12 ms·
The reporter claims the car informed him that "charging complete". That is not the same thing as "you have full range". He also clearly states he was in contact
by Shivetya 14y ago
The reporter claims the car informed him that "charging complete". That is not the same thing as "you have full range". He also clearly states he was in contact with Tesla throughout the drive and they provided advice, sometimes wrong.
Plus the real negative part of the article that Musk is glossing over is, having to turn off heat in a vehicle just to get somewhere, got to be loads of fun in the summer too.
So what we have is possible confusion on part of the reporter or bad UI design. Either way it only points out that a 100k electric car is not a road trip car. Its a trip for suburbanites or similar. Sure you "can" do a long trip but you don't have the range of alternative a normally fueled vehicle has.
battery powered cars are an interesting technology, I am not quite in agreement they are ready for prime time. Considering the range limits of the top of the line I doubt many would be satisfied with the entry level model.
The big automakers are investigating many different fuel systems simply because they know any replacement to truly take hold has to be simple enough for anyone. It just has too work, there is no place for a list of "buts"
- jonknee 14y ago> Plus the real negative part of the article that Musk is glossing over is, having to turn off heat in a vehicle just to get somewhere, got to be loads of fun in the summer too. You "have" to do the same thing in a gas powered car if you don't fill up the tank when given the chance.
- ken_railey 14y agoWhat? Using the heater does not affect range in a gas powered car.
- jonknee 14y ago> got to be loads of fun in the summer too.
- ken_railey 14y agoThis part of the quote was added after I replied
- StavrosK 14y agoThe cooler does, though (parent might be referring to the "in the summer" part).
- jessaustin 14y agoSure, but using the A/C certainly does.
- ken_railey 14y agoAs I mentioned, this was added in an edit - but even the A/C doesn't affect range as much as you might think. It is roughly ~8% in your typical ICE, which is less than rolling your windows down at highway speeds. No idea what the effect of running AC on a Tesla's range is though. www.sae.org/events/aars/presentations/2004-hill.pdf
- jessaustin 14y agoWhen I first heard the A/C vs. windows-down comparison it struck me as non-intuitive. I eventually reasoned that having windows down at speed results in moving much more air through the cabin than the A/C does. It takes work to move air, but it also takes work to run the compressor. There would have to be a break-even point at which having e.g. the driver's window and the rear passenger's window down a couple of inches each is cheaper than the A/C. Interestingly, the graphs on pages 14 and 15 of the linked report don't appear to support your point. That is, the green curve is strictly less than the blue curve at all investigated speeds.
- kgermino 14y ago> Using the heater does not affect range in a gas powered car. It typically does (though not as much as the chiller would). There's two costs to using the heater: 1. The electricity to power the fan comes from the engine. I'm not sure how much of an impact this actually is (depends on the power the fan needs) but there's something there. 2. The heat from the heater comes from the engine block, which cools the engine. On cold days (<15 F) this can have a huge impact on the engine's temperature and will often cool the engine well below it's most efficient operating temperature.
- pdonis 14y agoThe electricity to power the fan comes from the engine. I'm not sure how much of an impact this actually is The fan practically never runs in cold weather. The only time it's needed is in hot weather, when you're stopped or at low speed and there's not enough airflow over the radiator and/or condenser. In cold weather the thermostat controls engine temperature, not the radiator, so the fan never gets told to turn on.
- modoc 14y agoNot the radiator/cooling fan(s), the climate control system/vent fan(s.
- pdonis 14y agoAh, ok. That actually does draw a significant fraction of the available power on the 12V electrical system (in my car the interior lights dim perceptibly when the climate control blower is on high), but by the standards of the engine it's still not much.
- eli 14y agoIsn't it using electricity that is already being generated by the alternator whether the heat is on or off?
- tbrownaw 14y ago
- timdorr 14y agoOnce the Supercharger network is in place, I'll be driving my Model S up to my parent's house next Thanksgiving from Atlanta. That's 1000 miles, without any concerns about heating or AC usage. The reporter in this article both failed to charge his car as much as needed and took a large detour that took off some range of the car. If you want to drive recklessly, sure, you're going to run into issues. But there is a significant enough Level 2 charging infrastructure already and Tesla's Level 3-ish Supercharger network is going to supplement that entirely. As it is, I can already take long trips. I just have to wait longer for a full Level 2 charge than I will on a Supercharger in the very near future.
- StavrosK 14y agoHow long does it take to charge with a Supercharger?
- s0rce 14y ago30 minutes.
- jasonkolb 14y agoThe gal at the Tesla store by me told me an hour.
- timdorr 14y ago30 minutes for 150 miles of range from a near-empty battery. Approx 60 minutes for a full charge from empty. It does slow down as it gets closer to full, but the timeframe is measured in minutes instead of hours.
- Cushman 14y ago> It just has too work, there is no place for a list of "buts" Of course there is! Here are some example buts for ICEs: Gasoline is a dense energy source, but... it stinks. it's toxic. it's too noisy. its price is too determined by foreign politics. it puts high stress and heat on the car, requiring constant maintenance. it's not shelf stable. its performance is dependent on altitude.
- __--__ 14y agoNone of which matters a bit if you just want to take the thing on a 200 mile road trip. People do care about the things on that list, but they care about being able to get where they're going more.
- forgottenpaswrd 14y agoIt is a source of energy that not every country has enough. Most countries in the world have different sources of energy(from coal to wood, going through nuclear). The countries that do not have enough of it have to invent stupid excuses for invading the countries that do have, incurring in high costs while killing millions, because if not transportation halts and the economy nukes. It is a highly pollutant for cities, specially diesel particles that are carcinogenic, while on electric generation plants you could use particle filters that are very efficient and cheap, and also far from where most people lives. It is very complex and things breaks a lot. You need to change the oil frequently, drive belts and also the brakes while with regenerative braking they last forever.
- MikeCapone 14y agoAnd the list goes on! But from an engineering point of view, I just don't find ICEs elegant. Too many moving pieces, and all that for about 30% efficiency (the remaining 70% is lost as waste heat). Good thing gasoline is so energy-dense, because when you're wasting 70% of your energy, you need that.
- bkanber 14y ago30% is roughly the peak efficiency of an ICE. Average efficiency throughout a driving cycle is more like 17%.
- ANH 14y agoOn several occasions I've had to judiciously use A/C in hot weather in my petrol powered car, so that sort of power/thermal management seems to be a "real negative" of cars in general.
- cma 14y ago"Plus the real negative part of the article that Musk is glossing over is, having to turn off heat in a vehicle just to get somewhere, got to be loads of fun in the summer too." If that is the negative part then write an article about that and see how many views it gets. Fabricating a bunch of stuff will get more hits.