4 ms·
Tesla previously accused BBC's Top Gear of airing a "phony" review and sued them. The case was thrown out by a judge who ruled that the review was essentially t
by eli 14y ago
Tesla previously accused BBC's Top Gear of airing a "phony" review and sued them. The case was thrown out by a judge who ruled that the review was essentially true and that no reasonable person would draw untrue conclusions from it. (my words)
I haven't read every last word on the case, but it seems to me that Top Gear gave Tesla a very harsh review... but that they didn't cheat or do anything really wrong.
IMHO, I would at least give the NYTimes a chance to respond before jumping to any conclusions.
Top Gear's take on the lawsuit: http://transmission.blogs.topgear.com/2011/04/02/tesla-vs-top-gear-andy-wilman-on-our-current-legal-action/ http://transmission.blogs.topgear.com/2011/04/02/tesla-vs-to...
Tesla's reply:
http://www.teslamotors.com/forum/forums/how-we-see-it-top-gear-lawsuit http://www.teslamotors.com/forum/forums/how-we-see-it-top-ge...
Article on case being thrown out for a second time: http://www.guardian.co.uk/media/2012/feb/23/top-gear-libel-case-tesla-struck-out http://www.guardian.co.uk/media/2012/feb/23/top-gear-libel-c...
- smackfu 14y agoAnd that's with the UK libel laws, which wikipedia describes as: "English defamation law puts the burden of proof on the defendant, rather than the plaintiff, and is considered an impediment to free speech in much of the developed world. "
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- ImprovedSilence 14y agoI like Tesla, and wish them really well, but it's TOP GEAR... I love Top Gear, but to expect any sort of honest, unbiased, and completely factual review from them is madness in the first place. That's really what makes the show so great is that it is nothing but jokes. The only thing in it though, is that there's a little bit of truth behind every funny joke...
- Jamiecon 14y agoAgreed. I love Tesla. I'm really excited by what they're doing, and have nothing but admiration for Elon Musk. However, Top Gear have made their reputation winding people up. He was being pretty touchy by responding. Here's what I posted at the time: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2856821 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2856821 Of course, only time will tell in the case of the NYT.
- cowkingdeluxe 14y agoSo in summary, while Top Gear was correct in saying it had a 55 mile range with the way they were driving it on their race track, they falsely claimed that the car ran out of charge and had to be pushed into a garage. Instead they just turned off the car and pushed it into a garage. But the judge said that this is the kind of thing you expect from Top Gear as an entertainment show and it was ok to say it ran out of charge?
- eli 14y agoWell, a claim can't be libelous if it's true, regardless of how entertainingly it is presented. I didn't mean to re-litigate the case. You can read what the judge actually wrote here: http://www.onebrickcourt.com/files/cases/tesla_73294.pdf http://www.onebrickcourt.com/files/cases/tesla_73294.pdf The more interesting bits are towards the bottom.
- aeturnum 14y agoIf I remember correctly, Top Gear did not say the roadster ran out of batteries and had to be pushed. Rather, they said if it ran out of batteries, you may have to push it, and demonstrated with the car turned off. This looks bad, but isn't technically libel.
- grecy 14y ago...and is as useless as showing pushing any car ever made because it ran out of it's primary energy source (usually gasoline).
- nvmc 14y agoExcept that, you know, gas is everywhere and a tank lasts more than a hundred miles.
- grecy 14y ago> Except that, you know, gas is everywhere and a tank lasts more than a hundred miles. Not accurate on both counts. 1. If I drive East West or North from my house right now on major national highways, I won't find a gas station for many hundreds of KMs in any direction. 2. The Veyron will drain it's gas tank in ~10 minutes, as will other high-performance cars that achieve 1/4 mile results similar to the Model S. http://www.automobilemag.com/reviews/driven/1206_2013_bugatti_veyron_16_4_grand_sport_vitesse/ http://www.automobilemag.com/reviews/driven/1206_2013_bugatt...
- aidos 14y agoHN discussion on it at the time: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2400822 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2400822
- alan_cx 14y agoTop Gear's review was mostly very positive. Tesla picking up on the "bad" only advertised the "bad" to any one who hadn't seen the Top Gear review. Now we might see the same thing again here with the NYT. I'm all for electric cars, seems to me to be the future. But if Musk and Co will insist on reacting like a scolded car every time some reviewer says something negative, in a really over sensitive way, they aint never gonna look good. On top of that, they are aggravating relationships that could be crucial in the future. Dunno about the NYT, but I can see Top Gear just ignoring them, even when the car does improve. And there would come a time when TG does say, "yes this car is now practical". Well, there might have been. Who knows now. Sad that Musk is still crying over the TG "BS" too. Seems a bit of a grudge holder, even when proved wrong in law. I really like Musk's usual style and what he stands for, I also think he is doing a great job developing these cars, and soon, he will get there, but all this is a real turn off to me. And I can't help thinking he is making his own life worse with these reactions.
- stcredzero 14y ago> Sad that Musk is still crying over the TG "BS" too. Seems a bit of a grudge holder, even when proved wrong in law. Ronald Reagan's publicists used to love it when Frontline would have some scathing exposé of the administration, so long as they accompanied it with stock video of Ronald Reagan going around looking presidential, cutting ribbons at new senior care centers and such. It didn't matter if the announcer was discussing his cutting funds for such places. The text of the message didn't matter to them at all, only the images. We think of ourselves as lofty, intelligent Homo sapiens, but we really mostly operate on an ape-like, "monkey-see, monkey do," level. If you put yourself in shoes where such effects are really significant and cost you money or valuable publicity, I think you'd start to understand a bit more. It's much the same with various forms of prejudice and "oversensitivity." It's difficult to really understand the costs to all parties involved, short of direct experience.
- omni 14y ago> proved wrong in law. There is no such thing. Law is inherently subjective.