14 ms·
"Another common chemical name for methotrexate is amethopterin, which comes from the roots meth, Greek for wine, which I might stretch to spirits, and pterin, G
by Alex3917 14y ago
"Another common chemical name for methotrexate is amethopterin, which comes from the roots meth, Greek for wine, which I might stretch to spirits, and pterin, Greek for feathers."
Except for it's ameth, which would mean lack of intoxication, a la 'amethyst'.
In fact the whole article is complete BS as it doesn't even remotely align with the views the author presents in the original article -- nowhere does the author say that she is 'chemophobic', nor is this even hinted at beyond her saying that her husband has always been "more comfortable with pharmaceuticals, more trusting in general." And of course naturopathic medicine is going to seem like pure evil if you're willfully blinding yourself to the arguments in its favor and only seeing the (legitimate) weaknesses, as will anything else for that matter.
- InclinedPlane 14y agoExcept the NYT magazine article author makes it quite clear that she is chemophobic, with repeated statements about her fear. Here's a direct quote: "It reinforced an image of Shepherd as sick, forever dependent on a drug I felt afraid of, however unreasonable a doctor might tell me that fear was." Similarly, when a doctor suggests increasing the dose of methotrexate she panics.
- Alex3917 14y agoI guess I still don't see anything there that could be construed as 'chemophobia'. She doesn't want her kid to self-identify as sick or to die of liver failure. I don't see how either of these concerns are crazy or anti-technology or whatever. Especially since in the beginning she says she was excited about the diagnosis because it meant they could try different drugs.
- carbocation 14y agoIs there objective evidence that any element of naturopathic medicine has consistent, reproducible, positive value?
- Alex3917 14y agoBy element do you mean a specific plant or the broader principles of naturopathy?
- carbocation 14y agoI guess I'm thinking specific interventions, whether botanical or otherwise.
- Alex3917 14y agoHere is one example, marijuana for muscle spasticity: http://blog.norml.org/2010/02/17/%E2%80%98gold-standard%E2%80%99-studies-show-that-inhaled-marijuana-is-medically-safe-and-effective/ http://blog.norml.org/2010/02/17/%E2%80%98gold-standard%E2%8... The vast majority of commonly used plant medicines have undergone at least some scientific testing. The efficacy of specific drugs for specific conditions varies from extremely beneficial to completely useless or outright dangerous, the same as with any other medicine. And as with other medicines there are a lot of gaps and uncertainties in the research, although with plant medicines its usually because of lack of funding rather than because of bias stemming from the funding mechanisms.
- carbocation 14y agoInteresting, but marijuana is used in standard modern medicine already. Any examples of things not used by modern medicine that are shown to have efficacy? Do you have a source to support the concept that the problem with plant medicine is the lack of funding in the face of promising early studies?
- Alex3917 14y ago"Interesting, but marijuana is used in standard modern medicine already." First, marijuana is still illegal for doctors to prescribe in all 50 states, so saying that it's already used in modern medicine is a bit dubious. Any examples of things not used by modern medicine that are shown to have efficacy?" This largely depends on how you define 'modern medicine' and 'have shown efficacy'. E.g. modern as in modernism, or modern just meaning anything that's currently widely used? Because if you're defining modern in terms of modernism, which would be the most natural use of the word, then by definition no plant medicine can ever be part of modern medicine since it goes against everything that modernity stands for. If on the other hand you're defining modernism as anything that's currently widely used as part of medicine, then you get into the issue of widely used by who? In any event I'm going to take a pass on answering that only because I think it's largely a moot point to begin with, as I was only arguing that naturopathy can be useful and not that it is never used by 'modern' medicine (however you define it). "Do you have a source to support the concept that the problem with plant medicine is the lack of funding in the face of promising early studies?" So lack of funding is only one of the problems. Another big problem is 'blobology', which Willoughby Britton explains here: http://www.buddhistgeeks.com/2012/10/bg-266-mindful-binge-drinking-and-blobology/ http://www.buddhistgeeks.com/2012/10/bg-266-mindful-binge-dr... The basic concept is that every study is looking at something a little bit different, so even if there are hundreds of studies on some medicine and they are all positive, it still isn't necessarily conclusive. If you google for studies on the efficacy of, say, aloe vera for treating burns, you will see that pretty easily. And it shows up pretty widely, as it's just a problem that's inherent with science right now. I haven't taken the time to find a great source for funding specific stuff, but just a quick Google search shows that total US biomedical research spending is about 94 billion as of 2003, and the total NIH grants for CAM research (so not just naturopathy) are 441 million. (And presumably the amount of commercial research done on naturopathy is almost zero since plants can't be patented.)