6 ms·
Meet the Man with a Cheap and Easy Plan to Stop Global Warming
- Jabbles 14y agoAccording to Keith’s calculations, if operations were begun in 2020, it would take 25,000 metric tons of sulfuric acid to cut global warming in half after one year. Once under way, the injection of sulfuric acid would proceed continuously. By 2040, 11 or so jets delivering roughly 250,000 metric tons of it each year, at an annual cost of $700 million, would be required to compensate for the increased warming caused by rising levels of carbon dioxide. By 2070, he estimates, the program would need to be injecting a bit more than a million tons per year using a fleet of a hundred aircraft. Al Gore's "An Inconvenient Truth" included a clip from Futurama, which shows their method of combatting global warming: dumping increasing amounts of space ice in the oceans. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OqVyRa1iuMc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OqVyRa1iuMc I'm not criticising the idea, I don't have the required background. But it doesn't sound like a permanent solution.
- TimReynolds 14y agoI’m starting to believe the only permanent solution to these problems is reducing the global population. We just can’t keep using natural resources at the rate we are today.
- capisce 14y agoWho should we start by killing?
- TimReynolds 14y agoClearly not the solution. But do you really see a future were countries don’t have population control methods in place.
- capisce 14y agoThe number of children between 0-20 has been rather steady for the last decade or two, the only reason the world population is growing is that the average age is increasing, not that an ever increasing amount of children are being born. Eventually the population will stabilize by itself and possibly also start decreasing as the countries that have the largest population growth continue toward full industrialization and modern ways of living.
- ZeroGravitas 14y agoHans Rosling seems to think we'll top out at 10 billion. http://youtu.be/fTznEIZRkLg http://youtu.be/fTznEIZRkLg and the main mechanism is, counter-intuitively, reducing child mortality in the poorest areas.
- InclinedPlane 14y agoOf course. The best population control method in history has proven to be... wealth.
- vy8vWJlco 14y agoYourself. (OK, don't really, but c'mon...) Personally, I'd try giving away education and birth control first.
- capisce 14y agoNot a bad idea, but maybe we should also educate the people living in the wealthiest nations to consume less and have more sustainable life styles? 80 percent of the world's natural resources are spent by the wealthiest 16 percent after all: http://articles.cnn.com/1999-10-12/us/9910_12_population.cosumption_1_global-population-worlds-scientists?_s=PM:US http://articles.cnn.com/1999-10-12/us/9910_12_population.cos... We could start by working less: http://www.neweconomics.org/publications/21-hours http://www.neweconomics.org/publications/21-hours
- vy8vWJlco 14y agoI don't think I could work any less than I already am, but I agree with you. I am also convinced that in order to "do more with less" in the future, we will need to actually solve the basic problems that keep prices high on food, clothing, shelter, and knowledge. I'm not sure how to do that when science is a prisoner of copyright, for example, and education costs as much as a house, for example; I just don't see how to solve the physical problems, even for myself, in any big way when we can't collectively solve even the self-inflicted/social ones like copyright (and superstitions, and violence, and, ...). I think working less would be a sign of success, but I'm not sure how to get there from here. People won't do it voluntarily (nor should they be forced to). The government can always tax the wealthy and redistribute, but I'm leery of promoting that and just giving the government more power. (Now they want my guns too.) It doesn't help that the U.S. defaulted on it's gold debt in the 70's (brilliantly calling it "going off the gold standard") and now U.S. money is just an interest-bearing loan (as opposed to you, the government, just printing paper...), which means people pay interest on public debt, the rich get richer, keeping the pressure on and prices going up. (Most of the world's currencies are U.S. dollar backed, so it's not limited to the U.S..) It's musical chairs: ie, every now and then someone has to lose big (one chair is removed, in the form of interest payments), and the pie gets divided among fewer and fewer (and their children). No one's going to work less with that gun in their back. That's why, as unpopular as it can be around here (hey, everyone has to make a living), I think we have to fix this idea that we can charge for knowledge (or patent it, or copyright it), because we're really not (IMHO) going to be able to get to the important stuff if we keep fighting over the "how" (most food plants are sterile for goodness sake). I can't justify giving an inventor, even if it's me, a monopoly on an idea if it just means the whole world needs my permission to solve their own problems.
- AskHugo 14y agoThe most logical thing would be to work your way down this list: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_carbon_dioxide_emissions_per_capita http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_carbon_dio...
