7 ms·
Facebook sued over 'like' button
- omgsean 14y agoI too would like to patent the emotional response to seeing something that brings you joy or amusement.
- homosaur 14y agoI'm sorry, this violates my patent on making jokes about patents, I'm going to need some licensing fees for that...
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- bluetidepro 14y agoThe article is pretty vague, it would be nice if they had more details on these two patents.
- blauwbilgorgel 14y agoHere is the original complaint (pdf) http://www.rembrandtip.com/pdf/2013-02-04RembrandtSocialComplaint.pdf http://www.rembrandtip.com/pdf/2013-02-04RembrandtSocialComp... (With Facebook and AddThis as defendants) Here are the two patents in question http://www.google.com/patents/US6415316 http://www.google.com/patents/US6415316 (1998, Method and apparatus for implementing a web page diary) http://www.google.com/patents/US6289362 http://www.google.com/patents/US6289362 (2001, System and method for generating, transferring and using an annotated universal address) And here is a patent supposedly in the hands of Facebook right now, that references one of the above patents. This is now used to claim that Facebook knew of the patents, and willfully infringed them. http://www.google.com/patents/US7907966 http://www.google.com/patents/US7907966 (2011, System and method for cross-platform applications on a wireless phone).
- L4mppu 14y agoWhen will these stupid patents die out?
- logn 14y agoNow that all of the tech companies have invested billions in them and would logically want to protect their investment and competitive advantage, I don't ever see it ending (since of course corps control government). If we're lucky someone will get an iPhone banned in the US and then all hell will break loose.
- DanBC 14y agoI'm having trouble understanding the claims and drawings of the US6289362 patent, especially all the AUA stuff. i) It feels a lot more relevant to something like Pinterest. ii) Isn't the product they're describing just a copyright violating website? iii) Isn't the core of the product, the AUA, just a list of URLs? Isn't this just a regular CMS? Were there really no CMSs before 1998?
- roc 14y agoThe drawings are irrelevant; It's always and only about the claims. i) I'm not familiar with how Pinterest works, so I'm no help there. ii) they're describing essentially any annotation of content (including a link to content), provided the conditional presentation of that annotation happens on the client side. iii) Patents are granted to inventions comprising all the elements of their claims. Reducing things to their 'core' is a habit of engineers that hampers understanding of the patent system. The only things that are relevant as prior art, are those that contain all the elements. A CMS that contained annotations along with content is not prior art for Claim 1 of the '362 patent, if it did conditional rendering based on that annotation on the server. As Claim 1 includes sending an applet, template and data to the client, to handle the conditional presentation. If a given implementation doesn't send an applet, it wouldn't count as prior art if it came before, and it wouldn't infringe if it came after.
- ck2 14y agonews is about a week old so there are plenty of better articles on it http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2013/02/before-facebook-there-was-surfbook-now-pay-up/ http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2013/02/before-facebook-t...
- tragomaskhalos 14y agoThe guy who invented the "submit" button is lawyering up as we speak ...
- easytiger 14y agoAs should the guy who invented clicking.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- speeder 14y agoMicrosoft once tried to patent the double click. (good that this one failed).
- Aardwolf 14y agoCircumvention: the triple click.
- philipmcgarvey 14y agoNot a circumvention, since triple-clicking requires double-clicking.
- lawn 14y agoPatented it you mean.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- homosaur 14y agoTim Berners-Lee should have patented "text pages over a network," dude would be a bajillionaire.
- astrodust 14y agoAlso the World Wide Web would never have happened because who would want to marry themselves to a platform encumbered by so many patents?
- homosaur 14y agoSo you're saying that patents can be destructive to markets??? Man, I wish someone in the US government agreed with you on thatOH WAIT http://research.stlouisfed.org/wp/more/2012-035 http://research.stlouisfed.org/wp/more/2012-035 Not that a single report means anything for policy, I just saw this on HN a few days ago and thought it was relevant to that point.
- adrianonantua 14y agoThis is getting ridiculous by the minute. Being a software developer, I fear sooner or later I'll be a target. I feel it's just a matter of time. But worst of all is the feeling of helplessness of it all: it's a big dog fight. Small ones either have to run with tail between legs (pay up, give up, throw work away) or fight to eventually get crushed (by the outcome or by being out of financial breath in the process). I apologize for the negative rant, but frankly, as I re-read it, it really looks more realistic then pessimistic.
- psionski 14y agoGo to a country outside of their jurisdiction, either physically or virtually (depends mostly on destination climate).
- astrodust 14y agoIf you have even one American customer you're subject to these rules and ridiculous software patents.
- daemon13 14y agoHow/why is that? Let's say that the legal entity is registered in Switzerland or China or Russia for that matter. This company sells some goods [virtual/physical] through a web site [for example using Amazon 1-Click patent] to a person, who happens to be an American citizen, with payment made by credit card. How this company will become "subject to these rules and ridiculous software patents"? In which court will this case be processed? How the court decision will be enforced?
- astrodust 14y agoCitizenship doesn't matter, but the location of the user does. If you're doing business with American users, defined as "people residing in or doing business within the borders of" the United States, then you're subject to the patent laws. All a claimant needs to do is prove that this is the case and the lawsuit can proceed. Then you'll need to find representation in a particular court in Texas to defend yourself, or you'll have to settle out of court at your own considerable expense.
- escaped_reddit 14y agoIf facebook can patent and sue others because of some generic feature like a "wall", then i'm glad they are being sued for this.
- friendly_chap 14y agoWe herd you like patents dawgs, so we sued you over the like button.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- tathagatadg 14y agoWhat should a 2-3 person startup do if they find themselves in such a situation (i.e. get sued by a patent troll)?
- tuxidomasx 14y agoThis makes me wonder if there is a market for patent troll insurance. Pay a small monthly fee and get legal protection or money to hire your own counsel in the event of a lawsuit. It seems to be a pain point that small startups worry about, since it can be pretty deadly to a busines, even if they are innocent.
- astrodust 14y agoAh, you mean what Intellectual Ventures was supposed to be? Pay a small membership fee to have access to their "technology" as well as immunity from being sued with regard to their patents. It's not unlike the mob, though, having to pay a 'protection fee'.
- giis 14y agoI'm planning to get patent for the keyword 'main' then go and sue every programming application that uses 'main' :P -- patents are ridiculous