3 ms·
I'm sorry....but the OP is being naive and is wrong to slam Amazon here. The protocol Amazon has established here is sound...are they supposed to deliver detail
by danso 14y ago
I'm sorry....but the OP is being naive and is wrong to slam Amazon here. The protocol Amazon has established here is sound...are they supposed to deliver details of a device just because someone who was once registered to it demands so? In 99% of the cases, sure, no harm can come from it...but it's better for Amazon to adopt a clear line on this, so that their customer reps don't f--k up on the 1 percent of requests that are actually malicious social engineering attempts
* I'm not without sympathy...I was once liberated of much more expensive devices at gunpoint...and it is frustrating that the tracking capability is limited, even with a police order.
- Lagged2Death 14y agoThe protocol Amazon has established here is sound... The story I read could be summarized as: "Amazon has no protocol for stolen Kindles and flies by the seat of their pants instead, even if that means telling paying customers things that are not true."
- danso 14y agoThe OP did get misled but I'm not so sure it's jus Amazon making things up. Given the international boundaries involved here it is not a huge stretch to say that the initial rep was mistaken.
- Lagged2Death 14y agoYeah, that seems likely enough. What is the functional difference between running an organization that doesn't have protocol X and running an organization in which the boots on the ground - the people charged with implementing protocol X - do not know or follow protocol X?
- diminoten 14y agoI'm sorry, but paying customers of what, exactly? Amazon's Kindle device? Amazon's Kindle store? Which of these products comes with a service which helps you find your stolen goods? Amazon offers this as a convenience feature, not as part of your purchase price of the Kindle. A purchaser of a Kindle is not entitled to this service.
- Lagged2Death 14y agoI'm sorry, but paying customers of what, exactly? Amazon's Kindle device? Amazon's Kindle store? Both, presumably. Which of these products comes with a service which helps you find your stolen goods? Let's suppose that neither does. What does this have to do with "telling your paying customers things that are not true?"
- diminoten 14y agoOkay yeah that was not kosher, but I was more addressing his sense of entitlement that, how DARE they not give him everything he wants and more?! When you buy an item that is capable of being tracked (iPhone, car) you generally pay for a service to locate it (iCloud, onStar). Otherwise you have to get law enforcement actively involved, not just you, which raises the bar a bit for those who qualify. Imagine the Amazon nightmare: "Hey Amazon? Yeah I misplaced my Kindle, is it at my house or Grandma's?"
- andrewcooke 14y agoisn't that why they ask for details of the police case? (so it's not just at the whim of the owner; it has to be associated with an official investigation)
- danso 14y agoA police report is different than a court issued warrant. With a police report you can file with your insurance as proof for reimbursement. But in the OP's case, he is asking for Amazon to do a form of surveillance...I.e tell me who's name is on a device that is not in my possession. A warrant is a higher level of justification
- Zimahl 14y agoYou do understand that you don't have to have warrant to get details or records from someone? If a police officer asks me for an associate's address, I always have the option of just giving it to them. Sure there are compliance issues when it comes to things like HIPAA and the like, but Amazon probably wouldn't have any problem selling your information to another business. Oh, right, there's no money in helping law enforcement. There's the problem.
- danso 14y agoLet me get this correct. In a single HN comment, you: 1. Cynically accuse Amazon of being promiscuous with your data when it suits their profit motive. 2. Vouch that Amazon should be trusted to give police your data without introspection. That's quite an expansive viewpoint. As for there being "no money in helping law enforcement"...that's debatable. But there is definitely penalties for not fulfilling lawful requests.
- Zimahl 14y ago1. I think it's fair to assume that data on websites is for them to use as they see fit and not how the customer sees fit. I expect nothing less of any corporation. 2. Yes, give police the data of someone who is in possession of stolen property. He obviously could prove he had it in the first place. After that it's not up to Amazon to determine whether a crime took place, the police can handle that. no money in helping law enforcement It's a cost center only, I understand that. I doubt their 'law enforcement group' is heavily staffed or has any power within the organization at all. It's probably running as close to zero for resources.
- speedyrev 14y agoI know for a fact that they don't fully cooperate even when law enforcement is involved. Most LEO's won't jump through the hoops over and over when there are more important cases to work on.
- Xylakant 14y ago> I know for a fact that they don't fully cooperate even when law enforcement is involved. Nor should they. Let's construct a little far-fetched case where police officer X tries to spy on woman Y and asks amazon to retrive information for account of Y. That's what a court order is supposed to restrict. The police actually can do very little without a warrant, and that's for a reason.
- chimeracoder 14y ago> The police actually can do very little without a warrant, and that's for a reason. That used to be the case, but not so much anymore - [very] unfortunately.
- Xylakant 14y agoI have little knowledge about the US state of affairs but I was always under the impression that most of the extended permissions mostly apply to the FBI (warrantless wiretaps, ...) and not to the regular police - hence my cautious wording. I might be flat out wrong with this. Anyhow, the assertion is still true for germany. Unless there's an emergency they're not allowed to enter your house, ask for anything more than your name (well, they can ask, but you don't have to answer) and so forth. These regulations get ignored on a regular basis, but that's a different matter completely.
- Zimahl 14y agoFar-fetched and irrelevant. In the original case, a police officer isn't asking for information about a random person. They are asking about stolen goods and who now owns the account of the stolen item.
- edanm 14y agoAgreed, this is a complete non-story. I also think if Amazon did give the information, the HN crowd would be up in arms about a violation of privacy (correctly). This is exactly the kind of channel that easily gets hacked in social-engineering efforts. The only thing that was wrong here was that the initial customer service rep. said that a police report would be enough, but... that's it. One mistake by one customer service rep. (P.s. if the op is reading this - sorry about the stolen Kindle, I'd be upset too in your situation. I just don't think you should be upset with Amazon - I'd rather large corporations not go into spying and crimefighting)