3 ms·
The only criticism I have of this comparison is that, well, maybe people shouldn't be living in flood plains. Yes, I understand why people want to live near Win
by untog 14y ago
The only criticism I have of this comparison is that, well, maybe people shouldn't be living in flood plains. Yes, I understand why people want to live near Winnipeg and that there's limited space, but we may reach a certain point where we say "tough, the government won't bail you out for living in an at-risk area". Certainly, in New York State the Governor has announced plans to buy up waterfront land from people wrecked by Sandy to make sure that others don't make the same mistake.
Health isn't the same. We can't say "well, maybe you shouldn't have gotten cancer" to someone who develops it through no fault of their own. We can choose where to live, but we can't (often) choose our health.
- raganwald 14y agoThere is a certain amount of that going on. After Hurricane Hazel in Toronto, the government did buy up a lot of land on the Humber and Don rivers where houses were swept away, they are now parkland. the trouble is, moving people out of a flood plain within a city is easier than moving an entire city that is a substantial economic entity in its own right. So I think you're right that where practical, people shouldn't live in flood plains, and perhaps they shouldn't even have a choice in the matter.
- bmmayer1 14y agoYou can certainly choose not to smoke, and to exercise, and to take care of yourself in general. We do introduce a principal agent problem into the mix when we start letting people get their healthcare paid for by other people.
- untog 14y agoYes, and that's why I added "often" to my last sentence. But while you can certainly avoid some illnesses by making good life choices, it's still out of your control. You can have never touched a cigarette and still get lung cancer. In fact, that opens up another reason for public healthcare- many illnesses are caused by society as a whole. That second hand smoke from the man sat next to you at the bus stop is an individual thing, but the pollution coming out of the power station on the edge of town is a far broader issue. You could say "fine the power company!", but that's short sighted- everyone benefits from the power they provide. As a society we have decided that x level of pollution is acceptable in order for us to have y level of comfort. The side variable is the number of illnesses caused by that pollution, and I think there's a strong argument that the costs of that should be borne by society.
- bmmayer1 14y agoI agree, but eventually everyone does bear the cost as individuals.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- masklinn 14y ago> The only criticism I have of this comparison is that, well, maybe people shouldn't be living in flood plains. The problem is of course historical imperative: cities used to be set up on waterways (not just near water, but on major rivers), and cities which grew big existed pretty much exclusively on waterways: up until the 19th century they were the only way to move major amounts of materials (and supplies) in a timely manner and with acceptable costs. Also the only way to move water in and sewage out past a certain size (again until the 19th-20th century). So big cities grew around big waterways, whether inland or at the mouth, and big cities act as black hole, they have a "mass" attracting more people and growing bigger out of it. And big waterways flood, so you end up with the places which have been the most likely to accumulate huge populations over historical times also being those most likely to get flooded. To fix that, you have to tear down and remove cities with hundreds of thousands of years of history, social accretion structure and huge populations. Not really easy. And that's before you factor in the costs of creating a complete mature metropolis from scratch, and you start wondering about the location: coasts are out (storms, tsunamis); waterway plains are out (floods); geologically active zones are out (quakes, volcano eruptions); periodically dry places with vegetation are out (fires and firestorms); space is out obviously (hard life support system dependency, no ringworld for you). You're pretty much left with deserts, big mountain ranges and waterworld.
- waps 14y agoYeah, but the problem is similar to the "subverting natural selection" argument against health insurance. You're not just accepting historical accident, you're actively taking away the incentives for acting sanely. I can understand the historical imperative, but that's not all you're doing by switching the costs to the government : you're changing the incentives for individuals. The short-term advantages of locating in a specific location (including short-term savings of not securing against acts of God at all) are allocated to individuals, the costs are carried by the whole. In this case that means building a lot of houses that will predictably suffer massive damage due to floods and/or other "acts of God" that are actually reasonably predictable (when may be unpredictable, but you the odds are 1000:1 that it will happen at some point in the next, say, 10 years). In the health care that means having habits that are will predictably lead to health problems (take your pick what you consider worse: expensive health problems or fatal health problems or health problems that are likely to spread). Whether we're talking eating fat, smoking, carelessness around animals, not cleaning living places or promiscuity : all will result in steadily building likelihood of serious health consequences. The issue is that this leads to an exponentially rising cost (you can prove that given reasonable assumptions the consequences' cost and seriousness will rise along with population size or faster), even in the face of efficiency improvements. This is because exponentially rising costs versus exponentially diminishing efficiency improvements : there is no question which will win, there's only a question of when. The problem is that in the short term efficiency improvements are likely to win, which is then of course used as an argument to state "see ? We can handle it". The truth is, obviously, that there is no way to handle the exponential rise that doesn't violate the laws of physics. So the real question is : Why build systems that common sense says : 1) must fail, no matter how many resources are comitted to make them work 2) are very likely to cause enormous damage just before they fail completely