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- JonnieCache 14y agoWe start with the global emancipation of women. Unfortunately we barely seem able to get that going in the most developed country in the world, which makes doing it in the poorest a lot harder.
- adcoelho 14y agoOr consuming earth's resources at a rate lower than the production rate.
- vy8vWJlco 14y ago... And blocking out 1% of the available energy from the sun seems like a poor choice, if the answer is efficiency.
- patrickk 14y agoOr start consuming earth's resources in a sustainable manner, e.g: - heavily taxing gasoline vehicles and subsidising electric vehicles to encourage adoption. - heavily taxing non-renewable sources of electricity generation, subsidising solar, wind etc. - Use carbon taxes to fund more research into renewables and maybe Thorium, advanced battery technology etc. You could have a gradual ramp up of taxes to ease the burden of shifting to renewables. The biggest problem is getting people and governments to change their old mindsets. Politics, not technology is holding back progress.
- jsmeaton 14y agoWe've got some form of carbon tax in Australia and people are up in arms about it. "How DARE they put my power bills up". "Why should we go first if no one else is doing it"? Everyone complains about global warming and wants something done, but not out of their own pocket. Any government instituting these kind of taxes will be booted out, and the opposition will come right along and repeal them. It's ridiculous.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- InclinedPlane 14y agoI hate this sentiment. It's counter-factual and absolutely poisonous. Go live in a hut in the middle of nowhere if you're so concerned about resource use. For me, I fucking relish the day when everyone on the Earth can be as wealthy, or indeed wealthier, as I am today. Can live comfortably and look forward to sumptuous and delicious meals instead of living in fear of starvation or disease or war.
- jsmcgd 14y agoPeople who want to see a reduction in human population relish the same things you do. We can consume as much as we want if there are fewer of us. You can to almost anywhere on this planet and you can see human settlement encroaching on and damaging natural habitats. The magnitude of these effects are in direct correlation to human population growth.
- InclinedPlane 14y agoThis is exactly backwards. The more people there are who are skilled, educated, and working, the more resources are produced. Resources aren't manna from heaven, they are the products of human labor and ingenuity. In 50 years we'll be using robots to pluck Neodymium and Copper from the ground and Iridium from asteroids. We're not going to be running out of resources, we're going to be wealthier and resources are going to be more abundant. It's easy to imagine that we'll "run out" of "resources" because in theory many resources are in finite supply. But in reality the hard natural limits are so high as to be effectively infinite over extremely long periods of current levels of use and historically humans have gotten more and more clever about finding new methods to extract or produce resources that previously were not available. Moreover, our increasing wealth and technological capabilities have made it possible to reduce and reverse our environmental impact and encroachment of habitats. Personally, I like my life and I think it's worth living, and indeed even justified, and I think that denying the ability to live a similar lifestyle to others simply because they were born into a different part of the world is just know-nothing nonsense and veiled racism.
- TimReynolds 14y ago
- Swizec 14y agoPoor conspiracy theorists. They already have so many problems with chemtrails, and now somebody proposes this?
- stuaxo 14y agoI think we do need to reduce the amount of carbon emitted though - it causes ocean acidification + if we kill off the oceans we will be screwed.
- vixen99 14y agoAcidification (the state of something becoming acidic) occurs when the pH drops below 7.0 and thus the ratio of hydrogen ions to hydroxyl ions > 1. This has never occurred and we are nowhere near that situation. pH (it's a log scale) of the oceans is roughly around 7.7 to 8.4. This is not to debate future trends!
- japhyr 14y agoSo what do you call a downward trend in pH, when the pH starts above 7? And if there is a downward trend, what makes you think it would stop on its own at 7?
- DennisP 14y agoSeven is not the magic number where things go bad. The pH is dropping about a hundred times faster than at any time in the past 20 million years, and that's already affecting sea life. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ocean_acidification http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ocean_acidification "Corals, calcareous phytoplankton, mussels, snails, sea urchins and other marine organisms use calcium (Ca) and carbonate (CO3) in seawater to construct their calcium carbonate (CaCO3) shells or skeletons. As the pH decreases, carbonate becomes less available, which makes it more difficult for organisms to secrete CaCO3 to form their skeletal material." http://www.ocean-acidification.net/FAQeco.html http://www.ocean-acidification.net/FAQeco.html
- marcuspovey 14y agoWait... wasn't this basically the plan they came up with in The Matrix? ... I don't recall that working out too good... Seriously; while it's tempting to think of grand plans like this, I think that meddling in ecosystems is what got us into the trouble in the first place. Climate change is an economic problem, not an engineering one, which is far less sexy.
