3 ms·
How is the analysis flawed? It specifically looks at density. Quoting from the paper: > We analyzed a dozen historically dense, small cities from around the co
by dalke 14y ago
How is the analysis flawed? It specifically looks at density. Quoting from the paper:
> We analyzed a dozen historically dense, small cities from around the country in which the shares of residents getting to work by automobile range from 43 to 91 percent. We compared the rates of automobile use to the number residents and employees per square mile.
The underlying abstract says:
> Theory suggests that as automobile mode share increases in a city, the amount of land used for transportation also increases, whereas the land available for other uses decreases. This can result in a loss of activities from the city. This study compiles data from 12 cities in the United States to test these theoretical relationships. The findings suggest that on average each increase of 10 percentage points in the portion of commuters traveling by automobile is associated with an increase of more than 2500 m2 of parking per 1000 people and a decrease of 1700 people/km2.
It's saying that the more the city promotes car commuting, the fewer activities are in the city ("decreased robustness").
Small cities can also be dense cities. The paper included Cambridge, MA and Berkeley, CA in the study. Both have populations around 110,000 with a relatively dense population.
- Retric 14y agoCongestion is fairly independent of the amount of parking in a city. It also pushes people to use public transit where available. Public transit requires public buy in or it's not viable. Increased public transit allows for increased density, but in no way increases the carrying capacity of the local road system pushing up demand for public transportation further. In other words think of congestion as the engine of public transportation systems. Now, looking a small city's inside major metro areas vs outside major metro areas congestion is vary different. PS: Not to mention the relative student populations have direct effects on car ownership. Now, if they had looked at more city's this would have been less of an issue, but look at the 12 chosen.
- dalke 14y agoThanks. I didn't realize this was a paper on congestion. I couldn't find mention of that in the linked-to page, nor is it mentioned in the abstracts of the relevant paper. So I'm confused about how that's related to the analysis.