2 ms·
Where do you get that the author wants to completely remove the option of driving? For example, from the author's web site I read that he has a car. Based on t
by dalke 14y ago
Where do you get that the author wants to completely remove the option of driving? For example, from the author's web site I read that he has a car.
Based on the linked summary, "If the function of parking in these places was to enable growth and development, the data suggests they were abysmal failures." What this paper says is that increasing parking does not help the city, economically speaking.
If the thesis is correct - which the data seems to support - then having cars diminishes the options for those who want a "vibrant city." If you're in favor of options, then surely you should be in favor of no-car parts of town, no?
If you're in favor of more options, then (as the author comments on a link from his home page), do you think that "factors like suburban infrastructure and the distance to most business centers and even the distance between many stores have made people reliant on motor vehicles" and reduced the transportation options?
You write that you don't want to remove options. The issue seems to be that some options have already been removed, and should be restored.
At the very least, it would get the cycle-only weirdos and walking fetishists out of the parts of town that you want to drive to.
- jacques_chester 14y ago> * which the data seems to support* Which the hand picked examples seem to support. Any time I see "country/state/city did X and got result Y" I am immediately suspicious of the lack of broadly sampled statistics. It's very easy to cherrypick examples for and against any policy setting you care about.
- dalke 14y agoSure. Now what's the evidence - hand-picked or otherwise - that suggests that increased support for cars enables growth and development? It seems like it would be an easy study to carry out, if it were the common case. In any case, my question was 'Where do you get that the author wants to completely remove the option of driving?'