4 ms·
Here's what I posted after the NYTimes review: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5204109 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5204109 Our culture is badly bro
by stcredzero 14y ago
Here's what I posted after the NYTimes review:
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5204109 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5204109
Our culture is badly broken. When "the social contract" for broad swathes of society is so little regarded that lying is a matter of course, then we have already reached worrying levels of dysfunction, of the sort that historians point out when they discuss the fall of the Roman Empire, Czarist Russia, or the USSR. A point all of those have in common: The denizens came to assume public information was false as a matter of course, as a time and sanity saving measure. Large swathes of our society think of lying, even when deceiving large swathes of the public, as a kind of sport, and profiting from such lying as a kind of serendipitous fortune to be exploited without conscience, like finding cash on the sidewalk.
Such attitudes are shoved in my face when I see exclamations like, "Pictures or it didn't happen!" It's the same when big media corporations trade in innuendo and conspiracy theories and deliberately sabotage the dissemination of knowledge for their own ends. Such attitudes are so pervasive, that large swathes of the population actually disbelieve in any kind of objective truth, and accept mere social proof as its substitute and superior.
It's entirely possible that the journalist in question is innocent of deception and only guilty of poor journalism and/or poor trip planning and/or insufficient UI design. However, the issue with the review and that of the social contract are entirely related. In a world where reality itself is relative and subject to social proof, there is no need to double check your facts or to prove the null hypothesis. In a world where science is just another fabricated self-serving belief system, there's no need to apply one's scientific literacy or application of physics learned in school when doing things like taking a car trip in winter. One only need know enough to read the dials and gauges to be a good consumer, then complain loudly if things do not go one's way.
True competence, be it in programming or journalism or any significant endeavor, requires diligence with and prostration to the truth. Our society as a whole has forgotten this and our society as a whole is oblivious to the price it is paying as a consequence.
Another way to think of it: Our society as a whole doesn't have the epistemological foundation needed for the level of technical sophistication it has.
EDIT: Some of my fellow HN-ers seem to suggest they hold such relativism as a world view. This warrants much reflection.
- aduitsis 14y agoExtremely insightful comment, thank you sir.
- shanselman 14y agoTHIS: "Another way to think of it: Our society as a whole doesn't have the epistemological foundation needed for the level of technical sophistication it has." Perfect.
- smutticus 14y ago"Our society as a whole doesn't have the epistemological foundation needed for the level of technical sophistication it has." Thank you sir for reminding me why I am quitting my job to begin a Master's degree in Technology and Public Policy. Those in the know with regards to technology and its impact will forever be limited by those not in the know. Maybe we will never agree on the means used to determine Truth, but we should coalesce around empiricism. Not because we need all be scientists, but because empiricism and its methods provide the best means by which the powerless may confront the deceptive and calcified agents of power.
- nazgulnarsil 14y agoI sympathize strongly with your comment. But, following your own standards, there should be a little voice of doubt in your mind about this narrative as well. Perhaps it seems that civilizations grow more corrupt over time merely because their ability to detect and disseminate knowledge of such corruption improves.
- stcredzero 14y ago> But, following your own standards, there should be a little voice of doubt in your mind about this narrative as well. That was written before Tesla's response. You're saying, that for the interest on impartiality, I should have doubted Tesla's side before I even read it? Huh?!? Does that make sense? As I stated elsewhere, someone can replicate both Tesla's side and Broder's side by redoing the trip both ways.
- 14y ago