4 ms·
Venice is clogged with boats. These are basically cars on water. That their "roads" are flooded all the time is a technicality.
by astrodust 14y ago
Venice is clogged with boats. These are basically cars on water. That their "roads" are flooded all the time is a technicality.
- mikeash 14y agoWhen I visited (five years ago or so), boats were at least an order of magnitude less common in Venice's canals than cars are on the roads of a typical city, perhaps two or three orders of magnitude. It's far from a technicality.
- dalke 14y agohttp://www.italymag.co.uk/italy/venice/canal-traffic-getting-venetians-angry http://www.italymag.co.uk/italy/venice/canal-traffic-getting... - "Venice may have no cars but it has plenty of boats and their number has been on the increase over the past years. So much so that the usually tranquil canals of Venice now at times resemble the more chaotic traffic of Rome or Milan." I counted about 500 boats on the Grand Canal using Google's map imagery, either in motion or moored. (From the train station to Piazza San Marco.) The distance is ~3km. How do you map that to car traffic? Boats carry more than cars and a vaporetti caries more than a bus. After all, the boats carry a good fraction of the 18 million tourists per year. Boats also need more space and go at different speeds. Did you factor in wake pollution? Quoting the quite work from WPI (http://www.wpi.edu/Pubs/E-project/Available/E-project-122107-161101/unrestricted/Venetian_Boat_Traffic_and_Its_Environmental_Impacts.pdf http://www.wpi.edu/Pubs/E-project/Available/E-project-122107... ) "it is the only place in the world whose method of transportation has the literal ability to destroy the city." It also describes the effects of noise pollution, and the over 100 years of various attempts at traffic control. Given all of these differences, how did you base your comparison of the congestion of cars in a normal city vs. that of boats in Venice?
- megablast 14y agoThis is a joke, right? Most of the boats are moored and do nothing. They rarely kill someone, or have a dangerous accident. Anybody who has actually been to Venice can clearly see the difference. I mean, they have ambulance boats and deliver boats and garbage boats, but boats are not a problem. Most of the boats you will ever see are the bus boats, or gondolas.
- dalke 14y agoI have been to Venice. It has crowded river traffic. And most of the cars in a city are parked, and do nothing. Did you read any of the links I posted? The first says "There has been an extraordinary high number of boat accidents, people ending up in the water and general confusion since many are not used to the complex canal traffic code where imaginary lines mark lanes that you are not supposed to cross." Boats are definitely a problem. That WPI report I posted describes many of the problems with boats in Venice, including how they have "the literal ability to destroy the city" through wake damage, with pictures of what some of that that damage looks like and damage. Yet only 3% of boat traffic follow the posted speed limits. (And I know that that report doesn't go into the full details. Wake damage also increases the amount of rotting in the buildings, because submerged wood and dry wood rot at a slower rate than wood which is both wet and exposed to air, which the wake in Venice exacerbates.) My question to you was, how do you compare car traffic to boat traffic? Your response seems to be that you base it on the number of deaths or dangerous accidents. I thought surely that "destroy the city" quote would help you understand that you have an incomplete understanding of the issues. BTW, if deaths and dangerous accidents were the key factors to "clogged" traffic, then NYC's traffic congestion could be solved with a 5mph speed limit. You wrote "Most of the boats you will ever see are the bus boats, or gondolas". The traffic counts from that WPI report says that gondolas "represent a tiny portion of overall boat traffic in Venice" - except around the tourist area of La Piazza San Marco. It gives a breakdown. Gondole "account for 4% of the traffic in Venice" and "turismo boats account for only 40% of the total traffic." 44%+4% < 50%. The majority of boat traffic, though just barely a majority, were service, merchant, and sport boats. (I checked. The vaporetti are classified as turismo boats for purposes of this analysis.) So the reason that vaporetti and gondole are most of what you saw would be because you were a tourist, in the tourist areas, where the boat traffic more caters to you and people like you. Doesn't all this suggest that you don't understand the traffic issues in Venice enough to be able to make a comparison with "swarming" car traffic?
- mikeash 14y agoAccording to this article, Venice has 26 miles of canals: http://www.canalvoyagers.com/2012/does-birmingham-have-more-canals-than-venice/ http://www.canalvoyagers.com/2012/does-birmingham-have-more-... I picked an arbitrary American city of similar population that I'm familiar with to compare. Harrisonburg, VA has over 300 "lane miles" of streets: http://www.harrisonburgva.gov/sites/default/files/CMO/files/press_release/2012/11-07-2012%20Upcoming%20Street%20Closures%20for%20Paving.pdf http://www.harrisonburgva.gov/sites/default/files/CMO/files/... I'm not sure if a two-way road counts as one or two lanes for that count, but suffice to say that, despite having fewer people, Harrisonburg has roughly an order of magnitude more streets than Venice has canals. Venice's canals aren't appreciably more crowded from what I remember, which supports my "order of magnitude" claim. Alas, I couldn't find any statistics on the total number of boats in Venice, which really would be the best measurement here. But canal-miles seems like a decent proxy.