4 ms·
"x-ray video machine to examine their kids' feet at the shoe store" Except there's no real evidence this ever hurt anyone? And xrays are an incredible medical
by aaron695 14y ago
"x-ray video machine to examine their kids' feet at the shoe store"
Except there's no real evidence this ever hurt anyone?
And xrays are an incredible medical marvel that has saved millions of lives.
Fear hurts more than it ever helps, if they had delayed xrays for even a few years imagine how many more deaths there would have been.
The precautionary principle is a dangerous idea that has somehow has gotten mainstream acceptance. It regularly kills people, people somehow think it's a safe concept when it's not.
- StavrosK 14y agoYou're posing a false dichotomy, in that we either use X-rays for everything, or nothing. Using X-rays for medical imaging is worth the risk, using them to try on shoes isn't. Consequently, using this material to avoid getting your boots soaked and freezing to death on a mountain might be worth the risk, but using it on your coat isn't. The truth is that, indeed, we don't know the health risks. Fear has saved more lives than taken, I suspect.
- aaron695 14y agoThrough the magic of hind-site you can claim there is no dichotomy. xrays could have given cancer to the people conducting the treatments. Using fear, xrays should have never been used for anything. Is it worth the risk that doctors using xrays might get cancer to save some patients? Is it worth the risk of giving a patient cancer just because they might have a 10% chance of a life threatening injury. If you look at all clichéd stuffups with technology their kill rates are tiny, often like DDT they saved many many lives. Now take all the things people get scared of - TV, Mobile phones, electricity towers, chemicals(What ever this means). Mobile phones perhaps should only be used for emergencies in case they are cancer causing. Imaging how many 3rd world people would die if we made the decision.
- marvin 14y agoApart from the radium toothpaste and giving kids in development unnecessary, dangerously large radiation doses, you have a point about excessive caution being problematic. But there is a NIMBY-like concern here: I don't want to be in the early adopter group of a technology like this unless my life depends on it. Others are free to go ahead as they choose, and it is nice if this quickly reveals the picture of danger and helps create beneficial technology. But I won't be on the bleeding edge of this development. I guess my point is that there is a middle ground between jumping in headfirst (radium on your teeth, nano-coating on your cutlery) and being excessively careful and always covering your ass (contemporary life-saving experimental medical treatments).
- lobster_johnson 14y ago> Except there's no real evidence this ever hurt anyone? According to Wikipedia, "monitoring of American salespersons found dose rates at pelvis height of up to 95 R/week, with an average of 7.1 R/week. (Up to ~50 mSv/yr, avg ~3.7 mSv/yr effective dose) A 2007 paper suggested that even higher doses of 0.5 Sv/yr were plausible." There were a number of cases affecting salespeople that were linked to the use of shoe-fitting fluoroscopes. OP was criticizing irresponsible use of X-rays, not dismissing X-rays altogether. Given what we know about X-rays today, shoestore fluoroscopes seem an incredibly bad idea in hindsight. And given what we know about nanoparticles today, this nanotech seems like an incredible bad idea right now. Not bad enough to ban, but bad enough to regulate.
- Evbn 14y agoThe precautionary principle has kept us alive for millions of years.
- Spooky23 14y agoExcessive use of X-rays and CT exposure have been linked to increased cancers, especially in occupational contexts. That's why there are safety protocols when you get an x-ray. I'm sure the safety standards at a shoe store were less than robust.