3 ms·
Private health insurance works fine for a large percentage of the U.S. population. It's worked well for 3 generations of my family, for example, and there is pl
by snowwrestler 14y ago
Private health insurance works fine for a large percentage of the U.S. population. It's worked well for 3 generations of my family, for example, and there is plenty of data that shows similar successes for many millions of other people.
There are situations where it does not work well, and it is appropriate that the government steps into those situations. The U.S. government already does this, with Medicare, Medicaid, and Social Security. Just like they provide flood insurance to the few people who need it.
But neither the U.S., nor Canada, have stepped in to take over the entire homeowner insurance market. Why not? Because it works well enough the way it is. There's no need.
Likewise, replacing the entire private U.S. health insurance industry with government-run single payer is not needed. It would be hugely risky, but with little marginal benefit for those who would be most affected.
- kevingadd 14y agoI don't think you can claim that it's not needed just because a 'large percentage' of the population is well-served. The United States' population is over 313 million people according to the last census. Would you be okay with 3 million people dying or living in perpetual poverty because they don't have access to preventative/emergency care? Politicians in the US regularly make a fuss about things that affect less than 3 million people. Now, you can argue that any government-run single payer system would have 'marginal benefit', but you'd have to work pretty hard to do worse than what we have now for those people.
- snowwrestler 14y ago> Would you be okay with 3 million people dying or living in perpetual poverty because they don't have access to preventative/emergency care? Obviously not, which is why I said that it is right that the government should step into those kinds of situations. But now let's picture 3 million people for which private insurance works fine. Why should the government take over their insurance?
- mimiflynn 14y agoMedicare doesn't pay if the patient doesn't show improvement. If the person is dying, medicare will not pay for their care, leaving dying people and their families to choose between pain and debt. We will all die. Why, in this world of medical advancements, can't we all help each other die as painlessly as possible?
- snowwrestler 14y agoThis is a great question, and I agree with you about the value of palliative care. But it is a question of Medicare policy, not government vs. private insurance. Extending Medicare to cover everyone (one model for how the U.S. could move to single-payer), would not solve this problem.
- OldSchool 14y agoUnfortunately, health costs have far outpaced inflation and earnings. Just(?) 20 years ago I worked as an IT consultant for a large health insurer and the comfy corporate group PPO "family coverage" option (2 adults and an unlimited number of children) cost $300/mo total, not just the employee's portion. Today's total rate on a similar plan is about $1500/mo. That's almost 10x the net increase in the CPI over the same period. Put it another way: in 1993 there were plenty of IT pros (not company owners) making $100K+. Are there just as many percentage-wise making $500K+ now?
- snowwrestler 14y agoThis is a common misunderstanding; health care costs have gone up faster than inflation, not just private health insurance costs. Costs have gone up for government-paid programs as well, which is why there is such focus on entitlement spending in the political discourse recently. It is a real problem, but not one that rests solely on the shoulders of private insurance companies.
- OldSchool 14y agoYup, I totally agree. To make matters worse, the off-contract rates on the invoices are often astronomical compared to what they actually get from your insurance - like 10x or more. Normally you're good if you stay in-network, but an ER visit to an in-network hospital can result in a separate bill for say $600 directly from a doctor who might've seen you for five minutes but doesn't work as an employee of the hospital. Unless you just can't pay or want to white knuckle it and play poker negotiating you can't get a lower rate because that doctor's "not on your insurance." I've seen this virtually every time someone's gone to the ER.