5 ms·
You deserve that high salary far more than some guy named Raj [1]. Far better for Raj to continue living in poverty worse than the bottom 5% of America (== top
by yummyfajitas 14y ago
You deserve that high salary far more than some guy named Raj [1]. Far better for Raj to continue living in poverty worse than the bottom 5% of America (== top 5% of India) than for you to make slightly less money.
By the way, you do realize your high salary increases income inequality, right? (In both the US and the world.)
[1] Choosing India to personify this example simply because I lived there.
- jlgreco 14y ago> By the way, you do realize your high salary increases income inequality, right? In the same way that being fit makes obese people feel singled out?
- yummyfajitas 14y agoNo, in the same way that adding a value to a set of numbers that is well above average will likely increase the variance.
- jlgreco 14y agoSo yes, exactly the same way. Having more people of a healthy weight makes those who are obese stand out more. The fit person shifts average weight away from the obese. Nobody would dream of criticizing the fit person for making the obese seem fatter in comparison though, because it is plainly clear that when a person gets fitter other people don't become fatter. Despite how the variance of the population changes depending on how fit or fat individuals get, the fit person is not to blame for the obese. Dieting does not make others fatter, and having a high salary does not make others poorer.
- yummyfajitas 14y agoDieting does not make others fatter, and having a high salary does not make others poorer. True, which is why I don't care about inequality. I'm just pointing out that jquery's point is mathematically wrong - his high salary increases inequality. Immigration would reduce it.
- jquery 14y agoThese high salaries are taking from the top, not the bottom. More than any other industry right now, tech workers are making a significant fraction of the compensation of the people at the top of the management food chain. You can bet it rustles management jimmies when they see their workers living the same lifestyle as them! That's just un-American.
- gte910h 14y agoIf Raj was paid the exact same amount as the American, and had the same bargaining power, that would be one thing. But Raj doesn't. Raj is stuck in the job, terrified of being fired, and making far less than the American. This is a not horrible situation for Raj, but it is making a worse job than the one they'd have to give an American. It also makes the jobs of the Americans already working there less stable (as terrified Raj isn't going to leave).
- jquery 14y agoMy wife was a Raj and you described her situation perfectly. Strangely, after getting her green card she got a promotion and a 50% raise.
- philwelch 14y agoSo make it easier for Raj. Don't make it even harder.
- gte910h 14y agoI didn't say "No green cards". I said "No H1B visas". There is a good amount of the former. I'm not sure there is a good amount greater than 0 for the latter.
- spamizbad 14y agoI don't know how many Asian immigrants you've worked with, but the vast majority in my experience were well-heeled in their home country. Granted, their standard of living wasn't always on par with the American Middle class, but it was hardly poverty. Heck, one of my colleagues even had his own private driver back in India. I am a startup visa supporter but I have no delusions that in many cases it will be giving the privileged more privilege. It's goal is to spurn innovation in the US and make us richer - it's NOT a force in global equalization.
- yummyfajitas 14y agoI don't know how many Asian immigrants you've worked with, but the vast majority in my experience were well-heeled in their home country. My last job was in India, so I know a bit about it. The living conditions of the "middle class" in India are generally well below that of the poor in the US. Upper class lawyers and executives in Bandra and Colaba (richer areas of Mumbai) were little better off than people in housing projects in the US. The very richest people were able to afford luxuries like 23/7 (undrinkable) water, electricity, or maybe even a car. In contrast, about 70% of the US poor have a car and nearly all have water+power. But you are right that those who could afford a car could also afford a driver. The bulk of immigrant software engineers might have been rich by Indian standards. But they were very likely poor by US standards. This graph makes the point well: http://economix.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/01/31/the-haves-and-the-have-nots/ http://economix.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/01/31/the-haves-and-t... The top 5'th percentile in India is poorer than the bottom 5'th percentile in the US.
- protomyth 14y ago> By the way, you do realize your high salary increases income inequality, right? (In both the US and the world.) Income inequality is not the problem, but it sure sounds nice to the voters. Livability of lower income folks is the problem. Doesn't matter if there is only $100 difference between the lowest and highest wage earners if everyone is starving. I wish we spent less time being envious of the rich and lucky and spent a lot more time looking at ways we can use technology to make lower wages more livable.
- rayiner 14y agoFrom the perspective of the American government, yes, he does. The only duty of the American government is to Americans. Indians have a country and a government to protect their interests. God knows nobody in India wakes up in the morning and asks: "what would be good for Americans?" I'm not opposed to H1-B immigration as a principle (my father was an H1-B), but the only consideration should be how that immigration serves American interests.