5 ms·
Admittedly, the "Wikileaks in 1940" is such an anachronistic idea that it doesn't hold up to analysis. The WWII era not only lacked the technology necessary for
by philwelch 14y ago
Admittedly, the "Wikileaks in 1940" is such an anachronistic idea that it doesn't hold up to analysis. The WWII era not only lacked the technology necessary for Wikileaks, but also the ridiculous notion that governments should be completely disabled from keeping secrets at all. Since you've moved the goalposts and aren't even defended that notion, you've tacitly conceded that governments should be able to keep some secrets from the public, so I don't see the purpose of your quibbling.
> there was basically nobody on the Allied side who thought it was whistleblowing to leak secrets to Hitler
To Hitler directly? Perhaps not, but I'm discussing releasing information to the public as a whole, which would have the secondary consequence of revealing the secret to the Axis. This is also why the selective release of information to the Soviets is an irrelevancy on your part, since we're discussing the impact of revealing secrets to the public as a whole.
The basic threat of Wikileaks is that "basically nobody" is still somebody, and somebody is all you need to release secret information to everybody.
Your refutation is that, based the incomplete information they had, the Germans could have potentially chosen to bet correctly on everything they were uncertain of. Are you really incapable of distinguishing that scenario from one where they were able to make a more informed decision because the secrets were revealed decisively?
Regardless of Hitler's initial opinions, the fact remains that a large proportion of the German defensive force on D-Day were garrisoned in the Pas de Calais region and remained there even after the landing was underway, convinced that Normandy was a diversionary attack. It would seem that Hitler himself changed his mind, since the failure of the German forces to abandon Pas de Calais was decisive to the operation.
Empowering individuals to release information to the public makes it harder, not easier, to keep secrets. How can you argue otherwise? Keeping secrets was vital to the Second World War. How can you argue otherwise?
- ucee054 14y ago"Since we're discussing the impact of revealing secrets to the public as a whole." No, you were discussing that. Military plans are irrelevant to the public as a whole. They are only actionable by the opposing military. The case discussed that originated this three posts up was about use of Wikileaks as a vector to reveal US/Israeli military secrets to the Iranian government. The idea was never to get US military secrets to Old Farmer Sassan from Onion Village in Iran. What on earth would he do with them? "Somebody is all you need to release secret information to everybody." No, a whistleblower is what you need to release secret information. The difference being that the whistlebower is someone who doesn't want the secrets kept, because he/she has decided that the secret keepers (the whistleblower's own side) are the criminals. Someone like Bradley Manning. Or Wilhelm Canaris. Who on the Allied side wanted to reveal Allied war secrets? This is your flimsy argument against empowering whistleblowers? "the failure of the German forces to abandon Pas de Calais was decisive to the operation." You seem to get all your history from Action Man books http://www.amazon.co.uk/s/ref=ntt_athr_dp_sr_1?_encoding=UTF8&field-author=brogan%20mike&search-alias=books-uk&sort=relevancerank http://www.amazon.co.uk/s/ref=ntt_athr_dp_sr_1?_encoding=UTF... Do you have any idea of what a fiasco World War Two was? If there had been a Wikileaks leaking government secrets to EVERYBODY (gasp!) in 1940, I'm certain World War Two would have been smaller, because Japan and the USA would not have gotten involved. The American public would not have tolerated it. And maybe Britain might not have starved those 7 million Indian people by diverting their food to the British Army.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- philwelch 14y agoI should have known better than to respond to someone who literally Godwinned the thread right off the bat.
- ucee054 14y agoAnd I should known better than to reply to someone putting words in my mouth. I am responsible neither for your ignorance nor for your mistaking of battlefield trivia for all of history. Once you actually know something about World War Two we can talk about Wikileaks in 1940. Here are some references. Go and learn what the hell you're talking about. http://www.amazon.com/Day-Of-Deceit-Truth-Harbor/dp/0743201299 http://www.amazon.com/Day-Of-Deceit-Truth-Harbor/dp/07432012... http://www.amazon.com/Desperate-Deception-British-Operations-1939-1944/dp/1574882236/ref=ntt_at_ep_dpt_1 http://www.amazon.com/Desperate-Deception-British-Operations... http://www.amazon.com/War-Racket-Profit-Motive-Warfare/dp/1434407004 http://www.amazon.com/War-Racket-Profit-Motive-Warfare/dp/14... http://www.amazon.com/Churchill-Hitler-Unnecessary-War-Britain/dp/0307405168 http://www.amazon.com/Churchill-Hitler-Unnecessary-War-Brita... http://www.amazon.co.uk/Psychology-Military-Incompetence-Pimlico/dp/0712658890 http://www.amazon.co.uk/Psychology-Military-Incompetence-Pim... http://www.amazon.com/Prosperity-Misery-Modern-Bengal-1943-1944/dp/0195030826 http://www.amazon.com/Prosperity-Misery-Modern-Bengal-1943-1...