4 ms·
Gender Bias 101 For Mathematicians
- return0 14y agoIt's hard to distinguish bias from genuine preconceptions based on experience - for that one would need gender neutral data that is impossible to obtain. The reverse kind of gender bias could be found in divorce custody cases for example. Maybe one could do an experiment in online job marketplaces: change the gender of a large number of work providers and observe how payouts change. In any case this was a shallow and one-sided article. [But suitable for Sunday morning heated arguments over coffee and cookies] http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.174-1617.2000.tb00570.x/abstract http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.174-1617.2000.t... http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052702303592404577361883019414296.html http://online.wsj.com/article/SB1000142405270230359240457736...
- meredydd 14y agoI almost wish the author had included this trope too: "If I begin a conversation about sexism I am experiencing, that means that sexism against men must immediately become part of the focus of the conversation". It's not that those issues are unimportant, but does it not strike you as strange that the very first comment doesn't discuss the content of the article directly, but does make sure to bring up sexism against men? It's not the first time this has happened, either, on HN or elsewhere. (And, sure, this may be the first time you've brought it up. But just like the other issues she's bringing up, the "what about the men who are discriminated against?" response is a durable and ubiquitous trend. Check any other HN thread that mentions sexism if you don't believe me. It therefore becomes very annoying to people trying to have a conversation about the persistent sexism against women in technology/maths/science spaces.)
- return0 14y agoNo, my main point was that it's not pure bias, there might be real reasons why women get paid less and men are considered bad fathers (personally, i don't agree with both statements, but see the wsj article). I suggest, if we want to get rid of this bias, change the underlying situation that perpetuates it (e.g. not by introducing gender quotas, but by making childraising less time-consuming, or educating men to be better fathers and getting rid of ridiculous stereotypes that are perpetuated in mass culture).
- shardling 14y agoYou have (I hope unwittingly?) just fulfilled one of the specific tropes she does mention.
- return0 14y ago... And which she outright dismisses citing an irrelevant study. (I did mention it's a poor article, didn't i?) When we talk about real-life statistical evidence, that’s not conclusive, either, because all differences are explained by women having babies, other priorities, etc (Except they’re not, as the linked document explains very clearly.) The linked document is a report with some recommendations about how to measure pay gap Btw, can someone explain the usage of the word "trope" here?
- shardling 14y agoA trope is a recurring theme. In this context, it refers to highly predictable responses to particular arguments. I don't think the post was super well written, but I also don't see how the cited study was irrelevant -- it shows the existence of a gender bias that operates completely independently of the choices of any individual woman: http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/cosmicvariance/2012/09/19/scientists-your-gender-bias-is-showing/ http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/cosmicvariance/2012/09/19/...
- smsm42 14y agoUntil this concern is taken seriously, I don't see why it should not be repeated. So far I only see it reflexively dismissed as "oh this, yet again". While the silent assumption is that only certain people and certain biases are discussed and "we are all biased" actually means only certain set of data is taken into account, and other data is dismissed as irrelevant. It's not about focus, it's about basic inclusion. Data about gender/discipline compositions in academic disciplines: http://www.aei-ideas.org/2013/01/college-class-of-2011-by-academic-discipline-and-gender-the-selective-concern-about-gender-imbalances-is-imbalanced/ http://www.aei-ideas.org/2013/01/college-class-of-2011-by-ac... I remember hearing a lot about sexism in disciplines which are 80+% male in this list. But I pretty much never hear about sexism in disciplines that are 80+% female. Now, I don't make any claims here about existence or non-existence of sexism one way or another just basing on the percentage data. Maybe there is sexism in one place, maybe there is not in another, even though percentages looks the same. That's not my point here. What I am questioning is that seeing 80% on one side is universally taken alone as supporting the claim of sexism, if not proving it completely, but the same study showing the same bias to the other side is not considered the base to the same claim. I think this is related to the content of the article.
- crntaylor 14y agoMaybe one could do an experiment in online job marketplaces: change the gender of a large number of work providers and observe how payouts change. Do you really think that the problem is that enough studies haven't been done? The linked article mentions a study on the gender pay gap in academia[0], the results section of which includes "After accounting for [ underrepresentation of women at the full Professor level allocation of faculty members across departmental units, and experience] there remains an unexplained female pay disadvantage of about $3000. This finding is robust to alternative specifications of the gender gap decomposition." and later "... the female salary disadvantage found in the study can be interpreted as a lower bound." There is a similar study based on results from the financial industry, which if anything is even more extreme[1] "The gender pay gap for annual gross earnings in the sector is 60 per cent." "There is a gender gap of 80 per cent for performance-related pay" "The gender pay gap in finance sector companies cannot be explained away as a historical legacy. Analysis of salaries for new recruits shows that in 86 percent of the cases reported to us, women have lower salaries than men." "In 63 per cent of cases more than half of all job grades/categories exhibited a significant gender pay gap." [0] http://www.facultyassociation.ubc.ca/docs/news/GenderPayEquity_UBCV%20Report%20Recommendation%20Committee2012-07.pdf http://www.facultyassociation.ubc.ca/docs/news/GenderPayEqui... [1] http://www.equalityhumanrights.com/uploaded_files/financial_services_inquiry_report.pdf http://www.equalityhumanrights.com/uploaded_files/financial_...
