4 ms·
Incidentally, this is exhibit A in Orwellian political redefinition. Instead of using the plain meaning of a word, you load it with political assumptions based
by philwelch 14y ago
Incidentally, this is exhibit A in Orwellian political redefinition. Instead of using the plain meaning of a word, you load it with political assumptions based on your manichean worldview so any word with a bad connotation cannot be applied to your side.
"You can't be sexist against men" is a classic Orwellian contradiction in that (by the plain meaning of the term) it itself is a sexist statement while simultaneously reinforcing this redefinition. It is so blatantly self-refuting that I'd long assumed it to be some kind of straw man, not something feminists actually said.
- steveklabnik 14y agoCool story bro. (I've seen you comment on these stories before, and I know I'm not going to get anywhere with you, so know that I'm just choosing not to respond to you.)
- philwelch 14y agoIt's fine if you don't respond--the strange thing about ideologies is that any two followers of them are largely interchangeable due to the lack of original thought involved. Given recent events though, I'm surprised you're still going around setting yourself up as some type of moral authority. Someone who bullies women programmers doesn't really have much credibility on this issue, does he?
- qohen 14y ago> Someone who bullies women programmers Whoa...slow down there, hoss. Steve explained that his tweet about @harthur's replace utility was not meant to disparage its author, or its code, but was meant to express his feelings about Node (i.e. the ecosystem for which replace was written). And, he apologized, "unequivocably", for the fact that his tweet had caused pain to @harthur: http://blog.steveklabnik.com/posts/2013-01-23-node http://blog.steveklabnik.com/posts/2013-01-23-node And, @harthur then said this in a followup to her original post, http://harthur.wordpress.com/2013/02/01/open-source-rocks-follow-up/ http://harthur.wordpress.com/2013/02/01/open-source-rocks-fo... My last blog post was quite a downer, so I want to do a short follow up for posterity. First of all, there were some nice responses to it from Steve Klabnik and especially Corey Haines, who gave a very sincere straight-up apology. Several people have told me they are usually very nice, so keep that in mind. So, your characterization appears to be incorrect and unfair.
- qohen 14y ago(In fact, the only thing Steve perhaps can be criticized for, in my view, is for using the word, "unequivocably" -- which is non-standard -- instead of, "unequivocally", when writing his apology. :-) http://english.stackexchange.com/questions/69930/unequivocably-vs-unequivocally http://english.stackexchange.com/questions/69930/unequivocab... )
- steveklabnik 14y agoThanks. I just can't type. Fixing. (I didn't even know that people said 'unequivocably.')
- philwelch 14y agoIntentions don't matter. I'm glad harthur was magnanimous enough to accept the apology, but that doesn't really change much.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- jeffcutsinger 14y agoIncidentally, this is Hitlerian argumentation style. Instead of making a straightforward argument, you load it with emotional baggage to support your Stalinesque worldview.
- philwelch 14y agoAdmittedly, if you haven't read 1984 the Orwell reference probably went over your head. "Manichean" is a word you should just look up, as it is quite useful.
- jeffcutsinger 14y ago> Admittedly, if you haven't read 1984 the Orwell reference probably went over your head. Thanks for pointing this out. I did go through high school, so I'm hip to your extremely erudite reference. > "Manichean" is a word you should just look up, as it is quite useful. Really. I don't find much use for it. Maybe if I just spent more time virtuously casting my opponents as evil users of "Orwellian" tactics, I could also point out that _their_ worldview is manichean.
- philwelch 14y agoI guess I should have known you wouldn't have anything useful to say when you started off by comparing me to Hitler.
- cobrausn 14y agoHitler and Stalin reference in one comment! Surely there is some kind of achievement for that.
- benblack 14y agoThat you are unable to distinguish between an instance of sexual discrimination (called sexual discrimination) and systemic sexual discrimination (called sexism) does not mean anything political or Orwellian is afoot. Words have meanings. Ignorance of the meanings of words is easily solved. Stubborn refusal to recognize your own errors is rather less so.
- svlasits 14y ago+9000 Cause upvoting this comment just isn't enough.
- philwelch 14y agoI don't accept redefinitions of words that pack in political assumptions. Lots of people use "socialist" to mean "anyone to the left of Ronald Reagan" but we have no problem dismissing that as biased hyperbole. What you're essentially doing is trying to pack into the word "sexism" the notion that everything in society is systemically biased in favor of men, at the expense of women. But rather than establishing and defending that notion, you pack it in as an unquestioned assumption so that you don't have to defend it explicitly. As a result, you deliberately minimize any injustices suffered by men to the benefit of women, implicitly saying that it doesn't matter as much when a man faces sexual discrimination. Again, you could simply argue this point explicitly, but for some reason you're trying to pack it into your language. Steve Klabnik's point, stated explicitly, would be something like this: "that instance of sexual discrimination against men, in favor of women, doesn't really count for much, because on aggregate, society still discriminates against women in favor of men." As far as I can tell that's what he meant, and it's even a defensible argument from a feminist perspective, but it also lays bare a lot of assumptions that not everyone might agree with, so it's couched in the superficial form of a semantic argument. This not only makes the controversial premises of the argument easier to swallow, but renders them in a form of a simple factual claim giving the illusion of certitude. As far as the scope of this discussion is concerned, I don't have a problem with Mr. Klabnik's point, but simply the dishonest way he expresses it.
- king_jester 14y ago