to take less energy. Now do you understand that speed hurts efficiency? Hmmm, putting words in my mouth to spin it so it seems like my original position is actually yours and imply that I don't know a different basic bit of physics. (You can check my recent comment history.) Nope, definitely wouldn't hire you as a journalist.
- btilly 14y agoI have not put words in your mouth. Go back to http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5218597 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5218597 and look at the quote you were criticizing Broder for. Here it is. Based on that advice, I was under the impression that stop-and-go driving at low speeds in the city would help, not hurt, my mileage. You considered this proof that he didn't know basic physics, because obviously stop-and-go driving is inefficient. My point is that your criticism is wrong because this is actually a question of empirical fact that can - and does - go either way. (In fact in published mpg figures, the Toyota Prius does better in stop and go city traffic than on the highway. If you go significantly over 55 mph on the highway, you're probably getting worse highway mileage than the published figures.) ...imply that I don't know a different basic bit of physics. I make no claims on whether you understand how wind resistance works. I do claim that your initial comment showed no understanding for how important wind resistance is IN THIS CASE. But now I pointed it out, and then explained it with reference to actual energy loss for a popular model of car, and you have been pointed to the fact that published mpg figures for the Prius demonstrate that it leads to the very pattern that you thought Broder was an idiot for thinking possible. At this point if you believe in science and measurement, you've got to admit that your analysis missed something important, and you were wrong. If you're a mature person, you'd then apologize for some of the same things. Alternately you can demonstrate a willful denial of basic physics by continuing to insult me for having pointed out your mistake. But if you continue that path, I won't bother to respond because I trust that interested third parties can draw the correct conclusion.