- return0 14y agoI know there is a gender pay gap. The question is: how do we know it's not justified? Presumably the pay reflects the work done
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- smsm42 14y agoIt's a huge presumption, but it's equally huge presumption that every person on the planet secretly hates women and isn't even aware of it. Either one needs proof to be called true, and neither is proven by just stating the statistics and postulating that one's favorite explanation is the right one.
- fhars 14y agoIf you actually had read the linked "shallow" article, you would have noticed that the author cited exactly the kind of study you want to see. In the very first paragraph.
- return0 14y agoThat's not the kind of study i meant. We need a way to observe whether men deserve to be paid more because they work more or not.
- ivanmilles 14y ago...if they work more /as evaluated by men/.
- speeder 14y agoGender bias will never cease to exist, and for good reasons, the fight for equality happened many times before in history, and never ended well. Male and female are very dismorphic, we cannot change that easily, male and female have very specialized roles and purposes. Yes, I am happy that people now in general have more equal opportunity than ever, and that we can have awesome workers on some areas from any background, but we should not push it too much now, society now is already very different, and failing in some aspects, more equality won't make things better, but can make things worse, much worse. Understand that past societies were not forced to be the way they were, they just changed until they settled on something that works, and it worked for good reasons. Why several societies in the world are severely against gays, especially male ones? It is because it was very important on these societies to have children, not having children was unacceptable. Today having children became too expensive, so the focus of relationships changed, and now several countries even allow gay marriage or civil union, but the need to maintain your population don't changed. Some people will argue about over population, yes, I agree that it is a danger, but we must remember that we are not even replacing our populations, we are outright declining, and the result will be some cultures disappearing, and others with higher birth rates taking their place. The funny thing about equality seeking cultures, is that they tend to erase themselves and give way to totally non equal cultures to take their place. People forget that we still live in a world, where in many contexts, might make right.
- speeder 14y agoI love HN, I make a huge post, and when the page finishes loading the tread again it is already downvoted
- lclarkmichalek 14y agoWell you didn't really change your argument or raise any interesting points half way through. I mean, you're probably better off that people don't finish it if you want to avoid downvotes, considering that you suggest discrimination against gay people is due to societies wanting to maintain a population.
- shardling 14y ago
- sprash 14y agoThe average man is pumped full of a hormone called testosterone. This leads them to take more risks and have a generally more aggressive way of doing things. This fact has been scientifically proven over and over again. In a fast moving market with high competition you need these qualities hence it is no secret why in average males are more employable in tech than women. This is a healthy market response and has nothing to do with sexism.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- fhars 14y agoActually, organizing markets in a way that they favour one gender over another is an instance of sexist bias.
- ivanmilles 14y agoAn excellent example of structural discrimination - one group both organizes and controls the perception of value in a field. It becomes hard to unless you support the structure - hence women who are forced to act on male terms. "Karen's alright, she's like one of the guys." Such a structure becomes "sex inclusive" (accepting biological men and women who act masculinely) and not "gender inclusive" (accepting biological men and women who act masculinely or femininely).
- bromang 14y agobut perhaps there are reasons other than sexist bias for organization that favours one sex over another.
- almost 14y agoArticle is talking about Math, not tech (although we have the same problem). It also starts with a specific study showing a female name alone reduces the perceived competence of a mathematician in the eyes of others (including woman). So if you are correct that increased testosterone leads to men being more driven to achieve that still leaves the fact that when a woman "overcomes" her lack of testosterone and achieves the same as a man sheis still judged as being less competent than a man. This kind of thing is hard. I don't think there are easy solutions, but let's not pretend the problem doesn't exist.
- UnoriginalGuy 14y agoThe word "fact" is used extremely loosely in this article. While the first "fact" is in fact factual it then very quickly goes down the rabbit hole of personal opinion/perspective. By the time we get to "fact 3" the author isn't even pretending any more and the "fact" is just a bizarre "you're a mathematician, you can solve this!!1!" point... I'm happy to have a discussion about gender politics/equality, this article is just a very poor starting point for such a discussion. This is nothing more than a rant, pretending to be something more.
- almost 14y agoThat's an extremely shallow criticism of the article. It uses the Myth/Fact device which is quite common in articles, read then as Point/Counterpoint or something if you must. But let's talk about the content, not the style.
