5 ms·
"Robust" seems to be defined as "number of services in the city." If there's more support for cars, then those services get pushed outside of the city, or the
by dalke 14y ago
"Robust" seems to be defined as "number of services in the city."
If there's more support for cars, then those services get pushed outside of the city, or the city expands in area (if possible). Both trigger a higher need for cars. Venice can't expand, automobile traffic is mostly impossible, and also, the population is decreasing, especially in the historic old city, so likely not a good reference.
My observation is that cars "swarm" to the carrying capacity of the city, so that every city will have cars unless they are prohibited either by law or lack of drivable roads. After all, cars are really convenient, so people who can afford cars will use them until it's more convenient to use other means, like walking, biking, mass transit or (in a few places) animal-drawn carts. Therefore, seeing a lot of cars in a city isn't itself meaningful.
The question then isn't one of swarming, but of the response to the swarming. What are the effects of making it easier to commute by car? That's what this study appears to answer.