7 ms·
Call me the village idiot but is this good or bad?
by adamnemecek 14y ago
Call me the village idiot but is this good or bad?
- tptacek 14y agoGood. Infrequent colliding patent applications are cheaper to resolve, and prior art challenges get stronger.
- DannyBee 14y agoWhat he said (i'm a registered patent attorney). It's mostly good, though there was some bad/ambiguous wording in the original AIA that is now "mostly fixed". The thing to remember is that first-to-file doesn't mean that if i file a patent app on something you invented, before you do, that I get a patent. It's about what happens when two people file patent apps for things they can both prove they invented. Before, there was a complex system of colliding patent resolution. Now, it's "first guy to file wins". More things are also now prior art. You can't get around prior art by showing you invented before the prior art was published, for example.
- bo1024 14y agoThank you, this: > The thing to remember is that first-to-file doesn't mean that if i file a patent app on something you invented, before you do, that I get a patent. It's about what happens when two people file patent apps for things they can both prove they invented. was very helpful in clarifying.
- Daniel_Newby 14y agoBad, horrifically bad. An insider can find a trade secret, that may not even be recognized as a trade secret, and leak it to another company for patenting. The true inventor then gets their business shut down. Another failure mode is that computer spies steal the IP via a software security flaw, then patent it as their own independent reinvention.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- icebraining 14y agoThat wouldn't be a problem if the original creator had published or patented the invention her/himself. Which is what the patent system is designed to encourage.
- Daniel_Newby 14y agoSuppose you come up with a jig for drilling holes in engine blocks. To you it is just a cost of doing business, like stocking the bathrooms with toilet paper. Your competitor can "invent" it fraudulently, file a patent, and blow your factory out of the water.
- icebraining 14y agoIf you just want to protect yourself, just publish it somewhere. Prior art still exist with first-to-file, just not secret prior art. See Defensive publication[1], which isn't exactly a new concept, even in US patent history. [1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Defensive_publication http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Defensive_publication
- lusr 14y agoBut then aren't you potentially giving away your competitive advantage? Let's say I invent a new search engine, Poople. I don't have much money to patent it. But I can't keep the details secret either lest somebody else patent it. But by publishing the details defensively, my competitor with deep pockets, Paapo, goes and reimplements my algorithm and wipes me out of the marketplace. Which part of the story did I get wrong?
- icebraining 14y agoI don't understand, why can't you keep it secret? Daniel_Newby talked about rogue employees, but you probably don't have them if you can't afford $10k for the patent. So, how exactly would your competitors get hold of it?