3 ms·
I think you might be confusing beauty with design. The HN favicon is not beautiful at all. It's not "good-looking". But when I look at 20 tabs open, you can in
by crazygringo 14y ago
I think you might be confusing beauty with design.
The HN favicon is not beautiful at all. It's not "good-looking". But when I look at 20 tabs open, you can instantly tell at a glance which ones are Hacker News -- or in a list of bookmarks. That's good design. It's working.
A bad favicon, on the other hand, is reddit's [1], for example. It tries to cram the whole reddit "head" into a 16x16 space, with a small white head against a light blue background (too little contrast, especially against a light-gray tab), with thin black lines. Glancing at it in a list of tabs or bookmarks, it doesn't stand out at all (due to bad "background-y" color choices), and isn't easily recognizable at all (too much detail, no obvious clear central element).
[1] http://reddit.com http://reddit.com
- rcgs 14y agoJust because something is functionally acceptable, does not mean it is well designed.
- pubby 14y agoIn my experience the Hacker News icon is one that gets confused with icons on my tab bar. Colored squares are only easily recognizable if they have a unique color, which obviously won't happen with the billions of sites out there. Try opening http://blogsofnote.blogspot.com/ http://blogsofnote.blogspot.com/ , http://www.homedepot.com/ http://www.homedepot.com/ , and http://8days.nl/ http://8days.nl/ at the same time. See the problem?
- bconway 14y agoGetting a little off-topic, but my favorite two to mix up: http://www.outback.com/ http://www.outback.com/ , http://www.consumerreports.org/ http://www.consumerreports.org/