- arethuza 14y agoIt does sound a bit like Operation Dark Storm from the Part 2 of the The Second Renaissance from the Animatrix: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Animatrix#The_Second_Renaissance http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Animatrix#The_Second_Renais...
- jacques_chester 14y ago> Wait... wasn't this basically the plan they came up with in The Matrix? ... I don't recall that working out too good... Please tell me that you are not relying on The Matrix as a serious resource for ... well ... anything.
- StavrosK 14y agoAre you implying The Matrix didn't really happen?!
- Expez 14y agoThis article is mostly about geo-engineering technology, but I can't help but feel like the technological side of the venture is the easiest part. Who is going to make the go/no-go decision? The UN? By majority vote? How much do we lower the temperature by? I can't imagine an agreement being reached on something like this in my lifetime. For this reason I think we're far more likely to see this problem 'solved' by renegade geo-engineering efforts like what Russ George did (http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2012/oct/15/pacific-iron-fertilisation-geoengineering http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2012/oct/15/pacific-ir...) and that has me deeply worried.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- rytis 14y agoSo this will also reduce the amount of power harvested by the sun panels? Therefore increasing the "green energy" costs?
- greenyoda 14y agoIt will also reduce the amount of solar energy available to plants, which will reduce the amount of food we can grow and increase its costs. (And less photosynthesis means that plants will absorb less CO2 from the atmosphere.)
- LatvjuAvs 14y agoOnly way to prevent the doom and gloom is to stop fighting it.
- jacques_chester 14y agoHere's what bugs me about the whole story. The Headline: (Meet the Man with) A Cheap and Easy Plan to Stop Global Warming Key point made by David Keith: “I’m not saying it will work, and I’m not saying we should do it.” But “it would be reckless not to begin serious research on it,” he adds. “The sooner we find out whether it works or not, the better.” And people wonder why I am so ungenerous in my assessment of journalists and editors.
- hartror 14y agoThis had me twitching right from the start: Increasing what scientists call the planet’s albedo, or reflective power ... What scientists call? How about what everyone calls when they need to measure reflectivity. I don't know if this is just unfortunate choice of language or the author exhibits an bit of an us-and-them attitude towards science. I really hate the term "scientists", the way it is used is like they're this abstract homogeneous mass of not quite people who hand down decrees from on high. Instead of what they really are which is a very inhomogeneous group of hard working people working in a very broad number of fields with a vast array of ideas.
- panacea 14y agoSo fucking true. It bugs me no end when I read news reports that mention "scientists". Do we read articles where "policemen say" or "politicians say" or "priests say"?
- wwwtyro 14y agoI hope I'm not in the minority here -- plans like this terrify me. I'm currently a scientist by trade, and experience has taught me that while we have a mediocre grasp of very finely tuned experiments, to be frank, we don't know shit about predicting the chaos and unintended consequences of our actions within the complexity of the natural world. When dealing with nature, it's never as simple as do A to get B and that's it. There's some slim chance this guy's plan could work, but I am pretty confident it is infinitely more likely to either do nothing or do something really awful.
- lukeholder 14y agoCouldn't the same be said for many worth-wild things? Didn't people say the Large Hadron Collider would cause a black hole?
- InclinedPlane 14y agoThose people were provably wrong, as the Earth is bathed in high energy particles from the Universe all the time and particle collisions on the same scale as in the LHC have been happening routinely for the entire lifetime of Earth with no catastrophic effects.
- lukeholder 14y agoWow, dont understand why I was downvoted. I was agreeing with you. My point was people were scared of the LHC without scientific reasoning.
- DennisP 14y agoI think there's a cognitive bias at play here. We're already doing a massive experiment on the Earth's atmosphere by adding greenhouse gases to it. But for some reason that accidental experiment doesn't seem to freak people out nearly as much as doing an intentional experiment, even one that would partially compensate for the effects of the accident. I'd bet that most people would accept geoengineering without a second thought, as long as we convinced them it was a side effect of a for-profit venture unrelated to global warming. Because, heck, they're putting up with all the other crap we do. But tell them we're intentionally changing atmosphere and they'll riot in the streets. This particular approach wouldn't be completely unprecedented, because the same thing happens when large volcanoes erupt...and we've observed the temperature decrease when that's happened. It's far from a complete solution, but there's real concern that feedback loops will soon tip the Earth into an unstoppable warming cycle. The planet has gone into a hot state before, and rather quickly, with very little input to kick it off. Albedo adjustment could be a way to hold off that cycle while we figure out a way to reduce CO2.
