5 ms·
This is also a good way to never get positive press coverage ever again.
by TylerE 14y ago
This is also a good way to never get positive press coverage ever again.
- jonknee 14y agoHaving the most respected news organization in the world apologize for lying in its review of your vehicle will not harm your future press coverage. If anything it will ensure others take a more rigorous fact checking process in the future.
- prawks 14y agoThis is, of course, if Musk is correct and the NYT is indeed lying. If he can't prove it, I'd agree with TylerE.
- cremnob 14y agoAnd if Elon fails to actually prove this reporter lied/fabricated the review and just waffles, the NYT is going to skewer Tesla in their response and this story will get much more legs than if they had just ignored the review.
- nlh 14y agoI dunno - do you really think auto reviewers are all a same-think cabal who hold grudges on each other's behalf? I've met a bunch, and I don't think that's correct. Most are out to ... drumroll ... write reviews. If Tesla puts out a good product, they'll get good reviews.
- roc 14y agoNot to mention that most writers have a pretty good idea who else on their beat is writing tripe. And if someone has a habit of doing this sort of thing, they're not going to care one whit when that person is exposed.
- slantyyz 14y agoI thought many auto reviewers were like entertainment reporters (my perception could be out of date)-- they usually go on review junkets paid for by the auto makers and often don't post reviews that are too negative for fear of not being invited again. On the opposite end of the spectrum, Consumer Reports bought a Tesla for review, and when they announced it, they mentioned all the hoops they jumped through to prevent Tesla from knowing that they bought one.
- notatoad 14y ago>they mentioned all the hoops they jumped through to prevent Tesla from knowing that they bought one. Given Musk's tweet about how they always enable data logging for journalists, i'm wondering why it was so important for CR not to let tesla know they bought one.
- slantyyz 14y agoIf I'm not mistaken, CR buys all the cars they review, unlike most news organizations, who get loaners and/or expenses paid junkets. The most likely reason is that they didn't want Tesla to cherry pick the best unit they had available to ensure a positive review.
- danielweber 14y agoYes, this is more about Consumer Reports than about Tesla. CR cares a lot that they aren't getting any kind of special car. They want the exact same car their customers would get.
- smackfu 14y agoHonestly, I'm surprised anyone is even willing to do a review, when they have shown a willingness to sue the press for libel. Why bother taking the risk? Just let them have no press.
- jonknee 14y agoAny company or individual should be willing to sue the press for libel. It should also not be of any concern to a media outlet because by rule you should not be committing libel. It would be an awesomely poor publication that is only willing to report on people and organizations that won't sue the publication when it intentionally misrepresents the facts.
- lawnchair_larry 14y agoIn a perfect world. But in the real world, your concern has little to do with whether or not you actually committed libel. Just because you didn't, doesn't mean the company that you just trashed won't lawyer up and claim otherwise. If US courts were "loser pays", this would be somewhat less of a concern.
- hkmurakami 14y agopageviews? :)
- milesskorpen 14y agoThe UK has very different libel laws, so it isn't quite the same as suing for libel in the US (which is rather rare).
- cube13 14y agoWhich makes the fact that Tesla lost the lawsuit in the UK even more remarkable. The burden of proof rests on the defense in the UK, not the plaintiffs.
- monsterix 14y agoWhy so? I think it is going to be quite the opposite. They now have the exact kind of coverage they wanted. At best what's going to happen here is either a legal suit, or an apologetic exit. It's good that they were storing the logs - machines don't lie.
- homosaur 14y agoYour hypothesis is playing out already. I just saw a piece on CNBC a few minutes ago talking about the negative NYT Tesla review where they mostly talked about how glowing the reviews have been for the Tesla S and how as a company they are really doing well. My overall impression is that people were taking the NYT review with a grain of salt even before Musk called BS. But NYT also called BS on him, so let's see whose numbers add up.
- DigitalJack 14y agoMachines do what people tell them to do. All NYT has to do is claim Tesla faked the log data.
- monsterix 14y agoTrue that. However, that would be a bit of a stretch. A more likely outcome is great coverage in short course for Tesla and another short tone-it a-couple-of-notches-down by NYTimes on the third page. Unless of course there is legal entanglement.
- lawnchair_larry 14y agoMachines lie constantly. Get some filter oil on your mass airflow sensor, and watch your ECUs nose grow. Hell, we almost nuked the russians, and them us, due to a lying machine :)
- tadfisher 14y agoWell then you're changing the parameters of the question :)
- vm 14y agoNot true. Tesla sued BBC's Top Gear for libel after a review [1]. That didn't stop Tesla from getting this NY Times piece [2] and other award-winning press, such as Motor Trend Car of the Year 2013. [1] Tesla vs Top Gear, well documented by Tesla http://www.teslamotors.com/teslavstopgear http://www.teslamotors.com/teslavstopgear [2] NY Times piece in question: http://www.nytimes.com/2013/02/10/automobiles/stalled-on-the-ev-highway.html http://www.nytimes.com/2013/02/10/automobiles/stalled-on-the... Edit: removed date of lawsuit per comment below
- tokenadult 14y agoSee below (right now it's below, but it probably deserves to be upvoted some more) http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5203228 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5203228 for a more detailed discussion in this same thread of the Top Gear review and the litigation surrounding it.
- cube13 14y ago> Tesla sued BBC's Top Gear in 2012 [1] It was in 2011(http://www.engadget.com/2011/03/30/tesla-sues-top-gear-for-libel-new-stig-unavailable-for-comment/ http://www.engadget.com/2011/03/30/tesla-sues-top-gear-for-l... ), and it was over a largely positive feature on the roadster that aired in 2008.
- throwaway54-762 14y agoWhat positive coverage?
- wahsd 14y agoBecause they have to tell the truth or be called out with data? Not sure I follow, unless you are talking about auto industry shills.