5 ms·
> Its futile to argue with them that vaccines aren't (statistically) harmful, they've already made up their minds It's ignorance trying to defend freedom, back
by mindslight 14y ago
> Its futile to argue with them that vaccines aren't (statistically) harmful, they've already made up their minds
It's ignorance trying to defend freedom, backfitting the "facts" to their beliefs - the basis of most nutty theories. What they're really trying to defend is that government has no right dictating what one must or cannot put in their own body. But they lack the learning to be able to articulate and argue at this philosophical level (for if they had that kind of education, they'd most likely have ended up believing that society should be engineered).
It's not a good thing that these people don't vaccinate their kids and end up feeding them bleach or whatever instead, but one would be a lot better off trying to address the root causes of what makes them take an adversarial position against modern medical science, rather than wishing to paper over the symptoms with dictatorial fiats.
Also, I don't see how this is a very good simulation. As its rules are laid out, if you don't want polio, simply get vaccinated. Doesn't a large part of herd immunity have to do with even immunized people being susceptible under repeated contact with infected people?
Furthermore, it deviates from objectivity with an implicit value judgment that unvaccinated people either "cannot be vaccinated" or "are freeloaders", when it's really just individuals' utility functions. The problem with this assumption will be lost on those who'd like to engineer society, but it highlights the grave philosophical leap of the entire argument.
- DannoHung 14y ago> What they're really trying to defend is that government has no right dictating what one must or cannot put in their own body Talking about rights like this is useless. You have to assume some basic moral principles to proscribe who has a right to what. If I disagree with yours, then we'll just be shouting up a tree for hours. For one, I completely disagree with the idea that the government has no right to tell people what they can or cannot put in their own body. Depending on the moral principles that a government is founded on, it very well may have that right. > individuals' utility functions Invoking "utlity functions" is such an appeal to naturalism. All that means is that they don't give a shit about anyone else.
- mindslight 14y agoBetter off to disagree or debate philosophically than pretend common ground can be had, clouding the situation with dishonest arguments and fabricated 'facts'. In most political arguments with nutty theories on one side, those on the science-backed side think they are fighting for truth against ignorance. But what they are actually advocating is an implicit philosophy of deprecating personal autonomy in favor of an engineered society. This should at least be explicit, for the benefit of all. Analyzing utility functions obviously puts oneself first, but you overstep in trying to handwave them away as only not giving "a shit about anyone else". If we wish for systems of rules to be grounded in relation to reality (rather than taking on a self-perpetuating arbitrary life of their own), then we must consider the base case of self interest. Only after that is aligned properly can we examine emergent phenomena like societal good.
- dasil003 14y agoRhetoric is not quite so black and white as you seem to want to believe. The moment you mention "engineering society" huge swaths of people will stop listening to you regardless of their inclination to agree with your fundamental argument. Most people simply do not have the patience to precisely understand any argument with the accuracy that an expert in the field feels is necessary. Note that I am not saying you have to play fast and loose with facts or fabricate anything, but simply: phrasing matters.
- DannoHung 14y agoEverything you believe is based on the idea that everyone has relatively equal agency in their lives. But that's a load of horseshit. And that's the only thing I have to say to you.
- HarryHirsch 14y ago> For one, I completely disagree with the idea that the government has no right to tell people what they can or cannot put in their own body. Depending on the moral principles that a government is founded on, it very well may have that right. So you are saying, a government of the kind that you approve of has the right to demand that people be vaccinated, and one of the kind that you disapprove of does not. This does not compute, the outcome is the same, as is the science.
- tedunangst 14y agoWhat they're trying to defend is that they like the social contract, except when they don't.
- noonespecial 14y agoThe only thing this seems to leave out is the individual "will not be vaccinated"'s culpability in the spread of the disease to one of the "cannot be vaccinated"s. Manslaughter charges as part of the utility function then? Two or more people living within each others influence is an engineered society. The only question is what does the engineering. "If you choose not to decide, you still have made a choice".
- arrrg 14y agoAren’t people free to decide not to vaccinate? Calling that a morally reprehensible decision (which it is) is not in any way problematic and has nothing to do with the government at all.
- chiph 14y agoBut if/when they become ill, they then become a burden on society. They consume more healthcare, impact/infect friends, family, and strangers, and are potentially quarantined by the local health officials. More about the authority to quarantine someone: http://www.ncsl.org/issues-research/health/state-quarantine-and-isolation-statutes.aspx http://www.ncsl.org/issues-research/health/state-quarantine-...
- arrrg 14y agoWhat’s your solution to this? This is direct action for fear of direct consequences, not something controversial at all. By refusing to go into quarantine, you are potentially hurting other people’s freedom. One or the other has to give.
- chiph 14y agoIMO, this is where personal responsibility has to trump personal freedom. If you're sick, you have a duty to isolate yourself.
- ramblerman 14y agoMore so than the obese? The smokers? the drug users? People who sit all day and never move? I think they're pretty nutty myself. But if you're going to call them a burden on society's resources, you have to open up the argument to be inclusive of everyone who fits that bill.
- coldtea 14y ago>But they lack the learning to be able to articulate and argue at this philosophical level (for if they had that kind of education, they'd most likely have ended up believing that society should be engineered). Citation needed. I have "that kind of education" and I surely don't believe that "society should be engineered".
- hazov 14y agoFrom what I read from herd immunity you second to last paragraph is incorrect or it used a definition of herd immunity that I did not encountered yet? Can you point some material providing this information?
- lookACamel 14y ago>As its rules are laid out, if you don't want polio, simply get vaccinated. Yeah you missed the point. I quote: Herd immunity is important because there are number of people who cannot be vaccinated for health or age reasons - herd immunity effecting an indirect and statistically safe space for them.