4 ms·
>Naturally, on any occasion when it is actually possible to check a journalistic report against reality, the journalist will turn out to be lying I don't think
by jseliger 14y ago
>Naturally, on any occasion when it is actually possible to check a journalistic report against reality, the journalist will turn out to be lying
I don't think this is true "on any occasion"; that journalistic lying is news indicates that it rarely happens or rarely is caught.
I think it's possible to see this as an example of a problem with this individual journalist, or with the culture of journalism, without assuming "the journalist will turn out to be lying" in all circumstances.
- btilly 14y agoYou miss three important factors. The first is that few are in a position to prove journalistic lies. The second is that journalists do not like pushing reporting on other journalists lying because they are outing people they know, and they may get the same treatment some day. The third (and in some ways most important) is that since the rise of the "blogosphere" in recent years, facts have become much less important. (Why? Because if you report something wrong you get clicks, then you publish a retraction and get clicks, then you can do a puff piece about "how could this happen" and get more clicks. Bingo, you earned ad dollars 3x when fact checking would have earned you nothing. What incentive, then, is there to fact check?) Therefore there is an erosion of standards which means that we should expect lying to go up over time. My sister was famous back in "the good old days" of the 80s, back when media actually cared about its reputation. Even then it was a good idea to assume journalists were lying slime. Today I firmly believe that it is much worse. If you are a blogger and disagree, then tell me this. How much of a fact check did your last 5 stories get beyond, "Can I find someone else saying this?"
- AJ007 14y agoIntellectual dishonesty, fact checking laziness, and exaggeration might be more descriptive terms to use than lying, though yes they are lying.
- btilly 14y agoAnything for a good story.
- beambot 14y agoProfessional blogger or hobbyist? My last 5 blog posts (robotics on Hizook.com) were exceedingly fact checked. But then again, I'm a subject matter expert: I have a PhD in robotics. Terrance Tao... also exceedingly fact checked (Fields medal winner blogging about math). Richard Lipton... same (famous computer researcher blogs about P vs. NP). I know that's not your point... but not all bloggers are equally sketch. Some of us know what we're talking about.
- btilly 14y agoProfessional, of course. I also blog occasionally, and fact check my stuff. But if you're going to make money by the ad impression, you have a very specific set of incentives. Care and integrity are not high on the list.
- Eliezer 14y agoAmateur-run blogs are far more honest than reporting, in my experience. The sympathetic phrasing would be that bloggers haven't had all but the last shreds of their integrity worn away by an editor demanding 6 column inches by deadline, over and over again. The unsympathetic phrasing would be that bloggers are not professional liars and might naively fear getting caught. Either way, I trust non-professional blogs over Wired News any day. Blog coverage is often honest and accurate. Reporting, when I or anyone I know or any subject I know about in detail is being reported on, almost never is.
- btilly 14y agoDepends on the blogger. There are plenty of amateur hacks, particularly when you get into an echo chamber based on politics, conspiracy theories, religion, etc. But there are a ton of subject matter experts (like John Baez) out there blogging on objective stuff, and their average quality is often amazing.
- Eliezer 14y agoWe're not even talking about John Baez here, just blogs randomly selected from the set of blogs on the Internet that I actually run across, which is admittedly a biased sample. The thought that any mainstream media could possibly, possibly be as trustworthy as a John Baez blog post is a thought worthy only of derisive laughter.
- Samuel_Michon 14y ago"that journalistic lying is news indicates that it rarely happens or rarely is caught." Of all the times that I've been interviewed, I've been misquoted more often than not. Many others have noticed the same thing. Scott Adams: "I've been interviewed several hundred times in my career. When I see my quotes taken out of context it is often horrifying. Your jaw would drop if you saw how often quotes are literally manufactured by writers to make a point. " http://dilbert.com/blog/entry/quote_approval/ http://dilbert.com/blog/entry/quote_approval/ Marco Arment: "I’ve learned the hard way, over and over again, that it’s most wise to talk to journalists the way you’d talk to the police: ideally, don’t. You have everything to lose and almost nothing to gain." http://www.marco.org/2012/09/19/quote-approval http://www.marco.org/2012/09/19/quote-approval
- skc 14y agoI wonder why tech savvy people don't make use of the perfectly good recording device they carry with them at all times (their smartphones) to avoid being "misquoted". Let the reporter do as he pleases, but inform him that you have a record of the interview too. That would keep them honest.
- Samuel_Michon 14y agoIt doesn't help one bit. Journalists don't usually let you verify quotes, and once the newspaper is printed, there's little you can do. Even if you manage to get a rectification, no one reads it.
- ImprovedSilence 14y ago>>I don't think this is true "on any occasion" Woah woah here... I wasn't about to fully support the grandparent here, but I would hazzard a guess that more often than not, persons end up misquoted, out of context, or sentences are strung together "just so" to make you "think" in a certain manner, that may not be factual. It happens everywhere. My own anecdotal evidence: I was in boy scouts, we camped near a farm field, trampled rows of corn to make a boundary for a capture the flag game, got busted, and had to go back and pick up all the corn by hand and make amends with farmer. The newspaper wrote up a fantastic article about how local boy scouts helped the community by helping a farmer reap damaged crops. there were no lies or factual inaccuracies in the article, sans lies of omission. From this, and what others respond to you, I'd believe this happens more often that not. But certainly not at 100% either.