7 ms·
And herein lies the problem with Go. Seriously, try searching for articles about Go on HN. People always say "well the name isn't a problem, because you just se
by freehunter 14y ago
And herein lies the problem with Go. Seriously, try searching for articles about Go on HN. People always say "well the name isn't a problem, because you just search for it with "golang" instead!" but no one writes golang unless they're pointing out how to search for it. If I was trying to get back to this article a month from now and I searched for "go", would I find it? Probably not, unless I remembered the article title contained the word "assembly", but then I'm matching a search to assembly and not Go.
The name is a problem. And if the name is not a problem, then the community is a problem.
- bthomas 14y agoI'd imagine Google recognizes you're a programmer and modifies your results for "go" accordingly
- muyuu 14y agoIt doesn't. Well, considering how hard I try not to be tracked by Google, probably it does for someone else.
- nextparadigms 14y agoWould you say the HN search is a "good one"? And who would search for Go just by typing go in a search bar? Would you really do that on Google? I don't even do that for less common words, let alone one like "go". I usually use 3-4 words for my queries, maybe more. Because I have a pretty good idea of what I'm looking for and I don't want to waste time looking into pages of search results to find the relevant article, because I only searched for one word.
- Jabbles 14y agoWell, I'm glad to hear you don't have any substantial complaints about the language. What exactly are you searching for? Perhaps I can help you... http://lmgtfy.com/?q=site%3Anews.ycombinator.com+go http://lmgtfy.com/?q=site%3Anews.ycombinator.com+go Did you even try? (For those that have experience using Google, the search results are: http://goo.gl/fqNiC http://goo.gl/fqNiC )
- caligo 14y agoC has a bit of a problem with search as well. There is C, C++ Obj-C and C# which all tend to come up in searches. And that is excluding things that can be avoided with additional key words in searches, such as C the default drive on Windows and C as in City Group.
- dualogy 14y ago[[[EDIT: wrote this little rant before realizing you specifically refer to HN search rather than general search. Yeah why would I ever search on a specific Go topic exclusively on HN, instead of web-searching?]]] Every time a Go article comes up, the "name searchability" discussion comes up. Go's been around for some 4-5 years now, can we all come to terms with its name? Somehow whenever brainfuck-lang threads show up, this issue is never raised, but surely might exist just the same? What about Perl (a common word), or Basic (even more basic), heck "C" (a freakin' letter). Is that so much better for searchability? Rust -- a common word. D -- a freakin' letter. Miranda -- a language but also the name of 100s of townships, an IM client etc etc. Go is not the first language to have this "problem", and in fair daily practice it never ever is a problem. Because you never search for Go, you search for "Go channels" or "Go image processing" or "Go GTK binding" or "Go compiler error X" etc. etc. Like you would for all these other fine examples of oddly named languages. And somehow, Google is semantically smart enough to present a few decent matches among the first 10, even with all your personalization & tracking cookies etc. etc. disabled. So... problem? Herin lies the problem with Go? Seriously... it's just not a big freaking deal getting in the way of getting stuff done. Promised.
- TylerE 14y agoYour examples make no real sense, other than "Basic". Perl is absolutely NOT a common word. Pearl is common, but Perl is the programming language (only)
- dualogy 14y agozOMG you're right re pearl -- I'm kinda shocked at myself right now. In my defense, in German it's "Perle" so not that different... OK scratch the Perl example. Still standing by my point: it's a "problem" shared by many languages and it's not a problem in the first place.
- TylerE 14y agoI found a list of English words by frequecy of use in Project Gutenberg texts. "Basic" is around #9,500. "Rust" is ~#10,950 "Java" doesn't appear at all (List goes out to 40,000) (Admittedly, somewhat biased by the dated-ness of the material, but it's still not a common one.) Go is #106, and modern lists based on contemporary sources place it in the top 50 most used English words.
- songgao 14y agoAccording to golang FAQ, the origin of the name is that, “Ogle” would be a good name for a Go debugger. [1] I just came up the idea: why didn't they name the language "Goo", and leave "Gle" to the debugger? It would be more common for people to refer to the language itself than to its debugger. [1] http://golang.org/doc/faq#What_is_the_origin_of_the_name http://golang.org/doc/faq#What_is_the_origin_of_the_name
- jerf 14y agoWell, Go is a dynamic name, a verb, it evokes travel, motion, activity. Goo is a very static name evoking "slimy", "disgusting", and also, "useless for building things". I don't think Goo is a very name for a computer language. Then again... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goo_%28programming_language%29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goo_%28programming_language%29 , although the homepage http://people.csail.mit.edu/jrb/goo/ http://people.csail.mit.edu/jrb/goo/ suggests that that sort of thinking is not really in Goo's pedigree... even for 2003 that's not a pretty page.
- jholman 14y agoI think you should consider the possibility that the FAQ is joking. Also, if you're suggesting "gle" as a debugger name, you're missing the joke. "ogle" is a verb meaning, approximately, "to look at", so it's a good name for a debugger. "gle" is not. (Except that "ogle" is not actually a good name for a corporate-sponsored debugger, because "ogle" has sexual connotations. Which is why you should assume that this is a joke.)
- songgao 14y agoI didn't know that! Thanks :-)
- coldtea 14y ago>Seriously, try searching for articles about Go on HN. Well, either "site:news.ycombinator.com go" or " "site:news.ycombinator.com golang" work very well for me, getting tons of results. What exactly was the problem again? If you don't find as many articles on Go as you would like it's because there just aren't that many. It's a relatively new language, without much of a user base yet. Heck, it only has 3-4 books out on it.
- scott_s 14y agoI didn't even have to use that Google feature. "go hacker news" works great.
- morhus 14y agojust type go language, go programming
- naner 14y agoYes, the name can be difficult to search for. Same with C. Nothing is going to be done about it so most of us have moved on. Also, it is pretty easy to find this story by searching for 'go' in the HN search box. You can further reduce results by selecting 'Stories' and search by date. So in practice it is not a big deal.
- tomp 14y ago"C" might be even shorter, but I think it's much less frequent in the english language (as a word) than the word "go".
- tptacek 14y agoThe name "Go" is a problem, but the name "C" isn't? Silly.
- anon1385 14y agoWho said the name "C" isn't a problem?
- tptacek 14y agoI do indeed have the impression that anyone who would bring up Golang's name as a serious flaw would also believe that C's name has held it back as well.
- chc 14y agoWell, you're a bit mistaken. There are a couple of reasons why this isn't the case: 1. C was already pretty much the programming language by the time the Web took off, so it had an inherent advantage in Googlability due to its popularity. 2. The letter C does not tend to be used by itself as often or as widely as the word "go," so even if C hadn't already had an unfair advantage, it would have less of a problem just on this basis. The odds that an arbitrary programming article unrelated to C will have "C" scattered about are not all that great. The odds that an arbitrary programming article unrelated to Go will use the word "go" are actually pretty decent. Put another way, "Go" is a more common word than "C," so it generates more noise. I don't find this issue to be all that problematic anymore since the search engines seem to have learned that "go" in conjunction with programming terms indicates an interest in Go-centric material, but I did find it vexing when Go was younger and I was first trying to learn it.
- emmelaich 14y agoC and R used to be hard to search for, but these days Google search does brilliantly given a bit of context. If Go is hard to search for now, be sure it will get better. I do wish they had chosen a different name, but I realise it matters less and less.
- jlgreco 14y agoHonestly R is still a pain in the ass to search for, much more-so than Go currently is. This might be a fluke of my personalized google search results though.