- decad 14y agoI have always thought it would be interesting to see what affect painting all the roof's of all the buildings on earth white would have on global warming. I doubt there is enough buildings in the world for it have any affect though.
- tomelders 14y agoIt has been suggested (by people smarter than me) that lighter surfaces have the effect of reducing cloud cover, which allows for more sunlight to reach the ground which suggests it would only exacerbate the problem. Some suggest using solar panels instead, which comes with many of the same benefits as painting roofs white, but absorbs the light as opposed to reflecting it, and thus wont reduce cloud cover. Im not a scientist, just a casual observer, but my gut feeling is that the only way to halt or even reverse climate change is to stop producing as much carbon. Any other approach is more likely to come with unforeseen problems. So get to it! Pop down to your local Tesla showroom and do your bit.
- InclinedPlane 14y agoScientists don't really understand how clouds affect climate (some clouds cause localized cooling, some clouds cause localized heating, it's complicated), mostly they just include an empirically determined fudge factor to account for it.
- jsmeaton 14y agoSolar panels should be mandatory for all new homes - at least in the developed countries to begin with. Imagine how much carbon we'd reduce by effectively killing off the majority of power generation facilities.
- DennisP 14y ago> For the northern hemisphere summer, they found that increasing the reflectivity of roof and pavement materials in cities with a population greater than 1 million would achieve a one-time offset of 57 gigatons of CO2 emissions (31 Gt from roofs and 26 Gt from pavements). That’s double the worldwide CO2 emissions in 2006 of 28 gigatons. Their results were published online in the journal Environmental Research Letters. http://newscenter.lbl.gov/news-releases/2010/07/19/cool-roofs-offset-carbon-dioxide-emissions/ http://newscenter.lbl.gov/news-releases/2010/07/19/cool-roof...
- smogzer 14y agoCheaper solution: - Make people ride bicicles. - Reduce work hours to 4 / day. - Make it expensive to buy gas. So people ride bikes and so that Electric vehicles that are charged by solar panels increase. - People will be fitter, happier, more producive and more imaginative and with free time to plant trees also.
- raverbashing 14y agoIf they work 4h/day it's still 10 commutes per week So instead make them work 8h/3days (or 2.5days if you'd rather) then you only have 6 commutes per week Or just work remotely
- capisce 14y agoCommutes are less mentally draining if you're riding a bike though, you'll actually gain energy for working on challenging problems instead.
- SunboX 14y agoSimple plan? Woman should take men that respect our environment and don't eat much meat. Problem solved after some years - evolution for the rescue
- Not2shabby 14y agoThere was an old lady who swallowed a fly. I don't know why she swallowed a fly. I guess she'll die.
- kunai 14y agoGreat. First pesticides, and now this. No thanks, I don't want to breathe in atomized droplets of highly corrosive acid. I'd rather die from excessive global heat than live with the unknown ramifications of injecting the earth with acid. The actual plan is preposterous, as well. It's clear that Keith has little understanding of the details of his plan and whether it even stands a chance at working, because there is absolutely no scientific methodology at play here. Where is the evidence? There has been no citation of any source that confirms his assumptions. Where are the small-scale trials? How does someone just take jets to the atmosphere and spray it full of sulfur without even knowing the ramifications? When people were testing nuclear power plants for the first time, they made sure to do so in a controlled environment. Crossing your fingers and carrying out a very complex procedure for the first time in an uncontrolled environment without knowing anything beforehand is not only remarkably stupid, but it's also very dangerous. Currently, we're in a safe zone with regards to climate change. If we increase the number of carbon sinks, and if everyone switches to electric cars tomorrow and aircraft start using cleaner-burning biofuels with low NOx and CO2 emissions, we can decrease our carbon footprint by a large amount. Planting a lot of trees and stopping deforestation can compensate for the amount of carbon in our atmosphere already. Also, investing more time and money into alternative energy isn't a bad idea. Turbines have been around for centuries; it's about time we started using more of them. Solar power is advancing very quickly and could really offer a good source of electric power. If every state had 10 windfarms and 10 solar power plants, then we could be self-sustaining for as long as the Sun doesn't implode. A shame, though, that our bureaucratic government would rather invest money into restricting freedom rather than invest money to better our world. It's also a shame that people will be too selfish to give up their hydrocarbon-burning cars and vehicles.