6 ms·
It doesn't seem moral that the world doesn't invade North Korea and put an end to the insanity.
by guelo 14y ago
It doesn't seem moral that the world doesn't invade North Korea and put an end to the insanity.
- tptacek 14y agoMore people would die if we did than if we don't. Seoul is one of the most densely populated cities in the world, and it's extremely close to the border.
- guelo 14y agoThat's what they've been saying for 60 years with no end in sight. The other consideration is that neither South Korea or China wants a flood of refugees. But I tend to think that if China wanted it could be done and over quickly and the rebuilding could be assisted by the whole world through the UN.
- tptacek 14y agoI agree, although I'm probably no better informed than you are, that a China resolved to the elimination of the DPRK would result in the elimination of the DPRK.
- bfe 14y agoConventional wisdom is that China prefers to maintain the status quo in North Korea as a buffer against American power. Xi Jinping hasn't really signaled yet whether he will change direction on that. Yesterday the White House specifically referred to America's "nuclear umbrella" over South Korea, which is unusually explicit wording, so hopefully they are raising the pressure on China to do more to intervene. I don't think the DPRK could persist if China withdrew its support. I try to imagine a scenario for the incoming administrations in China and South Korea, working in cooperation with the U.S., to convince the DPRK to peacefully transition to a normalized and open country.
- Zancarius 14y ago> I don't think the DPRK could persist if China withdrew its support. I believe this is correct. I've read reports that China provides the North with about half (or more) of its food. I'd imagine a substantial portion of that goes to feed NK's military. The only solution will very likely involve China, and I can't imagine that they'll go willingly. They may change their mind if NK lobs an atomic weapon at the South or at US interests (continental if they can reach; elsewhere if not), but I'm dubious even that might work. Assuming the North's military leadership doesn't completely lose its few remaining marbles, they might believe that nuclear proliferation within (in the form of many functional, working weapons) gains them sufficient bargaining power that they can do whatever they want. In that circumstance, it's plausible that they might wind up stepping on China's toes. Although, I highly doubt this would happen either. It's depressing because there's very little that we can do, and China is unlikely to help for reasons bfe cited. They've literally starved out the population that could potentially overthrow the regime from within, so save convincing some segment of their army to stage a coup, all we can do is wait. It also doesn't hurt to spread stories like this one far and wide. The only problem is that the majority of people outside the Koreas (particularly those within the US) just don't care. It doesn't affect them, so why bother?
- PoliticsJunkie 14y agoThinking out of the box here, what about the West (US and Sout Korea) letting China take over North Korea. Make it part of China. Wouldn't that make it better for everyone involved?
- javajosh 14y agoYes. Only the South Koreans can make that call, as they have the most to lose. If they decided to invade, and asked for US assistance, I for one would support that, to the extent of volunteering to fight. Alas, from an historical standpoint, North Korea is a relatively small aberration as long as it remains isolated and weak. The thing that I don't understand is how such a repressive regime could possibly have developed nuclear weapons. It seems somehow unfair, not to mention dangerous for the rest of us, that advanced science can be done in such an environment. I've always assumed that anyone smart enough to do such work would be smart enough to refuse to do it. But I guess I am wrong.
- adrianm 14y agoHmm. I hear what you're saying, but I think you may be underestimating the cultural undercurrent present here. Intelligence does not automatically correlate to respecting freedom of thought or other Western ethical ideals.
- revelation 14y agoI guess the technology was a handout from the Soviet Union. I can't fathom that a country like North Korea would be capable of developing nuclear weapons on their own, when a highly advanced country like Iran can't do it in this day and age.
- tedunangst 14y agoNorth Korea has been working at it for a longer period of time?
- GregBuchholz 14y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abdul_Qadeer_Khan#North_Korea.2C_Iran_and_Libya http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abdul_Qadeer_Khan#North_Korea.2...
- rdl 14y agoNK bought their nuclear technology from a Pakistani, who is currently living comfortably in a house in Pakistan, protected by the Pakistani state (because he also gave them nuclear capabilities). He stole a lot of the technology from European companies where he worked. This guy (AQ Khan) provided resources to Iran as well (directly and indirectly via NK). The science isn't actually that hard (I'd feel comfortable I could design/build a gun-type fission weapon myself, given budget and resources, from open sources, with basic engineering education). The hard part is the smuggling, front companies, etc. to get the equipment and materials. I'm pretty sure by the time NK was looking at going nuclear, the SU wasn't particularly happy with NK. NK was closer to China, and SU didn't really support Chinese proliferation (there were substantial divisions on the SU-China border, after all...) China didn't really want NK to go nuclear, either.
- jrogers65 14y agoIt's OK to feel your emotions and make decisions based on them. Life isn't a business where everything comes down to a cost-benefit analysis. There are real people living in these conditions and I bet they're wondering why nobody is helping them. If you were in their shoes, how would you feel about our inaction? What if Nazi Germany stopped short of trying to invade western Europe and Russia yet still had it's concentration camps? Would you have argued that it's not worth the cost of war to put an end to them?
- tptacek 14y agoProbably not a great idea to start WW3 based solely on emotions.
