5 ms·
The minute you standardize something, you make it meaningless. Indeed. Expressing units of measurement in terms of feet or meters? Standardization makes them m
by yummyfajitas 18y ago
The minute you standardize something, you make it meaningless.
Indeed. Expressing units of measurement in terms of feet or meters? Standardization makes them meaningless. Instead, I'll just wave my hands in the air and say "roughly this long." And (X)HTML standards? Don't get me started. Lets all just throw angled brackets to the browser, that's far more meaningful.
Incidentally, your actual complaint seems to be that some existing standardized tests are poorly designed. This is a problem of test design, not standardization.
- tome 18y agoNo, his actual complaint is once you standardize a test, schools with a lot of resources will "teach to the test", giving their students an advantage.
- yummyfajitas 18y agoThat's not a bad thing for a sufficiently well designed test. Here are examples of decent tests which I taught to. "Teaching to the test" and "teaching calculus" were basically identical. http://cims.nyu.edu/~stucchio/classes/fall2008/2005Spring1aFinal-pub.pdf http://cims.nyu.edu/~stucchio/classes/fall2008/2005Spring1aF... http://cims.nyu.edu/~stucchio/classes/fall2008/2007Fall1aFinal.pdf http://cims.nyu.edu/~stucchio/classes/fall2008/2007Fall1aFin... http://cims.nyu.edu/~stucchio/classes/fall2008/2008Spring1aFinal.pdf http://cims.nyu.edu/~stucchio/classes/fall2008/2008Spring1aF...
- unalone 18y ago"Teaching to the test" and "teaching calculus" were basically identical. I'd argue that if that's how math is being taught, there's a problem. "Teaching to the test" taught me to hate math in high school. In middle school, we were given a brilliant teacher who was allowed to teach however he wanted, and we left 8th grade understanding trigonometry better than most of the high schoolers we were with. Have you read Paul Lockhart's "A Mathematician's Lament"? That highlights the problems fundamental with the current math curriculum. From the tests that you linked me to, with all due respect, it doesn't look like you're doing anything different: you're spitting out formulas to be memorized. That's not math: that's mechanics. I hate that students are taught like that.
- yummyfajitas 18y agoThe mechanics are important, and calc 1 is the course in which they are taught. If the mechanics of algebra and calculus are not second nature to you, everything that follows will be almost impossible. Similarly, when learning programming, you need to learn to write syntactically correct code, and when learning a foreign language you need to memorize vocabulary. It isn't fun, but it is necessary. Later courses are more focused on mathematical reasoning, and tests reflect this as well. For example: http://www.math.rutgers.edu/grad/phd_requirements/written_qual.html http://www.math.rutgers.edu/grad/phd_requirements/written_qu... These exams are also pretty tough to game (even though they are standardized); the easiest way to teach to the qual is to teach how to reason about real/complex analysis and algebra. You don't seem to agree with the curriculum. Lockhart's article claims that courses like Calc are not well suited for elementary school math (and I agree). That's an orthogonal issue. The calc tests do a decent job of measuring what they are trying to measure: how well students understand the mechanics and concepts of differentiation and integration.
- unalone 18y agoOkay, I'm sorry. I overgeneralized. The minute you standardize something and use it as a method of competition - be it GPA or SAT score or pretty much anything else where you accept people into something based on a number - you make that number meaningless. The presence of numbers means that people are suddenly able to hack the system, and that means that the numbers don't mean a thing at all. They are no longer indicative of good performance.
- jacoblyles 18y agoI would be willing to bet that there is some correlation between a student's performance on the SAT and their ability to complete college-level coursework. After all, it is not mandatory that colleges accept it, and most seem to think it is worth their while. Do you think the difference between an 800 and a 1400 student is "meaningless"?
- unalone 18y agoIt depends entirely on what kind of person that 1400 student is. Maybe I have a 1400 without studying. Or maybe I spent an hour a day every day for three years so that I could get that 1400. I have a friend who got a 2390 on the SATs, 800s in something like 6 SAT2s, all because she studied for them nonstop. If she hadn't studied, she wouldn't have that same score. The insidious part is that we're taught that the difference between a 2390 and a 2400 is more than the difference between a 2380 and a 2390. Either you're "perfect", or you're not. That doesn't mean perfect people rise to the top. It means that "perfect" students are the ones who waste their lives studying to look better on paper, when in reality they're just wasting their time on something meaningless.
- jacoblyles 18y agoI would be willing to bet that the student with the self-discipline necessary to study until he raises his grade by 600 points (a near impossibility) and the student who is bright enough to score a 1400 without studying are both better college prospects than the student that scored an 800, on average. I agree that too much can be read into tests, but to say they are meaningless is to overstate the case.