3 ms·
Here we are still mucking about in the echoes of the late 19th century trying to make these outmoded models work, in education, in politics, in the workplace. T
by InclinedPlane 14y ago
Here we are still mucking about in the echoes of the late 19th century trying to make these outmoded models work, in education, in politics, in the workplace. There is too much inertia due to power dynamics and due to government control, things won't change until people start proving there are better ways.
- sliverstorm 14y agoOk, what is the model you are envisioning then? There aren't many other structural models I'm aware of. Are you thinking modern companies should be more like Valve, perhaps, which are very flat instead of hierarchical? This works great for Valve, but they do cherry-pick veterans of their respective trades. I know the "flat" model is enticing, but I have yet to see an example that handles greenhorns well.
- InclinedPlane 14y agoIf I had a sure fire management model that was objectively superior and worked in almost all circumstances I wouldn't be talking about the problem I'd be off making money with it or proselytizing. I have many solid arguments as to why the current system, which really is rather feudal, is broken and could not possibly represent the apex of management systems. I also have a few good ideas about alternate systems. However, that would make for quite too long of a discussion here, so I'll save it for some other time/place. Nevertheless, I will point out that if there is a solid trend as it relates to the impact of the progression of networking technology and software in general it is that both have a tendency toward disintermediation. And if there is one intermediary who is oh so very ripe for being kicked into the gutter it is certainly the middle manager. How do we get along without him/her? To my ears such a question has the ring of "how will we get along without cholera?" So, here's some bullet points: greater individual autonomy/responsibility/return (e.g. profit sharing & equity); more peer relationships and fewer superior/insubordinate relationships (though not the absence of such), note carefully that this is not identical to a flatter hierarchy; more freelance-style and partnership relationships (whether across or within corporate boundaries); more reliance on leads instead of managers; more mentor/apprentice style relationships. In general the "employer/employee" relationship being closer to a partnership that both have entered into freely and with respect for the other party with the expectation of mutual benefit resulting rather than a coercive, unequal, and authoritarian bond that employment often imitates today.
- redblacktree 14y agoWhat system do you think will work better, assuming we can overcome this inertia?