- Osmium 14y ago> More people would die if we did than if we don't. Over what time scale? I'm not advocating military action--I don't know nearly enough to have an informed opinion--but it seems to me that military action could cost lives now, but save countless innocent North Koreans in the generations to come. One can think back to the Second World War and consider what the cost of inaction would have been there. Concentration camps should not exist and if all other avenues have been exhausted, at what point does one have to accept the risk of dying to end them? I don't live in South Korea, nor do I have family there, so I understand that words like this are easy for me and I don't pretend otherwise. This isn't our decision to make in the West. But there's something about standing by and doing nothing that just seems unconscionable to me. Are sanctions really going to stop this? And now they have nuclear weapons too? Can this ever get better without getting worse first?
- tptacek 14y agoThat's true if you believe the DPRK can survive over the long term. But the conventional wisdom is that it cannot; that it will inevitably disintegrate, especially if it can be prevented the use of allegiances and commercial relationships with other countries.
- drewcrawford 14y agoYou reach a certain point where the weight of the evidence suggests that the received wisdom of imminent collapse isn't correct. With North Korea, we (should have) reached that vantage point in about the mid-90s. The NK regime has survived, to date: two major power transitions, the financial collapse of its protecting superpower state, the worst famine in modern history, a full-scale ground and air invasion by a world superpower, a widely-known and well-documented human rights record that would shame Nazi Germany, openly kidnapping foreign citizens to be trained as spies and other major diplomatic kerfuffles in the same league that have previously started wars, and I think the longest and most severe economic isolation in the history of the United Nations. We're told breathlessly with each new development for the past 50 years that collapse is surely just around the corner. But I can think of very little that would seriously test the regime beyond what they have faced so far.
- phaus 14y agoThings just as bad were going on in Iraq and Afghanistan, but lots of people think they were unworthy causes. I know they were failures, but part of that stems from the lack of dedication and support we had for them.
- martinced 14y agoWhat is not moral is that there are still people willing to destroy the economical system of countries where people are, as of now, still free to talk and move. Once a state defaults it's typically followed by a more authoritarian regime. I cannot begin to understand how there are so many people asking for "more state" when you see what too much state leads too. It first invariably leads to default. Then to a more authoritarian regime. Then a planned economy and from there it's the infernal spiral down to mediocrity and tyranny. But of course people asking for more state will tell you that North Korea is not a good example of communism and that Argentina is not a good example of socialism. How convenient. The answer to our problems is not more state, but less.
- rosser 14y agoThe answer to our problems is not more state, but less. No, the answer is better state. In practice, that's seemed to correlate somewhat positively with less state, but it's by no means axiomatically so. Any assertion to the contrary is ideology. For existence proofs, plural, consider the Nordic states. They're more state than many, if not most, yet they're widely regarded as among the "best", even by objective measurements. Contrariwise, consider Somalia. That's about as least-state as you can get, and yet it's somehow not the very model of civilization...
- newbie12 14y agoThe Nordic super nanny state is something of a myth. All three have very open markets and size of government that is 50% of GDP or less (US is 42%). http://www.heritage.org/index/country/sweden http://www.heritage.org/index/country/sweden
- Al-Khwarizmi 14y agoThese GDP data appear frequently in this kind of discussions, but percent of GDP is a meaningless metric in practice. I have been to Sweden and to the US often and it's pretty obvious in day-to-day life that the state is much more involved in people's lives (for good and/or bad, I'm not discussing ideology) in the former than in the latter.
- newbie12 14y agoThe world did! 36,000 Americans died trying. The UN, led by the US, fought a brutal war in Korea from 1950-53 that nearly liberated North Korea...until Mao's Chinese army crossed into North Korea in overwhelming numbers in a surprise attack that resulted in the current stalemate. It was a global effort, over 1,000 Brits also died and hundreds from many other random countries gave their lives trying to free North Korea. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Korean_War http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Korean_War
- yareally 14y agoIt would seem the UN/US's previous attempt to invade is what keeps us from trying it again. That is, fear of a reprisal from China once again. From watching documentaries on the Korean War from the point of China crossing the Yalu River into North Korea onward, it seemed like not one GI would want to face the seemingly endless waves of Chinese Infantry again. We definitely underestimated the motives and preparedness of the Chinese at the time. Any future action on North Korea without China's approval would definitely not be a good outcome for the UN or the nations involved.
- mseebach 14y agoMore immediately, the world's largest standing army and nuclear weapons also enter into the equation.
- mtts 14y agoThat's one way of putting it. Another, more correct way, would be to state North Korea invaded South Korea and the US (and its allies) stepped in to stop them. They did this not to "free North Korea" but to prevent "communism" from overrunning one of its allies. (They were also so succesful at it they pushed back North Korea almost all the way up to the Chinese border, which got China very nervous, leading to them getting involved as well).
- rdl 14y agoI personally have no moral problem with overthrowing corrupt states -- it is individuals who have rights, not states. I don't believe humans born in North Korea are less deserving of freedom than humans born in Norway. From a purely practical perspective, it would be difficult for an external power (other than perhaps China) to force regime change in North Korea. "If you strike a king, you must kill him" -- attempting to change the NK government through force and failing is worse than doing nothing at all, since it puts Seoul at risk, and would also make life worse for North Koreans, including innocent conscripts to their military. About the only places I could see raising enough private force to successfully execute regime change against a corrupt government are in Africa: Equatorial Guinea, Zimbabwe, Swaziland, etc. But it's also immoral to force private citizens in a place like the US to support a state effort to regime change (and, it's proven to be politically and militarily inefficient or ineffective in Iraq and Afghanistan...) Maybe anonymous currency will give us kickstarter for coups ("Assassination Politics"), someday soon. Combine that with drones and private special operations forces and things can change.