- smsm42 14y agoCommon != right. Spam is common too :) If you write an opinion piece, there's nothing shameful in that, but it's not a fact. Word "fact" used to have meaning...
- andreasvc 14y agoIf you'd take a look you'd find that most any word is used extremely loosely. That's why dictionaries contain vague circumscriptions of words, often listing as many as 20 overlapping and/or separate word senses. Which is not to deny that people operate with the idea that words have a definite, literal meaning (perhaps even neatly delineated with necessary and sufficient conditions), it's just not the reality. So yes, when a particular use of a word is common, it's very hard to argue it's not right, because there are no facts to point at, only an idea in someone's head (but who's to say who is right?), or some historical data (but languages change, and prima facie that's neither good nor bad).
- UnoriginalGuy 14y agoThe article is so shallow its self that I didn't feel it deserved my time for a deep criticism. The author just stop justifying their points after the first couple. It is like they starting writing a really good piece, then got two "myths" in and then switched to random opinion mode.
- shardling 14y agoA couple of background points I had to poke around the site for: * The author is a professor of mathematics * The thing about Math Overflow (which as a non-regular reader seemed to kinda come out of nowhere) is referencing another recent blog post: http://ilaba.wordpress.com/2012/12/16/still-not-on-mathoverflow/ http://ilaba.wordpress.com/2012/12/16/still-not-on-mathoverf...
- Claudus 14y agoI've worked with a lot of programmers. Some of them have character flaws that make them unpleasant to work with. These character flaws do not affect their ability to "get the job done", but I'd rather not work with them and take steps to avoid doing so when possible. From a link in the article: Renowned conductors have asserted that female musicians have "smaller techniques," are more temperamental and are simply unsuitable for orchestras I think that "simply unsuitable for orchestras" is vague and unquantifiable, but "smaller techniques" and "more temperamental" seem like assertions that could be challenged. I have a general concept of what "smaller technique" means, is this something that is difficult to measure in a standard audition? Do female musicians in fact have "smaller technique" in general? Are female musicians "more temperamental" than male musicians in general? Is there a male equivalent of a "diva", if not does that support the assertion that female musicians are more temperamental? Can you determine how temperamental someone is from a blind audition? Is temperament a valid reason to not hire someone? To me, these senior conductors, scientists, etc. are asserting that, in general, women differ from men in certain dimensions that factor into hiring decisions but are not detectable in initial screening process. If you really want to end sexism, I feel like these sorts of questions need to be asked and answered. My observation of the subject is that many people have an intuition, gut feeling, opinion formed from personal experience, etc. that men and women in general have innate differences that make men (or women) more suitable for certain functions. The ONLY way that gender bias will ever end is to challenge these ideas and in fact show that these innate differences do not exist. On the other hand, if gender differences do exist, then fighting gender bias is an eternal struggle that will never end. It is human nature to min / max and game the system.
- erikpukinskis 14y agoMy observation of the subject is that many people have an intuition, gut feeling, opinion formed from personal experience, etc. that men and women in general have innate differences that make men (or women) more suitable for certain functions. Sounds like you'd like to ignore the science to the contrary and just rely on your gut. You're entitled to that, but I've found science to have a lot of usefulness.
- 14y ago
- _Dude_ 14y agoIt's funny how 'sexism' is used as if it could only be against women. Let's just say it: a white straight middle class young male is a public enemy. Why doesn't she just solve one of those Millennium Prize Problems? That would be a really nice case against anti-women kind of sexism.
- unconed 14y ago"Check your privilege!" you hear, after a woman scorned summons her white knights with a simple retweet.
- PeterisP 14y agoWhat's missing in the article - what the author wants to achieve. I mean, I agree with the description of gender bias and the other stuff, I have seen events like this first hand, and I have reflectively noticed my own biases that were unfair, so I'd like to correct that. But after the article, what would you like me (as a 'dude' in a science field) to do? Your own point #5 states that you do not want just to be 'heard and understood'; so what actions would you like to be the result of this?
- hugh4life 14y ago" The great enemy of the truth is very often not the lie—deliberate, contrived and dishonest, but the myth, persistent, persuasive, and unrealistic. Belief in myths allows the comfort of opinion without the discomfort of thought. - JFK " So, you're going to start your blogpost on sexism with a quote from JFK... how does that work? http://www.newrepublic.com/blog/timothy-noah/100566/jfk-monster http://www.newrepublic.com/blog/timothy-noah/100566/jfk-mons...
- wazoox 14y agoAnd really, in this thread people apparently come with the intention of confirming everything in this article. The sexism proudly displayed by some here is appalling: most shocking is the "sexism is based upon biology" argument, because you know, so were segregation and apartheid.