4 ms·
I really hate free to play. Having tried a few games in this category, I generally realized about ten minutes after installation I didn't download a game, I dow
by tedunangst 14y ago
I really hate free to play. Having tried a few games in this category, I generally realized about ten minutes after installation I didn't download a game, I downloaded a money funnel. A lot of my gaming these days is casual on my phone, where this shit dominates the marketplace. I sincerely wish apple would create a separate $5 max spend gaming category (even a lot of paid games seem to make most of their profit from iap).
- ishansharma 14y agoAnd don't forget all the stuff that is shoved down your throat to make you more "engaged" with the game! Like touching a building to make it work, getting notified every 5 minutes of a completed action and what not. I find myself playing expensive but ad-free/not so purchase based games because of this. Need For Speed, GTA, Infinity Blade are a few names that come to mind!
- cookiecaper 14y agoThat's not the kind of "free to play" that Valve promotes. The phone apps are much, much more spammy. Valve mostly takes AAA games and can open them for free because the money they make as a facilitator between content creators and consumers pays for the game. The content makers make awesome stuff and get paid, the consumers get awesome stuff and have fun. Valve takes a commission for providing both the entertainment and payment platform. Everyone wins. It's a one-way street on most phone apps. The devs write a little phone game, and then put 90% of it behind staged paywalls. Quite a different thing than what Gabe has done, and what he discusses here.
- tedunangst 14y agoI guess I've never thought of TF2 as a AAA game. It was just a bonus you got for buying the Orange Box, or a kind of goodwill offering that kept you hooked on valve/steam. I'm not surprised their revenue spiked after making it free, I'm surprised people paid for it in the first place. :)
- Pkeod 14y ago>I'm surprised people paid for it in the first place. :) Based on this, as a developer, I wouldn't take your opinion that you hate F2P games seriously, and I would never want to make games for the audience you belong to. TF2 is one of the best games available to play and my second favorite game ever made. Haters gonna hate.
- obviouslygreen 14y agoIt's certainly true that many free to play games fall into this category, but definitely not all of them... I don't do a lot of mobile gaming, but I do know there are decent games out there that won't make you hate your life with inane calls to action. Robotek is an example of a great free-to-play game that does use in-app purchases, but doesn't require them (games that claim not to but basically do if you want to actually get anywhere are horrible). Anecdotal evidence is crap, I know, and this is only one example (I've played others but can't recall them right now)... but the top earners are obviously always going to be the kind of money-pit BS you're talking about. That's a shame, but putting all free to play games -- with or without IAP/advertising/etc. -- into that category just isn't realistic.
- Goronmon 14y agoHaving tried a few games in this category, I generally realized about ten minutes after installation I didn't download a game, I downloaded a money funnel. The snarky response to this would be to stop downloading bad games. There are plenty of good F2P games out there. Planetside 2, League of Legends, Path of Exile, etc. On mobile, there are games like Angry Birds that aren't just a money funnel. But honestly, you're going to have a tough time on the mobile space because IMO there just aren't that many games worth playing out there.
- jquery 14y agoJust out of curiosity, how much does it cost, in money or time, to get all the heroes in League of Legends? It may be a good game, but it's also outrageously expensive. Unless you like playing a limited set of heroes.
- archagon 14y agoHonestly, that kind of stuff is much closer to gambling than what I would consider gaming. I just really hope (though I'm probably wrong) that "social" games occupy their own niche and aren't pulling gamers away from more honest games.
- bitwize 14y agoThe difference is that your typical smartphone f2p game is like a strip club: they offer a taste, but limit the amount of fun you can have without digging into your pocket. Whereas TF2 sans headgear is still a blast to play. Hats are largely Veblen goods, and the standard weapons aren't "nerfed" compared to specialized weapons.
- stcredzero 14y ago> I really hate free to play. Having tried a few games in this category, I generally realized about ten minutes after installation I didn't download a game, I downloaded a money funnel. Widespread scammy/spammy feeling greedy money-suckage? Sounds like great news to me! That shouts opportunity. I think Valve has a formula that could do well in a market like that described above. You keep the size of the company small, so expenses are low, thus minimizing the temptation to money-suck. On top of that, you emphasize user-generated content. This increases the game's value, harnessing resources to compete with content ground-out by larger shops' payrolls, while offloading development risk for content to the users. The game makes money as a marketplace. Most importantly, build your brand on an emphasis on quality and playability. Steer clear of the mentality that you give people something for free so you can addict them using variable schedule of reward to suck money out of them. Be genuinely focused on delivering fun and build the brand on that. It's those companies who will eventually stand out over self-deluded hacks who can't see up over their own swollen greed. (I like that!) tl;dr - Be true to and work with the passions of your userbase, and you'll stand out from the crowd of self-deluded hacks who can't see up over their own swollen greed.