3 ms·
Couple thoughts: * there was an earlier thread on touch screens in laptops, the surface thread, and I stated I have the Lenovo tablet laptop with touchscreen a
by samstave 14y ago
Couple thoughts:
* there was an earlier thread on touch screens in laptops, the surface thread, and I stated I have the Lenovo tablet laptop with touchscreen and it is horrible and I don't like it.
I work with lots of visual docs, from visio, PDF acad plans, acad itself and revit. Not once have I wanted to interact with any of these documents via touch.
We have a few plan-grid users in the office and that works kinda ok - but not on a laptop.
* I bought a chromebook for my mom, and I lamented here on HN about how it lacked features and the UX was very clunky.
This thing is going to likely wind up in the iPad price range, and I am suspicious it's experience will be some weird limbo between a full OS laptop and a fully purpose built tablet.
I want this to succeed, but I feel that the chromebook, with almost zero functionality without access to the Internet is shortsighted in the depth and sophistication (savvy) users need from their devices.
While "we" (my wife and I) have an iPad, "I" do not have one; I find the iPad too one dimensional for the majority of what I need to do. Using robust and nimble applications for work, light gaming and heavy web content consumption.
I typically have multiple browser containers open with upto 20 tabs in each.
For light browsing, I use my phone - as I am now to type this.
This video showed a person clicking a CGI jellyfish to change its color. Ok, zero utility and the spark of coolness lasted about a nanosecond.
The only thing semi-inspirational said in the video was also very scary: 4 million of these pixels create a new world.
This statement leads me to believe this is a hardware wrapper to G+, is a google encased physical portal into their total information awareness about your individual, and the pixels overall communal, online use.
This makes it sound liberating - but this is actually a digital prison.
Finally, it's a me too ad in response to Apple trying to tout "completely designed by google".
Don't get me wrong, I love lots of things about google, most things actually - but what I will never trust about google or any other company is that they are working in my interest.
So, people will find this useful, and interesting - but this ad showed me very little to convince me that my computing experience is about to evolve into anything other than a benefit for googles information indexing leviathan, let alone become something completely better.
- jjcm 14y agoYou're right in that Google isn't working in your best interest, they're working towards the interest of all of their users. While touch isn't ideal for your use cases, it may be for some. Touch is a pretty bad modality for content creation, but it's very good for casual use/content consumption. You seem to be heavily putting down this laptop because it's touch enabled. It's simply another feature, at the end of the day this is still a laptop. It's not a negative to have it be there - it barely increases the cost of materials/construction. Was it a pretty boring/generic ad? Sure. Does it present anything that we haven't seen before? No, not really. But at the end of the day, it's cool to see Google pursuing new hardware ventures. The nexus line is absolutely fantastic, I would love to see that level of quality in a laptop, even if the laptop is only a netbook.
- samstave 14y agoSure, I recognize that they aren't necessarily looking at my specific use case with this; what I am also saying is that I believe the depth of the use case scenario pool for touch screen laptops to be fairly shallow. Further, as a chromebook owner, I also am putting down the overall concept from a freedom of capability standpoint. While I am not putting down the engineering, aesthetics, and great job they did in crewing the chrome book, I think it is a mistake in thinking that a node on a point cloud is going to provide you the experience you have with a laptop. You may say "well that's obvious" So, assume that you agree with that, then, where are we heading with this: we still need a phone, a laptop/desktop, potentially another true tablet. So we are fragmenting the depth of information interaction and creation between all these devices. There are solid use cases for each class of device - but if we look at this device-scape further we realize we are building walls around particular behaviors. One might say: this is perfect for a teen user, kids, casual consumption at home. We already have devices that fit that need, so this just may further deepen the divide. One should start to think of google and Facebook and others along the lines of a television channel. (It's a weak analogy, but hear me out): Basically, we only have so much time per day to spend our attention. We are dividing that attention up between not only multiple services, but also multiple devices. We wind up with devices that we spend a bunch of time on that can be seen as more built for consumption than production. Honestly, if this box were focused on education then it would be much better. Rather than show me clicking a cgi jellyfish - show me a device that will create an instant adhoc classroom with many students. Click on a menu of topics, and show me classes hosted by teachers in that area, and connect me with the other students interested in that topic which are close to me, close to my age etc. If you're going to create a point cloud of devices - then think of all the things that could potentially tie those points into groups and provide an experience around that.
- joshred 14y agoI have a chromebook, a laptop and a desktop. I go to the Chromebook when I need something light and portable. The laptop is collecting dust.
- 14y ago