8 ms·
Yadda yadda yadda, doesn't matter. When people buy a laptop they expect the OS will take up a good chunk of the storage space. When people buy a tablet they do
by InclinedPlane 14y ago
Yadda yadda yadda, doesn't matter.
When people buy a laptop they expect the OS will take up a good chunk of the storage space. When people buy a tablet they don't have that expectation.
More importantly, when the free space is significantly less than half the advertized storage and there is no warning that's the case people are going to be surprized and upset, and rightfully so.
In a Macbook Air the worst you get is a reduction to about 70-75% of the listed storage capacity (in the 128 or 64 gb models), which is annoying but not crazy. In the Surface Pro 64 model you are reduced to about 1/3 of the initial capacity, which is ridiculous and definitely deserves some sort of warning on the packaging, I would think. Expecting a reduction by 1/4 is reasonable common sense, experiencing a reduction by 2/3 is surprising.
- jimktrains2 14y ago>When people buy a laoptop they expect the OS will take up a good chunk of the storage space.[sic] Why? My linux install has a full dev environment and office suite and doesn't take a ton of room.
- mikeash 14y agoPeople's expectations aren't based on your Linux install.
- jimktrains2 14y agoI just meant there is no reason the OS needs to be so large.
- mikeash 14y agoCertainly, but the OSes that people typically encounter are, so they expect that because it's what they see.
- gcr 14y agoIsn't that a problem that we should address? Users expect their office suites to crash, but that doesn't mean that we as developers shouldn't be constantly trying to improve our code.
- criley 14y agoIn my experience, I only ever get crashes with LibreOffice. I can't honestly remember a MS Office crash for me since the 2003 version. Are people honestly getting regular office suite crashes?
- stcredzero 14y agoAside from Linux, you mean?
- criley 14y agoSorry, yeah I've been using W7 since beta and now W8. I don't know what kind of crashes happen on Linux with office software.
- gcr 14y agoLinux user. LibreOffice on linux....feels like it's been getting better. It doesn't crash "very much" any more, maybe once every two months for me. I don't use MS Office on windows much, so I can't comment on its stability.
- lostlogin 14y agoEver tried getting word docs into Indesign without converting to RTF as an interim step? This may not be a MS problem and may be Adobes fault, but whenever I get a .doc, importing into indesign directly makes my life miserable for too often. Even if it doesn't crash Indesign, it often causes strange behaviour and bizarre formatting issues. Between that and the damn paper clip wizard man of old, my Office suite tolerance is about zero. But LibreOffice, ouch. After this last week, one more 'java update required' popup and I might start crying. I DID IT 1 MINUTE AGO.
- InclinedPlane 14y agoThere are plenty of reasons, but the question is whether or not they are good reasons. A Windows install, for example, will have lots of pre-cached drivers, a crap-ton of little utility programs, several pre-installed libraries and frameworks (.net, vb6, etc.), and a VM for running 32-bit apps. All of these things provide valuable features for the OS. Now, on top of that there is certainly plenty of bloat, and in many instances linux has simply approached these same problems differently. For example by installing shared libraries on demand via the internet through a package management system, or by simply having poorer hardware and cross-architecture support (zing!), or by having a vast ecosystem of open source tools available so that it's always possible to install something via a native compilation. Those are good choices for the linux way of doing things but they certainly come with tradeoffs. P.S. Linux should be installable on the Surface Pro, so if the hardware intrigues anyone it might be worthwhile to see how it fares with a different OS.
- monochromatic 14y agoNo reason at all? Microsoft and Apple just do it out of spite, I guess.
- ishansharma 14y agoExactly. With laptops, reduction of 20-30 GB is already expected. But not so much with tablets. However, we are also ignoring the fact that its whole Windows 8 there on Surface unlike mobile only iOS which is ~1 GB.
- Negitivefrags 14y ago> When people buy a tablet they don't have that expectation. Well perhaps they should have that expectation, because the reality is no different on Apple phones or tablets. My 16GB iPhone should have 15.25GB of space (16 billion bytes), but it doesn't. It's formatted capacity is 13.7 GB.
- SquareWheel 14y agoI disagree, desktops and tablets should advertise their usable space. The true drive space should still be available on the spec sheet, but usable space should be the main highlight.
- Negitivefrags 14y agoYes, they should do that. The reality is that they don't and tablets and phones are no better though.
- hessenwolf 14y agoAnd home broadband providers should advertise their contention rates. And, if that starter is free with the main course, I'll just have the starter free on its own please.
- frobozz 14y agoDisk space has a history of misleading sizing, with 1 "MB" often meaning 1000 KiB, and 1 "GB" seeming to mean any combination of decimal and binary multipliers between 1GB and 1GiB (Including 1000 "MB", which might itself be something between 1 MB and 1 MiB). Given that mess, I can't see the marketeers taking the trouble to distinguish between total and free space. The first company to honestly advertise the space on their device in the manner you describe will miss out on sales due to poorly written (or poorly understood) comparison tables.
- lostlogin 14y agoCan I add to that and say that the device should also carry a price tag that reflects what will come out my pocket. That happens where I live, but I went to San Francisco recently and when buying found that the price tag excludes tax. What? What's the price tag for then? Make the writing on the label reflect what I give and what I get.
- guelo 14y agoShit Apple fanboys say: 3/4ths is totally reasonable. 2/3rds is outrageous!
- InclinedPlane 14y agoI don't personally own any apple products. Also, pay more attention. It's 3/4 remaining vs. 2/3 taken, or 3/4 vs 1/3.
- overcyn 14y agoYoure mixing up the fractions. 64gb mba, 48gb free ~ 3/4ths 64gb surface, 23gb free ~ 1/3rd
- _Simon 14y agoI've no skin in this. To be honest its an article by someone that has a track record for being economic with facts and it's on ZDnet, which is good enough reason to ignore it. However I don't see so much "fanboys" (please don't, it's childish), as people desperately trying to prove the authors point. I'd suggest at this stage and as a neutral the exact opposite is the case.
- scholia 14y agoYou're wrong. Ed Bott has a track record of being very accurate with the facts. You are, of course, welcome to produce some bulletproof factual examples (since you have just shown your opinions are not worth anything) to prove otherwise.
- _Simon 14y agoCalm down. He has been paid by Microsoft in the past so his opinions are hardly partisan and being economic with facts means that he often tells half a story, generally Microsofts. Like I said, I don't care either way, what I do care about is needless name calling and veiled ad hominems.
- telcodud 14y ago