4 ms·
>> Meanwhile, in psychology, virtually all ideas are excuses for debates between differing factions. > I'm not aware of any serious debates against cognitive p
by lutusp 14y ago
>> Meanwhile, in psychology, virtually all ideas are excuses for debates between differing factions.
> I'm not aware of any serious debates against cognitive psychology.
That's not what I said -- read it again. I said that factions within psychology differ about which of them is real, is scientific. For example, clinical psychology and psychiatry famously doubt the validity of the other. But neither of them have scientific evidence to support their claims, which is why that debate goes on and on.
Before you make a predictable objection, remember that in real science, fields are united by theory, not divided. Genetics doesn't only guide the activities of geneticists, it unites all of biology. SO does evolution, in exactly the same way -- any evidence that either supports or casts doubt on evolution changes the entire field of biology at once. This pattern is true of all legitimate sciences -- all of them are simultaneously defined and united by their theories. It is not true of psychology, which has factions that pursue similar subjects but come to diametrically opposite conclusions, with no on noticing or caring. The reason? Everyone tries to describe, but no one tries to explain.
> Psychology is an intrinsically much more difficult field than physics. Comparing other fields to it is what is disingenious.
1. Unless you're planning to invent a new word, do look up the word "disingenuous".
2. There is precisely one kind of science. Science is not an ice cream store with dozens of flavors -- science has one flavor. Any scientific field can be compared to any other scientific field as to methods and results. When this comparison is made with psychology, psychology fails the comparison, as the more candid commentators within the field freely acknowledge (see below).
> Cognitive psychology is the future of psychology.
Yes which partly explains why psychology is being replaced by neuroscience.
> It is perfectly scientific ...
Scientific fields craft and then test falsifiable scientific theories, explanations. Cognitive psychology can only describe, a failing freely acknowledged by its practitioners.
http://www.simplypsychology.org/science-psychology.html http://www.simplypsychology.org/science-psychology.html
A quote: "Despite having a scientific methodology worked out (we think), there are further problems and arguments which throw doubt onto psychology ever really being a science."
I could produce any number of quotes like the above, included in the papers of psychology's honest advocates and supporters, but I don't think it will make any difference -- your mind is made up and you refuse to be confused by the facts.
- nessus42 14y ago> Before you make a predictable objection, remember that in real science, fields are united by theory, not divided. You are ignorant on the history of science. Read Kuhn's The Structure of Scientific Revolutions. It will set you straight. > Scientific fields craft and then test falsifiable scientific theories, explanations. Cognitive psychology can only describe, a failing freely acknowledged by its practitioners. You cherry pick your quotes. Cognitive psychology is just like any other science. It constructs models, uses those models to make predictions, and then performs empirical experiments to test the accuracy of the models. If you don't understand that science is about models, then you don't understand science.